3 ms·
Sure. The electoral college needs to go. Pointing to the popular vote can show reinforce how close the vote was. That said, the plurality winner in a system tha
by grzm 10y ago
Sure. The electoral college needs to go. Pointing to the popular vote can show reinforce how close the vote was. That said, the plurality winner in a system that uses the electoral college isn't by itself evidence that the same result would be obtained in an election without the electoral college.
Campaigns are run knowing the electoral votes are what matter. Voters vote knowing the electoral college is in place. We know some voters stay home because of the EC. We also know people trade votes because of the EC.
I repeat: I'm not arguing to keep the electoral college in place. I think it's highly likely it should be removed for a lot of other reasons (disproportionate elector/population ratios being a good one). I'm pushing back on the idea that we'd necessarily see the same result in an election without it.