3 ms·
Ask HN: Is it weird to do a friends/family round after doing an accelerator?
My startup was in the first batch of the Intel Education Accelerator. Our demo day had a bunch of VCs and very few angels. Because of this, it feels weird to me to consider doing a friends and family round — like it's somehow a failure. But none of our other startups in our cohort raised VC money coming out of the accelerator, which makes me wonder if I'm being irrational.
I've spent quite a bit of time talking with VCs that aren't a good fit, often because they want to write bigger checks that we're looking for. I have half a dozen friends and family who have expressed strong/repeated interest in investing, and it would be a lot faster to close a round than courting angels/VCs that I don't know.
Does anyone know what's "normal" for a startup coming out of an accelerator? Would it be a red flag for future investors if we raised from friends/family at this point?
- smt88 10y agoThe most successful company will raise $0, in theory. Raising more money from bigger names is not a metric of success. It's not an indicator that you're going to succeed or not. In fact, it may indicate that your goal is harder, since your product doesn't immediately generate revenue and prove itself to be profitable. If you want to raise a friends/family round (the size and terms work for you), then do it. Stop thinking about whether your round looks like success or not. Again, you'd be better off if you were cash-flow positive and didn't need to raise at all. I would say, though, that friends/family rounds are a great way to destroy relationships with friends/family if they're not absolutely loaded. Startups are one of the worst and riskiest investment vehicles, and you don't want someone with < $1M in assets to lose, say, $50k on your startup.
- gnicholas 10y agoGood points, thanks! I'm not concerned solely with signaling (also important to work with investors with relevant expertise and connections, of course), but I would be more reluctant to do a f/f round if it were going to be taken as a strong negative signal in future rounds. Appreciate your and brudgers mentioning the personal relationship aspect of taking f/f investments. That's definitely a consideration also.
- NumberCruncher 10y agoIf your friends/family want to support you they could offer you free accommodation (living at their place) as long as you work on your startup.
- arikr 10y ago> Does anyone know what's "normal" for a startup coming out of an accelerator? Most startups I've seen out of YC get the bulk from accredited investors > Would it be a red flag for future investors if we raised from friends/family at this point? The only true red flag is a product that users don't love or no growth Amazon's first funding came from Bezos' parents. Friends and family funding won't kill your company
- gnicholas 10y agoThis was my sense regarding YC as well, but I wonder about other accelerators, since the vast majority of accelerated startups come out of something other than YC (and I realize that HN skews YC, but hope there are some folks with other expertise to share). I realize that Bezos and many others have gotten funding after doing a friends/family round; I'm wondering if there are ever red flags associated with f/f rounds, such as if they happen after completing an accelerator.
- arikr 10y agoShort answer is investors will question it (they may or may not ask these questions, they will be thinking them) "why did they raise from f/f and not institutions then" "what did those investors who presumably said no know that i didn't" "are they better now?" but it's not a massive red flag unless there are scary answers to the above qs
- brudgers 10y agoThe big question to me is not 'what does it signal?' The big question is do the friends and family really understand they are investing in a vehicle where the profits come from spreading risk across a portfolio of companies and all their eggs are in one basket. Professional Venture Capital understands that and have sufficient capital to diversify their risk. It (hopefully) has the experience to project how much money a company is likely to actually need in order to have a chance at successful startup growth. It will tend to hard push the upside rather than protect against the downside more so than individual investors. To me, the business decision should be a business decision. Which investors would you choose based on track record and the ability to add value? Good luck.
- aminozuur 10y agoYes, it is weird.
- gnicholas 10y agoThanks for weighing in! Are you a funder, entrepreneur, or other?
- aminozuur 10y agoI'm just a dude who likes to build simple web apps. I only use the term 'entrepreneur' when someone has had significant impact. I don't think you should worry about 'what is weird', try to do what you think best regardless of how it may look.
- rajacombinator 10y agoI think you should take a step back and personally consider it a red flag if, after strong exposure through an accelerator, you're unable to get substantial interest from institutional investors. That's what accelerators are for. The "checks too big" problem doesn't really fly IMO. If some strangers really want to give you a check for $X million for something that is currently worth $0 million, you should do it. Worrying about maintaining equity is silly, because you can just think of it as reducing future fundraising needs. Also, if the checks are really too big, surely these professional investors would find another way to make it work with a smaller check, or introduce you to smaller professional investors downstream in their pipeline. Most likely, "checks too big" is their way of letting you down gently. Do you really want to ask F&F to put money into something that professionals are not that enthusiastic about? They are most likely unsophisticated investors and you risk damaging your relationship with them. Accordingly, your confidence in the startup should be quite high to take their money. I think the signaling risk is irrelevant. If you take the F&F money, either it will be enough to get you to the next level needed to raise more or it won't. (Or you won't need to raise more, so again it's irrelevant.)
- gnicholas 10y agoThanks for the candor. If we were the only startup in our cohort not to raise from VCs, I'd certainly have some concerns. I think the accelerator had some flaws (it was their first cohort), and we ended up not actually being exposed to suitable potential investors, which is why no one raised coming out of demo day. You make a good point about introductions to smaller investors — that's certainly something to think about. I agree that in most cases a startup should open to taking large checks, but we're a bit of an anomaly in that we're a licensing business with relatively light expenses. So we're only looking to raise around $300k, which doesn't make sense for most of the VCs we met through the accelerator. I understand that they have to put cash to work, and that if they prefer a 5x return on a $10M check than a 10x return on a $250k check. With such a small investment, there's basically no chance that we materially impact their fund's overall return.
- borplk 10y agoNot that I'm any expert but I would always try to stay away from a "friends/family" round regardless of other factors. I know it's not what you want to hear but statistically you are setting yourself for trouble. When you can try to prevent the effect of your work from leaking into other areas of life.