20 ms·
How Stable Are Democracies? ‘Warning Signs Are Flashing Red’
- m741 10y agoSomething I've wondered recently: in the past 10-15 years, how many functioning democracies have fallen apart vs been created? I'm fairly ignorant about this, so please correct me if my perceptions ar wrong, but Turkey seems to have devolved to autocracy after being democratic for a while. I've heard scary things about Poland. Venezuela, as mentioned in the article, fell apart. Obviously there's Putin's Russia, though I'm not sure Russia was ever really democratic. I can't think offhand of any new, functioning, democracies.
- TeMPOraL 10y ago> I've heard scary things about Poland. Poland is fine, don't listen to the bullshit in mass media. That was just some noise of little importance to anything whatsoever, perpetuated because the party that lost last elections wasn't too happy about that fact.
- trendia 10y ago> That was just some noise of literally zero importance to aything whatsoever, perpetuated because the party that lost last elections wasn't too happy about that fact. That seems eerily similar to what happened in the US.
- mtgx 10y agoSo the proposal to ban abortions was just a lie? https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/oct/05/polish-government-performs-u-turn-on-total-abortion-ban https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/oct/05/polish-governm... What about the story that Poland is one of the few European countries that want access to encrypted communications? https://www.euractiv.com/section/social-europe-jobs/news/five-member-states-want-eu-wide-laws-on-encryption/ https://www.euractiv.com/section/social-europe-jobs/news/fiv...
- true_religion 10y agoThey proposed a ban and backed down on public pressure. That does not seeem anti democracy.
- nolok 10y agoHow is any of it undemocratic ? If people elect candidates who are anti abortion and pro surveillance, then being democratic means those laws should happen. "Democracy" doesn't mean "they do what you agree with" nor even "they do what's best for their citizen", it means the citizens elects the one they want, even if it's the guy whose policies are so bad he's going to send them backward 20 years.
- scotty79 10y agoIf people elect candidates who are pro-totalitarian surveillance state and limitation of individual freedoms, then being democratic means those laws should happen as well? Basically if people elect candidates that want to kill democracy then the democratic thing would be to let it die?
- AnimalMuppet 10y ago> How is any of it undemocratic ? If people elect candidates who are anti abortion and pro surveillance, then being democratic means those laws should happen. See, this is why the US is supposed to be ruled by a constitution, rather than just be a democracy. The constitution says that there are things you can't do, even if you have a majority (unless you have enough of a majority to amend the constitution). Now, granted, that's been eroded under the last few presidents, with (probably) worse to come under Trump. But this is why it matters that we have a constitution that limits what a president can do.
- int_19h 10y agoWhen people in the West talk about "democracy", what they usually really mean is "liberal democracy".
- TeMPOraL 10y ago> So the proposal to ban abortions was just a lie? Yes. I.e. not the proposal itself, but the stories about it being likely to be implemented - yes. The "Black Protest" thing was a media-inspired panic. > What about the story that Poland is one of the few European countries that want access to encrypted communications? That is indeed worrying, but I don't see anything different here than happens in many other western countries.
- isido 10y agoIn Poland, the ruling party (Party of Law and Justice) is a right-wing, populist party, which has tried to nominate/replace judges and to some extent, control the media. EU is has voiced concerns, but Poland's democratic processes still work, as evidenced in the recent recall of controversial abortion bill. A Similar, but perhaps further evolved situation is in Hungary, where right-wing populists have held the power for quite a long. But even in Hungrary the rulings party's power is not absolute, at the moment, and you don't get thrown into jail for having wrong opinions.
- saboot 10y agoTry RTFA: The government’s attempts to undermine the country’s constitutional tribunal, for instance, set off an investigation by the European Union. The resulting report warned that the government’s actions “endanger not only the rule of law, but also the functioning of the democratic system.”
- TeMPOraL 10y agoI live in Poland, I know this stuff first-hand.
- ianai 10y agoI don't know, but I'm definitely interested. I know nationalism is on a world wide tear.
