4 ms·
Are you equating parents helping their kids with "privileged life" ? I'd certainly agree that people who have no parents have a harder life, but simply having p
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
Are you equating parents helping their kids with "privileged life" ? I'd certainly agree that people who have no parents have a harder life, but simply having parents doesn't seem to rise to the level of privileged that you imply here.
- paulcole 10y ago> Are you equating parents helping their kids with "privileged life" yes, that is like the definition of privilege
- gnud 10y agoBy that definition, 3 out of 4 millenials are priveleged. At that point, I'm not sure it's a useful term any more.
- michaelchisari 10y agoI think it is. All that privilege requires is the existence of the non-privileged or disadvantaged. To give an extreme example, the majority of people in the US don't have to deal with what those who live on reservations have to deal with. That means that the majority of people in the US are privileged in a way that those on a res aren't. I've always thought of the discussion about privilege to be a very American way of talking about human rights. We can't possibly talk about having enough food, housing, safe interactions with the law, etc. as rights, and thus those who don't have that are being denied their basic rights, so instead we talk about those things as privileges that are denied to a segment of population. I would much prefer talk about these things as rights, personally.
- gnud 10y agoWell, sure. Someone getting help from their parents are privileged compared to someone not getting help. The term isn't normally used in this relative sense, though. The oxford dictionary says that privilege is 'a special right, advantage, or immunity granted or available only to a particular person or group'. Something the majority enjoys is not a privilege.
- albedoa 10y agoI don't understand your comment. The term is always used in that relative sense, even in the examples that Oxford gives: Someone who is very rich is privileged compared to someone who is not. Further, no part the definition you quoted restricts a privilege from being enjoyed by the majority.
- km3k 10y agoIt's not a majority of millenials, it's a majority of millenials with six-figure investments. Check the report.
- mindslight 10y ago> We can't possibly talk about having enough food, housing, safe interactions with the law, etc. as rights For housing/food, sure - in the USian context it doesn't make sense to talk about such things as "rights" because they'd have to be provided by somebody else [0]. The existence of life's basic necessities is actually not guaranteed and it is worthwhile to remember that. (However this framework says nothing about the idea of distributing surpluses to people who couldn't otherwise afford it, just that it does not constitute a "right"). But inverting the sense and labeling their presence "privilege" is a completely regressive zero-sum framework, ultimately promulgated by political shills that are more concerned with bolstering their followers rather than actually fixing problems. This is especially clear when talking about things that are rights, like say simply not being murdered (eg by the police). By labeling as "privileged" the people who are just not having their rights violated, the tone is set that they are the exception. The "privileged" group then checks out of the conversation (as they're being told that the problem does not directly concern them), while the ire of the "unprivileged" group is harmlessly directed at the "privileged" group instead of their actual oppressors. [0] It's the distinction between saying whether a "right" to Internet access implies a free basic monthly service, or merely disallowing the possibility that one could be banned from the Internet via governmental action like an explicit law or "private" "three strikes" system.
- douche 10y agoIt's a little disturbing that being a functional, supportive family is labeled as "privileged." But I can't argue against the reality that having two parents who stay married, are not abusive to each other or their children, and are generally functional human beings is something of a luxury.
- dsfyu404ed 10y ago>having two parents who stay married, are not abusive to each other or their children, and are generally functional human beings is something of a luxury. "Functional human being(s)" is the key there. Lots of people who were raised by a single parent, divorced parents or occasionally abusive households turned out fine.
- jonknee 10y agoI think it was probably all the down payment for a house talk.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoProbably, for what it was worth the seller took back a second mortgage, my in-laws loaned us $10,000, we sold all of my Intel stock (about 500 shares), and dropped down to exactly $500 in our checking account to make that work. The interest rate was 12.2% on our mortgage (adjustable) which only adjusted every 6 months by at most 1.5pts and was tied to the LIBOR index. My wife and I are both engineers and were both working (pre-kids) so we made it work and ended up being able to pay off the loan from the in-laws and the seller after just over 2 years (28 months to be exact). But its true, I was only three years out of college and my wife and I lived in a house the bank owned but would let us keep if we kept paying them on time :-)
- km3k 10y agoIf by help you mean financially and aren't including help using their time/talents, then yes. I know a lot of people who would be much better off if their parents could help financially, but their parents could not afford such assistance. Assistance of time/talents is possible too, but not reported on here.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoIt is a spectrum that is for sure. I expect everyone has an internal barometer where financial help flips over from ordinary to extraordinary. If you give your child graduating from college a used car. Is that privileged? Even if that child has $100K in college debt? Or if you pay their air fare to come to Thanksgiving two times after they are out of college, is that privileged? How about you pay their bail to get them out of jail, is that privileged. I disagree with the idea that any financial support means your children are privileged but do agree that there is a level of support at which they are so. In my personal definition I draw the line at things like subsidizing their rent or paying their gas or insurance bills. I would consider someone whose parents supported them to that level as living a privileged life. But as I said, I expect that line is in different places for everyone.