4 ms·
On the contrary, Buckyballs was never marketed to children, and had clear warnings all over them. They were still pushed into closure by the CPSC. Even after th
by ocdtrekkie 10y ago
On the contrary, Buckyballs was never marketed to children, and had clear warnings all over them. They were still pushed into closure by the CPSC. Even after they were clearly marked "Keep Away From All Children".
If we can't sell things to adults because they're dangerous to children, we might as well close... well, all hardware stores.
- clarkevans 10y agoHardware stores have mostly uninteresting tools -- Buckyballs are toys.
- zardo 10y ago>Hardware stores have mostly uninteresting tools My nephews don't think tools or random bits of hardware are uninteresting. I certainly didn't either. If you're of a mind to play, the world is nothing but toys.
- DanBC 10y agoSome adults will let their children use power tools. They'll make sure there's the discussion about safety, they'll do a bit of supervision. They'll hopefully include safety glasses. Everyone knows a drill is dangerous. No-one just hands a hammer drill to a six year old and leaves them to it. The regulator's point about the magnets is that the manufacturers didn't manage to stop them being sold in toy shops to children, and that even with the warnings parents were giving them to children as toys. And, even compared to random bits of hardware store: if you swallow a nail you're probably going to be ok. If you swallow magnets you're probably going to need medical help.
- dpark 10y ago> if you swallow a nail you're probably going to be ok. As long as you're okay with sepsis from a perforated intestine, then sure.
- DanBC 10y agoNo, in most cases the child is going to be fine. This is exactly the point - swallowing a nail is a bad idea but is unlikely to cause significant harm. Swallowing a magnet doesn't look as bad as swallowing a nail (the magnets are smooth and shiny, sometimes round, and very small), but the consequences are usually worse.
- dpark 10y agoI'm not sure I believe that. Depending on the size of the nail and how sharp it is, it could pass through, but could also puncture something along the way or get lodged. If a child swallows anything larger than a dime, the standard recommendation is to seek medical attention.
- anigbrowl 10y agoComplete nonsense. Most small boys (and some girls) are fascinated by tools, that's why there are play tools in toy stores so kids can pretend to be a construction worker or suchlike. Conversely I enjoy playing with magnets but I also find them useful for visualizing complex problems and as artistic tools for texturing paint. Maybe you didn't find physical tools interesting as a child but it's fallacious to assume that no other children do when there's abundant evidence to the contrary.
- DanBC 10y ago> Buckyballs was never marketed to children, The first warning label on Buckyballs said 13+. Anyone under 18 is a child.
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoBy most conventional definitions, 13+ is a teen. Apparently, in 2010, Congress extended the definition of "child" up to age 14[0], and the CPSC started their complaint on that one year differential. And Buckyballs, for example, changed their notice then to "Keep Away From All Children" and agreed not to sell them at stores like Toys R Us. Two years later from them voluntarily making those changes, the CPSC sued them and sequentially drove them out of business. The facts fall staunchly in opposition to your comments suggesting that they were resistant to applying warning labels, and actively trying to market them to children. This is why all of your comments stating such are downvoted into the grey. One of your other comments claims all the CPSC wanted was warnings, but the reality is that the CPSC worked to drive these companies out of business after all of the warnings were present. [0] http://gizmodo.com/how-buckyballs-fell-apart-1609183224 http://gizmodo.com/how-buckyballs-fell-apart-1609183224