- nolok 10y agoPoland is still as functioning a democracy as it was 15 years ago. They elected a party that's a bit on the extreme, so what, isn't that how it's supposed to work ? Does Trump's election means american democracy has "fallen appart" ? Turkey is still democratic. Yes, the rule of law is taking massive hits, and yes, Erdogan really wants to be sultan and makes his way there, but so far he has always won in the election in the same way and rules people won with 15 years ago there. He didn't have a 50+% majority of votes to be PM but neither did the torries in the UK. It might go wrong if there are more actions against legislative political opponent. Venezuela went from a pretend democracy where everyone massively voted for the popular charismatic dictator to a pretend democracy where everyone massively dislike the unpopular dictator, nothing fell apart because there was nothing to break there. Russia is a valid case.
- howlin 10y agoTrump's election may very well cause US democracy to "fall apart". He's already signaled that he wants to stifle a free press, and he's made a lot of campaign promises that go against the rule of law. Congress doesn't seem willing to stand up to him, and there are a lot of vacancies in the judiciary that Trump can fill with people more likely to give him a free pass. Trump's greatest enemy in accomplishing his undemocratic agenda is his own incompetence and unfamiliarity with Washington DC politics. He'd be the next Erdogan or Putin if he could be.
- woofyman 10y agoFor example, American flag burning has twice been ruled a first amendment right by the Supreme Court. This morning Tump tweeted: >Nobody should be allowed to burn the American flag - if they do, there must be consequences - perhaps loss of citizenship or year in jail!
- MollyR 10y agoHillary co-sponsored an actual bill called the "the flag protection act". The fact that the democrats and republicans produced such like minded candidates is the more worrying aspect.
- glup 10y ago'Functioning democracies' are probably better thought of as being a gradient rather than a binary property. There are a number of indices of varying regional and temporal scope, e.g. you could look at the Economist Intelligence Unit's Democracy Index for 2006 onward [1]. There's a lot of latent causes that move these indices (e.g., the collapse of the Soviet Union) so theoretical frameworks are useful for understanding the raw data, e.g. Samuel Huntington's 'waves' characterization of democracy [2]. Not saying that this is right, but sometimes it helps to think about the underlying currents. Finally, democracy and liberal institutions are not concomitant... in fact it's sort of a bug in democracy that you can totally democratically dismantle institutions like court systems, press freedoms, and even voting [3]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democracy_Index https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democracy_Index [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third_Wave_Democracy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third_Wave_Democracy [3] http://media.library.ku.edu.tr/reserve/resfall15_16/Sosc116_SEaytac/Week3.pdf http://media.library.ku.edu.tr/reserve/resfall15_16/Sosc116_...
- js8 10y ago> Finally, democracy and liberal institutions are not concomitant... in fact it's sort of a bug in democracy that you can totally democratically dismantle institutions like court systems, press freedoms, and even voting [3]. Actually, I believe that to avoid those Russell-style paradoxes, it should be a rule that the vote must be potentially reversible in the future with the same process. So the decisions like - strip democratic rights to a minority - kill a specific person cannot be democratic. On the other hand, creating a democracy then cannot be democratic decision either. Dismantling press freedoms and courts would still be democratic (in fact, many democratic countries do not have full freedom of speech), as long as people could vote again on the issue (I don't see why they would vote to dismantle it, so it's not a big deal).
- woofyman 10y agoHungary is becoming authoritarian. http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2016/05/22/world/europe/europe-right-wing-austria-hungary.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2016/05/22/world/europe/e... >Viktor Orban and his right-wing Fidesz party, running on a joint list with the K.D.N.P., a Christian Democratic party, have won the last two parliamentary elections in Hungary, worrying many Western leaders about his increasingly authoritarian rule. The party also decisively won in voting for the European Parliament in May 2014. Jobbik, a far-right, anti-immigration, populist and economic protectionist party, won 20 percent of the vote in parliamentary elections in 2014, making it Hungary’s third-largest party. Its policy platform includes holding a referendum on membership in the European Union and a call to “stop hushing up such taboo issues” as “the Zionist Israel’s efforts to dominate Hungary and the world.” Jobbik wants to increase government spending on ethnic Hungarians living abroad and to form a new ministry dedicated to supporting them. In a 2012 bill targeting homosexuals, the party proposed criminalizing the promotion of “sexual deviancy” with prison terms of up to eight years.
