3 ms·
Ok, wow. My initial take on this article was "This is a crappy piece of journalism which takes some arbitrary facts and tries to use it to criticize millennial
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
Ok, wow.
My initial take on this article was "This is a crappy piece of journalism which takes some arbitrary facts and tries to use it to criticize millennials." My observation is that generally crappy journalism can be easily exposed and lampooned by inverting the headline's wording which doesn't change its meaning but flips its implication. So "3 out of 4 millennials get helped by parents" flipped is "1 out 4 parents of millennials don't help them." The first might be interpreted that millennials are slackers and the other might be that baby boomers are lousy parents. Both implications are unwarranted and wrong. And that is the hallmark of crappy journalism. There is no interpretation of this headline which conveys useful information.
As a parent, and having been around thousands of parents and read many surveys of parents, there is a common theme. The majority of the time they want to help their kids in any way they can. It is instinctual. Further, any assistance parents give their grown children can be interpreted as "financial" assistance, from babysitting the grand children to giving them the old sofa that has been in the basement for the last 10 years. And that in no way reflects on the character of the children, aka the millennials, in this piece.
That said, I never intended to imply that parents who could not help their children should be criticized. My use of the inversion device would have the headline imply that, and I would disagree with a story based on that just as much as I do the current one.
- notacoward 10y ago> "3 out of 4 millennials get helped by parents" flipped is "1 out 4 parents of millennials don't help them." "Don't help them" != "don't care" so that's not inversion. You added that negative implication. Maybe you didn't mean to. I'll take you at your word on that, but attempts to deflect the reaction back to the OP seem disingenuous.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoI am not attempting to deflect reaction, it is real and it is heartfelt and I understand how people reached the conclusion that I was insulting parents who did not provide financial support to their children. I wrote it poorly and had I been talking face to face with someone one I hope I would have seen them getting angry and immediately sought out the disagreement between what I thought I was saying and what was being heard. Here its a bit more difficult and it once again reminded me of that. To your specific criticism, you are correct that I added the connotation. When I read the original title I also added the connotation that "have received financial help" was "are slackers". And I disagreed with that strongly as well. You can receive help from your parents and not be a slacker. And I recognize that for some portion of the people reading here they read my headline inversion literally rather than as a critique because of the lack of context. If I were to rewrite it, it would have started with "I disagree strongly with the implication of the headline, you might as well write 1 in 4 parents don't help their millennial children and I would disagree with that too." And then we could talk about the poorly defined notion of "help" and the question of privilege and whether or not that is an objective thing or a subjective one, and if its objective how do we define it.