5 ms·
Small towns of 10k? What about the city of hundred thousands? Or the city of millions? Off the top of your head, would you mind speculating as to what % of Amer
by threatofrain 10y ago
Small towns of 10k? What about the city of hundred thousands? Or the city of millions? Off the top of your head, would you mind speculating as to what % of America lives in cities or urban environments?
Are we forgetting that small states and small districts generally get an unjust magnitude of political power? That the gerrymandering game of the last 30 years have favored these small states with small districts? Are all American lives equal or do those who live in cities matter less? The answer is yes. American lives are equal, and those who live in cities are worth less.
Trump did not win the populist victory. Hillary Clinton did. This is twice in recent memory that the majority of the United States was overruled by the minority.
As people criticize Hillary Clinton for arrogantly not visiting states and cities she thought were victories, do people in those states not realize that they get an unjust magnitude of power and influence every time election season rolls around? And that big cities and states basically get zero attention?
And why? Is it because big states like California or Texas are unworthy? Yes, thanks to the structure of American politics and districting. The Texan economy is doing great by the way.
Or did you think that Trump is a populist candidate? So popular that he didn't win the popular vote? Do you believe that Trump will ever win the popular vote?
How long should American voters remember that they were twice denied by minority voices? For how many years ought they bear this stain in their trust in government legitimacy?
- basch 10y ago>This is twice in recent memory that the majority of the United States was overruled by the minority. Which means nothing because they were not playing a popular vote contest. We will never know who would have won, on that day, in a pure popular vote contest. Winning the popular vote and losing the contest means you miscalculated, and misprovisioned your campaign resources, focusing too heavily on areas you already won.
- threatofrain 10y agoThe name of the game that's being played is gerrymandering.
- basch 10y agoHow often do state borders change? How frequently do counties switch states?
- serge2k 10y agoThe problem is that this hasn't been a problem since the late 1800s. It's only in the last few elections that the combination of people moving to cities, polarization of most states, and capping the house have created a situation where you can actually lose the popular vote and still win the presidency (it's always been possible, but it didn't happen for over 100 years for good reason).
- basch 10y agothe electoral college exists to prevent the popular vote from mattering.
- serge2k 10y agoIt also exists to give slave states power and to make the choice of president up to the electors but we don't use it for either of those purposes nowadays. Plus, the number of representatives has been capped since the early 1900s. That serves to take things further away from even.
- basch 10y ago>make the choice of president up to the electors which maybe they should have. >representatives has been capped which should be fixed.
- serge2k 10y agoPeople who live in cities aren't real americans. They are the white collar elite. THey don't deserve votes worth as much as those hard working, blue collar gents in the Heartland of America.
- aclsid 10y agoI should probably point out that the vast majority of people that live in cities could hardly qualify to be called white collar elite.
- r_smart 10y ago>small states and small districts generally get an unjust magnitude of political power The electoral college exists for a reason: precisely to protect the interests of the minority of people who don't live in cities from the whims of those who do. I live in Maine and we recently passed a citizen referendum for a large minimum wage increase in the state. This is almost entirely because of the people in a few population centers. These places will be able to absorb that hike moderately well, but the rural parts of the state are going to get crushed by it, and they're already the poorest parts of the state. It should have been a city ordinance, but was not. >Trump did not win the populist victory. Hillary Clinton did. Both campaigns were strategized around the existence of the electoral college. Winning the popular vote is merely an artifact of the system in place, but holds no real meaning. There's little reason to assume that were the popular vote what actually decided the election that the result of the election would have been different, as the strategies employed by both campaigns would have been different.
- rconti 10y agoYes, both campaigns were strategized around the existence of the electoral college, but that's tweaking at the margins. It doesn't explain a vote difference in the millions.
- r_smart 10y agoHow do you know that? How many republicans in California don't bother voting?
- bduerst 10y agoTrump had the same number of Republicans voting for him as did Mitt Romney, while Clinton had far less Democrats voting than Obama. This idea that there is impact from republicans not voting isn't true, and what happened actually exasperates the popular vote difference.
- r_smart 10y ago