- vkou 10y agoRussia was a democracy that, in less then a decade completely fell apart economically. Putin, and the rising price of oil can be credited for stabilizing the country, and largely pulling it out of a dystopian horror show. Freedom and democracy is nice, but having the means to buy bread, and not being robbed and killed by desperate people is even nicer. Edit: I presume the downvotes aren't coming from people who lived in Russia through the 90s.
- scotty79 10y agoIn Poland it's just poor people electing populist leaders and well off people taking their nice and modern country for granted and not bothering to show up at the election or spreading their votes on anti-system small parties because it's rad.
- Chathamization 10y agoSome countries that became more democratic over the past 10-15 years would probably include places like Tunisia, Pakistan, Myanmar, and Georgia (to name a few). It's a complex issue, and like others have pointed out, being democratic isn't a binary switch. Take Turkey, for example - in a country prone to military coups, the most recent military coup failed. Erdogan has autocratic tendencies, but people really do support him and he seems to be in power because of mostly democratic elections.
- clumsysmurf 10y ago"In The Demon in Democracy, Legutko explores the shared objectives between these two political systems, and explains how liberal democracy has over time lurched towards the same goals as communism, albeit without Soviet style brutalality. " Unelected bureaucrats become nonviolent totalitarians. The Demon in Democracy: Totalitarian Temptations in Free Societies https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/1594038635 https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/1594038635
- badsock 10y agoTo take the US as an example, there's about 2.5 million people in the federal civil service - assuming a generous 1:8 ratio of bureaucrats to workers, that's about 300 thousand bureaucrats at just the federal level. I'm guessing you're not proposing that they all be elected.
- HarryHirsch 10y agoUnelected bureaucrats become nonviolent totalitarians. I for once am grateful to the faceless bureaucrat at the FDA who demanded that Theranos submit their device to FDA for appproval. This unnamed fellow is the Stanislav Petrov of medicine.
- int_19h 10y agoOn the other hand, you also have FDA certification process to thank for the Daraprim monopoly and its consequences (like the ability to raise prices 50x). Which is to say, regulation can be good sometimes, and it can be bad sometimes, even when it's the same exact regulation. The trick is to find a balance that is beneficial to all of us overall.
- HarryHirsch 10y agoIt's unfair to pin Daraprim (and stock price movements when a candidate fails Stage 3 trial) on the FDA. They are tasked with safety. Pricing is an issue outside the remit of the FDA, one that most of the civilized world has dealt with successfully, usually through some form of centralized buying.
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoWhat I see nobody discussing is the very old concept of political cycles - in Greek the term was Kyklos (literally cycles). It has been fairly well documented that societies undergo four distinct phases which repeat: 1. Anarchy 2. Democracy 3. Aristocracy 4. Monarchy This also matches up with the Strauss-Howe generational theory: 1. High 2. Awakening 3. Unraveling 4. Crisis [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kyklos https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kyklos [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strauss%E2%80%93Howe_generational_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strauss%E2%80%93Howe_generatio...
- dpark 10y ago> It has been fairly well documented Has it? Citing some ancient Greek philosophy hardly counts as good documentation. You also have the cycle mostly reversed.
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoYes, if you read Polybius and the source material for the fourth turning it's pretty well understood. Cycles don't have a start/end...but I'd consider anarchy the starting point for humanity.
- dpark 10y agoNo, you're pushing these as accepted theories when they are not. Strauss-Howe has had quite a bit of criticism and so far as I can tell Kyklos/Anacyclosis seems to have little attention at all except from people interested in historical philosophy. You're also conflating two different theories that don't mesh meaningfully. The Strauss-Howe theory is predicated on complete cycles of ~90 years. I'm utterly confident that the US has not cycled through anarchy, monarchy, aristocracy, and democracy twice.
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoActually, they are so baked into economics that they are overlooked. Sismondi in his development of the business cycle theory, now a fundamental feature of economic theory and thus political theory, cited Polybius frequently. The point is that there are cycles of societal organization that can be demonstrated fairly unambiguously.
