3 ms·
"But the soldier pays the biggest part of the bill" I'm not sure how it was in Butler's time, but I've read that the overwhelming majority of casualties in mod
by pmoriarty 10y ago
"But the soldier pays the biggest part of the bill"
I'm not sure how it was in Butler's time, but I've read that the overwhelming
majority of casualties in modern warfare are civilians. It would seem to me that
they are the ones who pay "the biggest part of the bill".
Not that I would deny that the people doing the mass murder can themselves become
the victims of war. But I'd personally have more sympathy for civilians who are not
trying to murder others but are themselves murdered.
- ajdlinux 10y agoMy recollection from history class was that the proportion of civilian:military deaths in war in the 2000s is basically the inverse of how it was in the early 1900s.
- Teever 10y agoThe ration between soldier deaths vs civilian deaths has grown tremendously since Butler's time. But more importantly back then American soldiers were conscripted and forced to fight against their will.
- pmoriarty 10y agoIt is debatable whether one can do anything at all against one's will. In regards to conscription in the US, one could always refuse and go to jail. Also, I believe even then there was such a thing as a conscientious objector.
- jnbiche 10y ago> In regards to conscription in the US, one could always refuse and go to jail. What about going to jail against one's will? Can you refuse to do that? That doesn't seem so debatable.
- pmoriarty 10y agoEven then you can refuse to cooperate. You might be shot or might be bodily dragged to jail, but you still have a choice to cooperate or not, to resist or not.
- marvin 10y agoSo you're saying that if you refuse to go to war, are threatened with being killed and then go to war, you are in fact going to war voluntarily? That sounds like a rather philosophical interpretation of "of your own free will".
- pmoriarty 10y agoI'm saying that I recognize that there is coercion, but also that you have a choice. Those that are ordered to do something and do it choose to do so. But they could have chosen otherwise and faced the consequences. In fact, many in the past have done just that. It's disingenuous to say they didn't have a choice or they did it against their will, for if they really willed otherwise, they could have done otherwise (as demonstrated in the previous paragraph). They may have preferred to do something else, but not enough to actually do anything about it. If you really and truly object to going to war or killing, then don't. You always have that choice. Don't pretend you don't.
- wonder_er 10y agoIn "On Killing" [0], the author argued that WWI troops consistently aimed over the heads of their enemies, in order to avoid ever actually killing someone. This tendency obviously ran counter to the goals of the generals, so after WWII the military devised ways to make the soldiers comfortable with aiming at people. That's just to say - even among active-duty soldiers, there is a spectrum of those willing to kill or not. [0] https://www.amazon.com/Killing-Psychological-Cost-Learning-Society/dp/0316040932 https://www.amazon.com/Killing-Psychological-Cost-Learning-S...
- michaelt 10y agoIt's disingenuous to say they didn't have a choice or they did it against their will If a school bully someone tells me "give me your lunch money or I'll give you a black eye" and I give them my lunch money, would you say I've done so against my will? I would say I had done so against my will - because although I had a choice between two bad options, I was forced to submit to a choice that was structured to deny me the option to do neither.
- lolc 10y agoWith conscription the third option, not going to jail and not joining the army, has been removed forcibly. If I intend to work on my farm but get conscripted I don't get the choice of staying. I will have to leave against my will. Hey choose between joining the army or jail time! It's your free choice so it can't be against your will!
- StanislavPetrov 10y ago"Modern" is a relative term. When Butler was fighting around the turn of the the 19th century in the Philippines and elsewhere, as many(or more) men died from disease, dysentery, and infection then they did "in battle". Many conscripted men died before they ever had the chance to kill someone in the name of empire. It's very unfortunate that this 80 year old polemic by Butler is still radical in this day and age, when so many are chomping at the bit to wage war.
- firethief 10y agoLet's not overlook the toll that murder takes on those pressured and conditioned into being willing and able to do so. PTSD rates among recent Iraq and Afghanistan veterans are about 20% [1]. More veterans commit suicide after coming home than are KIA. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Posttraumatic_stress_disorder#cite_ref-VAscreen_26-4 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Posttraumatic_stress_disorde...
- pmoriarty 10y agoThere's an interesting book related to that, called "On Killing".[1] It's about the psychological conditioning that killers-to-be undergo to actually get them to kill. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/On_Killing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/On_Killing
- danieltillett 10y agoGreat book and I would highly recommend reading it. I am still amazed to learn how difficult it is to get soldiers to kill.
- wz1000 10y agoThis phenomenon was summed up succinctly by Frankie Boyle > Not only will America go to your country and kill all your people, but what's worse I think, is that they'll come back 20 years later and make a movie about how killing your people made their soldiers feel sad. > America making a movie about what Vietnam did to their soldiers is like a serial killer telling you what stopping suddenly for hitchhikers did to his clutch. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uZwuTI-V8SI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uZwuTI-V8SI It's not that PTSD doesn't exist or affect many people, but the scale of the tragedies involved.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoThe US found a solution to this problem and has been testing it for quite some time in Pakistan -- drones don't get PTSD.
- dhaivatpandya 10y ago> I'm not sure how it was in Butler's time, but I've read that the overwhelming majority of casualties in modern warfare are civilians. This may be true, but a soldier probably has a far higher likelihood of dying in a war than a civilian, thereby "paying the bill." This means that in expectation, each individual soldier pays a higher value of the bill in comparison to each individual citizen.
- fsloth 10y agoI'm not sure how it was in Butler's time, but I've read that the overwhelming majority of casualties in modern warfare are civilians. It would seem to me that they are the ones who pay "the biggest part of the bill" Focusing on this aspect is kinda lame since the main point of Butler's message was that someone suffers, and someone else profits, and that military action is generally taken for monetary profit, and not for any higher purpose.
- doug1001 10y agono, Butler has it right. His use of the term "bill" refers to the cost of US participation in war; All of the wars he's talking about took place outside the US, so de minimis US citizen casualties still i would agree, and i bet Gen Butler would as well that civilians suffer the "biggest part of the" damage, but Butler's statement that you quoted was more specific.