3 ms·
Is Chomsky's Theory of Language Wrong? Pinker Weighs in on Debate
- grzm 10y agoIt’s all too easy to claim that children don’t need any innate priors or assumptions or representations, only to sneak them back in when it comes to get serious and implement a model. That was the trick in a lot of the neural-network models of language that were popular in the 80s and 90s – when the rubber met the road, they always built in innate structure without calling attention to it. From the outside, seems like there are still similarities wrt ML and current AI.
- cocktailpeanuts 10y agoSaying Chomsky is wrong is like saying Newton is wrong. Or Freud is wrong. A good theory is valuable because it provides a way of making sense of the world. There are some theories where it CAN actually be proven wrong (like the old theory that the earth is flat, etc.), but it's stupid to say something is "wrong" when it cannot be proven wrong by definition, nor is it meant to be right or wrong. No one understands how human beings work. Unless if you're a God.
- kafkaesq 10y agoBut the thing about Chomsky is that pretended to "know" how a certain function of the brain worked (and on a level much more complex than F = ma, and much more specific than anything offered by Freud), well ahead of any available evidence.