- siavosh 10y agoMy current thought is that corrupted capitalism has corrupted democracies making them unaccountable to the majority of people, leading to a massive and still accelerating level of economic inequality. When this happens all sorts of bad things happen; political monsters, populist demagogues, racism, loss of faith in democratic institutions etc. Leading to people wanting to radically change the system to someone who says they will 'get things done', which has to be outside of the system. These are truly concerning times; in America at least, no one in political power is discussing serious policy proposals to reduce the influence of money in politics and hence address the accelerating transition of wealth from the lower and middle class to a tiny fraction at the very top. This is not a stable course. Even the current president elect despite his populist slogans is going to increase the regressive tax rate based on debunked trickle down economics (what actually helped lead to the current inequality in the 1980s), and wants to eliminate the estate tax all together. Both of these will merely accelerate the current course. No light is visible at the end of the tunnel.
- drewrv 10y agoI think the recent election demonstrated that money doesn't matter that much. Voters actually have power. That's the silver lining to the depressing reality that voters don't care if industry writes regulations, the executive branch tortures people, and the rich pay even less in taxes.
- mi100hael 10y ago> voters don't care if industry writes regulations, the executive branch tortures people, and the rich pay even less in taxes. The irony in your statement is that it's pretty much impossible to tell which candidate those voters you're referring to supported.
- glhaynes 10y agoSeems pretty easy to me.
- 10y ago
- dublinclontarf 10y agoThe NYTimes can't be considered a legitimate publication on issues such as this given their despicable behaviour during and after the US election.
- perardi 10y agoSuch as?
- vkou 10y agoWell, right now, they are currently calling blatant lies by Trump 'unsupported accusations', as opposed to... Well, lies. A month ago, they were completely uncritically shilling for Clinton. How she became the paragon of the left still boggles my mind.
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoWhich seems to be the opposite of the behavior dublinclontarf complained about...
- TheGirondin 10y agoThis very story. They lost the election and suddenly "Warning Signs Are Flashing" for democracy.
- mturmon 10y agoYour claim is inaccurate. The NYT and half the Republican leadership (among others) has rather consistently said this candidate was exceptionally unqualified.
- bduerst 10y agoSomething like 99% of the major newspapers, even those with conservative histories, disavowed Trump as being exceptionally unqualified for president too. http://mediamatters.org/research/2016/11/02/racists-corruption-and-relatives-story-donald-trumps-newspaper-endorsements/214248 http://mediamatters.org/research/2016/11/02/racists-corrupti...
- rm999 10y agoI see this as part of the waning influence of the USA as a world hegemon. The USA and its allies, as a matter of foreign strategy, have propped up secular "democracies" since WWII. This has led to world-wide stability and peace (especially post-cold war, when its sphere of influence expanded into Soviet territory). But, this often involved supporting unpopular and/or autocratic leaders who would maintain a democracy as long as they could overthrow unsuitable leaders (often with covert American help). I think there have been multiple backlashes to this in recent times. The socialist revolutions of central and south america, the arab spring, the rise of Putin's influence in the ex-soviet sphere of influence, and now the rise of nationalist anti-globalization leaders like Trump. A lot of people world-wide are deciding that America's place in world affairs is no longer tenable or desirable. I'm totally mixed on this and consider myself fairly neutral. I appreciate the relative peace and stability that we've had, but I also think it's been untenable. A better world will likely come, eventually, from more distributed decision making that doesn't involve just a small % of the world's population.
- dagss 10y agoThat is a very optimistic view. What mechanism would ensure distributed decision making in a world where power is very unevenly distributed?
- foota 10y agoSeems like the U.N. is a crippled organization by the privileges that members of the security council have.
- rm999 10y agoI'm thinking 20-50 years from now as the developing world develops and embraces globalization on its own. In the next couple decades we're likely going to see some bad (or at least chaotic) times :(
- 0xfeba 10y ago> I appreciate the relative peace and stability that we've had But we have extreme anti-American sentiment that has been brooding for quite some time in some of these countries, which we are now seeing actualized in the form of terrorist attacks. I think we will have to live with those for a while after our meddling in other countries' affairs ceases--if it ever does.
