4 ms·
Probably-not-hypothetical case: Tensions rise with Russia over Ukraine/Syria/Baltics/Eastern Europe/etc. The Pentagon draws up contingency plans for respondin
by nostrademons 10y ago
Probably-not-hypothetical case:
Tensions rise with Russia over Ukraine/Syria/Baltics/Eastern Europe/etc. The Pentagon draws up contingency plans for responding to an armed conflict in any one of those areas.
When questioned by a reporter, the White House responds "We have no plans to go to war with Russia."
Should the White House Press Secretary go to jail?
I sympathize with the information-libertarian position that holds that all information should be free, truthful, & accessible to everyone. But there's a really big pragmatic problem in that when individual soundbites are pulled out and shared, they lose context. People don't understand the circumstances behind the facts, and they bring all of their own prejudices and emotions along. Oftentimes, reporting the truth brings about a worse outcome (in some cases, a disastrous outcome) than lying to the public.
It's not just the government either - corporations, institutions, and individuals lie all the time too, and often for good reasons. I was a Google employee when the Nexus line was under development, and I knew that the official press statement of "We are not and have no plans to develop a phone" was false. The reason for it was that if news of the Nexus line leaked, it would've jeopardized supplier relationships such that there wouldn't be a phone. In some cases you can actually get into logical paradoxes where a statement is true only if everyone believes that it is false and vice versa.
- AdamSC1 10y agoI can entirely concede the case for secrecy in these situations. Obviously, my statement is not a full proposal for a specific law, but rather a starting point. There is certainly a level of nuance (as there is with all laws), but, I think it comes down to the difference between publishing content you know to be false for matters of personal gain, manipulation, malice, etc. To be a practical law it would need some sort of clause akin to separate the 'actus rea' from the 'mens rea' as well as the impact. Consider cases in libel. The 'actus rea' (the actual act of committing libel) and saying something defamatory about someone that you believe to be true, is different than the libel which has the 'mens rea' (forethought of the action) in which you made claims you knew to be false but did so for a negative impact against someone else. The 'actus rea' alone is often swept under the rug with a slap on the wrist, unless the plaintiff proves substantial damages from the act itself. That qualifier can make it a criminal act even without the 'mens rea'. I agree, there is a lot of nuance to tease out in such a legal concept. My retort to the other commentator was more that if you are going to say something is a bad idea, you have to put forth why and not just put forth rhetoric! But, once again, I wholeheartedly agree with your examples. I couldn't call for a law that compels the truth. Just something that prevents false publication with the intent to deceive people that it is real for the purposes of malice or ill-gotten self-gain.