4 ms·
That's a complicated question because it intersects with a bunch of philosophical questions: * Can the victims of a crime be made whole by compensation? * If
by michaelt 10y ago
That's a complicated question because it intersects with a bunch of philosophical questions:
* Can the victims of a crime be made whole by compensation?
* If a crime harms people at random, is the crime only against those harmed or against all those placed at risk? Or society as a whole?
* How should the justice system balance the relative priorities of making the victims whole against deterring offences that haven't yet happened and reducing recidivism?
* To what extent do criminals take a rational economic view of crime? Should punishments and compensation be scaled relative to prosecution rates?
* Is it just for victim payoffs to depend on BATNA, if it means a poor, powerless person's life is worth less than a rich, powerful person's?
* Can a payoff ever be just if the justice system, which is the victim's only alternative, isn't just?
* Should we accept a less economically efficient response to crime if doing so removes perverse incentives?