- slicktux 10y agoNot to fear my fellow Americans! The U.S.A is a Republic not a Democracy. . . Although, many view it as a democracy. . .even president's do the same. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13019834 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13019834
- int_19h 10y agoThe USA is a democracy under the 21st century dictionary definition of the word "democracy", which includes representative democracies like USA. It is also a republic. To be very specific, it is a constitutional federal democratic representative republic. Now, back when the Declaration of Independence was written, your statement was true - for the simple reason that the word "democracy" was very exotic then, as was the form of government itself. The people who used it then, used it more in a sense of Aristotelian dichotomy between demokratia and politeia (the latter word was later somewhat incorrectly translated to Latin as "res publica"), and generally implying direct democracy. Since then, numerous new democratic states appeared, with various differences in their specific arrangements - and so there was a need for a word that would describe the things that are common to all of them, and distinguish them from states with other forms of government. "Democracy" happened to be the one that was already in use, but also rare enough that its evolution wouldn't be bothersome, and its etymology made it the perfect candidate; and so, here we are. So, what you were really trying to say - assuming that you meant the original 18th century meanings of the words - translates to modern English as, "USA is a representative democracy, not a direct democracy". Well, duh.
- glup 10y agoI find the rather scant coverage of election topics on HN to be a glaring warning in its own right... if the technocratic class is focused on bricklaying (Go, TensorFlow, Docker, etc.), who is deciding what gets built at the macro level? Maybe it's time we all take responsibility for creating a fair, just, open, and economically robust society?
- StephenConnell 10y agoGood point, but I appreciate the scant coverage on HN.
- mturmon 10y agoYeah, the problem with politics on HN is that HN readers typically don't bring much depth to the discussion.
- baq 10y agoi'll be less blunt than the OP: the fact that politics pisses you off is fine, but the fact that people who are able to see through this bullshit (which is what makes you pissed off, i assume) don't want to be involved is very bad. "somebody else's problem" and "it's not going to be that bad (again)" clearly aren't working.
- drewrv 10y agoI agree that hackers and techies should be more civic minded, it's really a disgrace how ill informed we are on something so important. Unfortunately the site guidlines pretty explicitly declare politics off topic. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- tdb7893 10y agoI think that the problem is very complicated and doesn't have a simple technical fix so I'm not sure a primarily tech forum is the right place for it.
- sgslo 10y agoI know its fun to think of us tech crowd as being somehow superior to the rest of the populace, but nothing could be further from the truth. We are just as ignorant and naive as the next set of folks down the line. Believing anything else is craziness.
- ihsw 10y agoIt seems simple -- progressive extremism and progressive supremacy is what threatens democracy in today's West. The obstinate and divisive leaders of neo-liberalism have made absolutely no effort to reach across the aisle and greet their political opponents midway, instead opting for tasteless attacks and tone-deaf dismissal. Democracy involves meeting each-other half-way without exception and clearly the likes of Merkel and Clinton have shown no interest in budging on wedge issues, which only accelerates their fall from leadership. Clutching onto power through underhanded further ensures our dangerous position on the edge of a precipice.
- gipp 10y agoSeems pretty ridiculous to assign blame for the lack of compromise to one side or the other. Where are the rightists "reaching across the aisle"?
- serge2k 10y agoI'm confused which wedge issues they aren't budging on? I also find this statement laughable when you consider that the republicans have made up excuses and refused to vote for a year on the Garland nomination. That nomination would also be considered reaching accross the aisle, given the Obama picked a candidate that he thought the republicans could live with. The republicans have thrived on obstructionism and blaming the other side.
- danielschonfeld 10y agoThis reminds me Nick Hanauer video about the pitchforks that are coming. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nbj6hIOMcSk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nbj6hIOMcSk
- vkou 10y agoThere are currently serious discussions among the left as to whether or not protesters should 'Bundy up' to be taken seriously. The last time we've seen something like this was during the heyday of the Black Panthers. Now, what does this say about trust in public institutions?
- lechiffre10 10y agoUnited States isn't a democracy. It's a republic
- mwfunk 10y agoDemocratic republics are forms of democracy.
