3 ms·
No offense. But if you had a magic way to reduce HTTP headers to zero, it would have no impact on me as a user. The fact that a web page loads 40+ domains? Y
by bsder 10y ago
No offense. But if you had a magic way to reduce HTTP headers to zero, it would have no impact on me as a user.
The fact that a web page loads 40+ domains? Yeah, that's a problem.
The fact that a web page prioritizes serving me an ad so everything blocks until it gets that ad? Yeah, that's a problem.
The fact that a web page downloads 25 Megabytes of data? Yeah, that's a problem.
HTTP headers getting compressed? Not even on my radar.
- schmichael 10y agoYour complaints about the web are valid but totally out of scope for the HTTP spec.
- bsder 10y agoAsking why everybody is wasting time on something THAT WILL HAVE NO IMPACT ON END USERS is quite in scope, thanks. This benefits a very small number of companies who manage to serve very small, highly optimized payloads and nobody else. And everybody else pays the cost in terms of complexity, security holes, and implementation bugs.
- schmichael 10y agoMore efficient protocols mean lower costs for those companies. Lower costs potentially means fewer ads to make the same amount of money. Not every technical advance needs to have a direct impact on end users to have a positive indirect effect.
- byuu 10y ago> This benefits a very small number of companies ... And everybody else pays the cost in terms of complexity, security holes, and implementation bugs. Yes, exactly!! SPDY, QUIC, et al are designed by Google for the Googles and Facebooks of the world. It is not prioritizing what most sites need most. Hell, most sites don't need this period. Optimizing even the most generous 1.4% that Cloudflare claims isn't going to have any meaning to sites ranked below 100,000 in Alexa (eg 99% of them.) They're not going to run out of bandwidth, and their traffic means they're only using ~3% of a $5/mo VPS. You want software and website monocultures? This is how you get it. Unbelievable complexity creep. All the fun we've had with OpenSSL vulnerabilities? Get ready for them in the new QUIC-HTTP/2 servers. TLS alone already basically makes it impossible to write your own web server anymore, but at least that's a necessary evil due to ISP and state actor spying abuses. If you're okay with a world where everyone has the choice between nginx or Apache, I guess that's fine. I'm not, though.
- jgrahamc 10y agoYou are thinking narrowly about web sites. Lots of other things use HTTP/2 and you will care about performance of those connections (e.g. an API for your favorite app).
- thecompilr 10y agoIt might not impact you as a user, but it will impact many other users. The average numbers are largely skewed by websites that serve huge assets. If we are to look at the median we would see much higher numbers. Also some outliers on the other end of the spectrum, that serve mostly text, such as hacker news, save well over 15% of total bandwidth due to HPACK.