3 ms·
What I see nobody discussing is the very old concept of political cycles - in Greek the term was Kyklos (literally cycles). It has been fairly well documented
by AndrewKemendo 10y ago
What I see nobody discussing is the very old concept of political cycles - in Greek the term was Kyklos (literally cycles).
It has been fairly well documented that societies undergo four distinct phases which repeat:
1. Anarchy 2. Democracy 3. Aristocracy 4. Monarchy
This also matches up with the Strauss-Howe generational theory:
1. High 2. Awakening 3. Unraveling 4. Crisis
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kyklos https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kyklos
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strauss%E2%80%93Howe_generational_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strauss%E2%80%93Howe_generatio...
- dpark 10y ago> It has been fairly well documented Has it? Citing some ancient Greek philosophy hardly counts as good documentation. You also have the cycle mostly reversed.
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoYes, if you read Polybius and the source material for the fourth turning it's pretty well understood. Cycles don't have a start/end...but I'd consider anarchy the starting point for humanity.
- dpark 10y agoNo, you're pushing these as accepted theories when they are not. Strauss-Howe has had quite a bit of criticism and so far as I can tell Kyklos/Anacyclosis seems to have little attention at all except from people interested in historical philosophy. You're also conflating two different theories that don't mesh meaningfully. The Strauss-Howe theory is predicated on complete cycles of ~90 years. I'm utterly confident that the US has not cycled through anarchy, monarchy, aristocracy, and democracy twice.
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoActually, they are so baked into economics that they are overlooked. Sismondi in his development of the business cycle theory, now a fundamental feature of economic theory and thus political theory, cited Polybius frequently. The point is that there are cycles of societal organization that can be demonstrated fairly unambiguously.
- dpark 10y agoIt's one thing to say that social structures show evidence of cyclic behavior. It's another thing entirely to say that it's an accepted fact that every democratic society will inevitably fall to anarchy and be reborn as a monarchy.
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoI mean history is pretty replete with examples...more than enough books have been written on this. Note that the Anarchic period is usually very short and often accompanied by war because people can't figure out how to live without a ruler apparently.
- kilroy123 10y agoReally? I strongly prefer this greek philosophy, Anacyclosis: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anacyclosis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anacyclosis The idea is, there are seven stages of governance for people. 1. Monarchy, 2. Kingship, 3. Tyranny, 4. Aristocracy, 5. Oligarchy, 6. Democracy, and 7. Ochlocracy The cycle just endlessly repeats itself through time.
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoWe're really talking the same thing...as they come from the same school. Point being that there are "natural" cycles to human organization and that recognizing them is important. I don't know if there is a way, or if it's even desirable to stop them.
- kilroy123 10y agoI agree and I think this theory is absolutely correct, and we're seeing it in action right now. I think the US is at the last stage right now. Which very oddly means, North Korea is now closer to democracy than the US is. Hear me out, I think the US is going to have to go back through all the cycles before going back to democracy. Whereas a country like North Korea is further along the cycles.
- nostrademons 10y agoYour link for Kyklos doesn't match up with your summary. Polybdius's description cited on Wikipedia suggests that the cycle is Anarchy -> Monarchy -> Tyranny -> Aristocracy -> Oligarchy -> Democracy -> Anarchy, with each pair forming a basic government + degenerate form of that government and the cycle trending towards greater dispersal of power, until the final degenerate form of democracy (anarchy/mob rule) fails to provide a society at all and a new strong-man emerges to rule it. The Strauss-Howe cycle has a very different mechanism; in particular, the time scales are much shorter (80 years vs. several generations), and the mechanism proposed is each generation's individual childhood/formative experiences rather than interactions & social cohesion between individuals.
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoThis is verbatim from the wiki summary: "According to Polybius, who has the most fully developed version of the cycle, it rotates through the three basic forms of government, democracy, aristocracy, and monarchy" The version you describe is the Anacyclosis, which is equally valid IMO but not what I linked.
- nostrademons 10y agoThat full paragraph: "According to Polybius, who has the most fully developed version of the cycle, it rotates through the three basic forms of government, democracy, aristocracy, and monarchy and the three degenerate forms of each of these governments ochlocracy, oligarchy, and tyranny. Originally society is in anarchy but the strongest figure emerges and sets up a monarchy. The monarch's descendants, who because of their family's power lack virtue, become despots and the monarchy degenerates into a tyranny. Because of the excesses of the ruler the tyranny is overthrown by the leading citizens of the state who set up an aristocracy. They too quickly forget about virtue and the state becomes an oligarchy. These oligarchs are overthrown by the people who set up a democracy. Democracy soon becomes corrupt and degenerates into mob rule, beginning the cycle anew."