- vkou 10y agoA republic is a country that is not governed by a king or queen. Russia is a republic. China is a republic. Canada is not a republic. Japan is not a republic. Describing a form of government as a republic is almost entirely meaningless. It's a split-hair thought-stopper that adds nothing to the conversation.
- CPLX 10y agoTo coin a phrase, it's the income inequality stupid. Current trends are inherently unstable. You can't have a workable political system when nearly all the economic gains accrue to a small group at the top. This has been the fundamental tension in political systems since we've had political systems. Some have been screaming their heads off about it for years, but with minor exceptions there haven't been genuine working and middle class focused political movements in the west with actual power in at least a generation. This is what happens when you do that.
- iainmerrick 10y agoCurrent trends are inherently unstable. You can't have a workable political system when nearly all the economic gains accrue to a small group at the top. I don't think that's necessarily true (unfortunately). There's probably a threshold where inequality becomes unsustainable, but it could be very high. See Axelrod's The Evolution of Cooperation. It's most famous for the iterated Prisoner's Dilemma contest, where the simple "tit for tat" strategy beat all the others, but there's a lot more great material in there. "Tit for tat" is just one stable solution, but there are others. Another stable solution is an unpleasant-sounding caste system, where everybody is nice to people of higher rank and nasty to people of lower rank. That system is self-sustaining and resistant to interlopers as long as it's self-policing, i.e. the insiders punish people who buck the system. Even people at the bottom of the pecking order are incentivized to play along and keep their heads down. Similarly, I think extreme inequality could be stable and self-sustaining. I think it would require people to actively reject "government handouts", which is exactly what we see in a lot of political rhetoric these days. Almost all large corporations have extreme salary inequality, but they're still relatively stable and successful entities. Why wouldn't the low-level workers demand more pay? Because it's a "meritocracy" -- we need high executive salaries to attract the best people, and if you just work a bit harder maybe you'll get promotion and earn the big bucks for yourself.
- CPLX 10y ago> Another stable solution is an unpleasant-sounding caste system, where everybody is nice to people of higher rank and nasty to people of lower rank. Yes, to some extent. I suppose there is an argument you can make that there's another Nash equilibrium at the point of extreme inequality, where a couple people are rich and everyone else is essentially starving. But that sort of seems besides the point, given how complex and interconnected our current economic and political structures are. > Almost all large corporations have extreme salary inequality, but they're still relatively stable and successful entities. On what time scale? I would argue that if governments were even 1/10 as likely to fail as large corporations the world would be quickly reduced to rubble.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- iainmerrick 10y agoIt's hard not to think that democracy could be on the way out. People losing interest in democracy qua democracy, rather than what they can get out of it; the hero-worship of entrepreneur barons like Musk and Zuckerberg. Maybe the best we can hope for in the future is a benevolent corporate-style government. For all the current furore right now about whether we're "normalizing" fascism, note that communism (as practised in China) is already pretty well normalized. Other countries are judged on how friendly they are, not their political systems, so China and Saudi Arabia are okay. It would be great to see some real willingness to repair democracy in the US. Ditching the electoral college would be a small but significant step. Almost nobody likes it, after all! If we can just keep the discussion clear and calm, and separate the proposal to improve the system from the result of this election, maybe we could make progress. I'm not holding my breath, though... I would also love to see experimentation with really radical forms of democracy. For example, Arthur C Clarke's The Songs of Distant Earth has a fun aside about random selection of leaders. The Venetian Republic apparently used multiple rounds of lotteries and nominations; incredible to think that such a complex system was used successfully for centuries. (Excellent writeup in the New Yorker: http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2010/07/26/win-or-lose http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2010/07/26/win-or-lose)
- int_19h 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Council_democracy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Council_democracy Take this, and remove all references to "workers" and "proletariat", and it sounds like it could be a very workable system, more stable than direct democracy, but with a much faster feedback loop than any modern representative democracy (since any council can recall its delegate to the higher-level council at any point).
- iainmerrick 10y agoYes, that's interesting! It failed pretty quickly in the USSR, though, so clearly additional checks and balances are needed: Lenin […] issued a "temporary" ban on factions in the Russian Communist Party. This ban remained until the revolutions of 1989 and according to critics made the democratic procedures within the party an empty formality.
- mirekrusin 10y agoWhat happened to that idea that Google wanted to create it's own country?
- vivekd 10y agoHow valid is this research? They seemed to have arbitrarily chosen factors that the researchers seem to feel is "essential to democracy" and then simply decide that these factors are in decline. Maybe I missed this but I didn't see the researcher list what the actual factors were that were "essential for democracy" and how these factors were chosen. It seemed as they just arbitrarily picked factors that they felt were essential for a democracy and then showed that these factors were experiencing a decline. The countries chosen in the study, Poland and Venezuela are particularly poor examples as they were both countries that were under long periods or autocratic rule and then briefly attempted a transition to democracy which failed. To hold these up as examples of a general trend of failing democracy seems misleading. What this really seems to me is people with a particular political bias sounding the bell of doom because a candidate they dislike won the election. Really they even mention Trump in the article and mention his election as a sign of failing democracy - you can't get much more biased than that.
- eumoria 10y agoAlso Venezuela has the curse of easy natural resources it's generally awful for a functioning democracy. That really skewed things in my opinion and isn't very helpful in comparison to a nation like the U.S.
- serge2k 10y ago> Also Venezuela has the curse of easy natural resources it's generally awful for a functioning democracy Which democracies have been hurt by this?
- hash-set 10y agoWhy even post article from the NYT? They are not a reliable source of information. Mostly just propaganda.
- sctb 10y agoIt's time to stop the unsubstantive and politically-motivated comments like this. They do nothing but derail the civil and thoughtful discussions that we're trying to have here.
- Pica_soO 10y agoOne of the biggest irony is that a lot of dictators and there cronies are worried more then we are on democracy. Dislike it all you want- the day, your generals decide that you are no longer need - having money in a stable place half the world away, is a value for itself. Maybe those declining political party's could ask some African dictators for donation?
- MichaelBurge 10y agoThe NYT were enthusiastic supporters of Fidel Castro, who was a communist. He visited their offices in person, mentioning that he couldn't have gotten into power without them. It could be that there is systematic bias at the NYT opposing democracy, except as a rhetorical technique to appeal to its readers. Castro's chief executioner had this to say: A foreign reporter -- preferably American -- was much more valuable to us at that time (1957) than any military victory. Much more valuable than rural recruits for our guerrilla force, were American media recruits to export our propaganda. They didn't seem to like Hugo Chavez(mentioned in the article, and a socialist) at the time, which is evidence against it being a general trend. I'd need to look at other leaders to see if it is systematic from the NYT. Maybe Hugo just wasn't as good at dealing with the media: http://www.latinamericanstudies.org/venezuela/chavez2.htm http://www.latinamericanstudies.org/venezuela/chavez2.htm There could be bias from this specific author, though. If this author was going to write any article at all, it was going to be about Trump destroying Democracy. The same author used to work at Vox and there are many other articles comparing him to a dictator: http://www.vox.com/authors/amanda-taub http://www.vox.com/authors/amanda-taub How much independence are NYT writers given? Does the company take a stance on certain issues? Is there selection bias for certain employees, even if there's no explicit company policy on politics? This could be measured to some extent by checking political donations from employees associated with the NYT. I think that data is public. None of these necessarily oppose their argument, but good evidence and arguments subjected to enough selection bias can say any story you want it to. http://lesswrong.com/lw/js/the_bottom_line/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/js/the_bottom_line/ Does the difference correlate well with immigration patterns? A lot of the European countries are admitting many refugees and migrants from countries with a lot of corruption. The US might have many migrants from Mexico or other Central or South American countries with a higher corruption index. It could be that the migrants don't care about democracies, because they weren't raised in a culture that cares about democracies. I'm 27 and prefer a Republic to a Democracy, since it keeps more power closer to the people governed. I haven't looked at their study to see if I would count as a younger person opposed to Democracy. Sanders is a socialist and he seems to be pretty popular. It could be that people are warming up to socialism or communism. That's different from the system of government, but depending on how they did the study they could've said that socialists are not in favor of democracies.