5 ms·
Those examples are obviously dangerous while magnets are not. A parent is going to leave their 2 year old playing with a loaded gun, but they might leave them
by slg 10y ago
Those examples are obviously dangerous while magnets are not. A parent is going to leave their 2 year old playing with a loaded gun, but they might leave them to play with a bunch of magnets without realizing the danger.
- jessriedel 10y agoThat's what warning labels are for. A policy of banning any product for which the general public isn't fully informed of the dangers is a policy which prevents the public from becoming aware of dangers and mitigating them. ("A week ago there was no acceptable warning, no acceptable age, no sales restriction nor waiver that allowed production of magnets like Zen Magnets, Buckyballs, Neoballs, Magnicube or Neocubes.") Also, there are no warning labels on balloons, much less are they banned, but, as the OP points out, balloons are the #1 cause of child suffocation. It's clear here that these rules aren't being made based on any sensible cost-benefit regulatory consideration, they are just putting unnecessary burdens on new products and grandfathering in the old ones because this is the path of least blame/resistance.
- evan_ 10y agoThere actually are warning labels on balloons, plastic bags, and the like warning of suffocation/choking hazard.
- jessriedel 10y agoSorry, yes, I should have said "Warning labels aren't mandated for balloons...". For instance, the first result for "balloons" on amazon doesn't show any warning labels on the exterior package or the front of the interior bag. https://smile.amazon.com/Kings-Deal-10color-Latex-Balloons/dp/B00KJHCU2U https://smile.amazon.com/Kings-Deal-10color-Latex-Balloons/d... (Maybe it's in small type on the back?) EDIT: Was able to find this PDF, which says that latex balloons must be labeled if they are intended for children under 12. But presumably nothing is required if intended for adults. http://mohawkglobal.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/12/labeling-childrens-products.pdf http://mohawkglobal.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/12/labeling-...
- drcoopster 10y agoDon't be silly, no one reads warning labels anyways.
- tn13 10y agoI can least a zillion things on earth that can kill little children but parents might leave those things around. When I was a child I put a hairpin inside power socket and had caught a poisonous snake in the backyard. I don't think it is sensible for government machinery to waste taxpayer money on inventing new ways of saving babies and instead let parents make those decisions. Parents care for their babies infinitely more than government and those parents who might be irresponsible might put children in harms way despite all regulations. A good clear label indicating the harm is good enough.
- ferentchak 10y agoI for one support snake labeling
- ninju 10y agoSomething like this maybe :-) http://www.kidzone.ws/lw/snakes/ws8.htm http://www.kidzone.ws/lw/snakes/ws8.htm
- gertef 10y ago> A parent is going to leave their 2 year old playing with a loaded gun Perfect accidentally correct typo. You meant "NOT going to", but your intent was wrong: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2016/05/01/toddlers-have-shot-at-least-23-people-this-year/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2016/05/01/toddl...
- Cpoll 10y ago> but they might leave them to play with a bunch of magnets without realizing the danger. Or, according to the website, "a balloon, the #1 cause of child suffocation, a novelty everyone grew up with and often believe to be harmless."
- cbsmith 10y agoThe irony here is that the reason Zen Magnets had such a fight on their hands is that there isn't a comparable amount of regulation for guns & fireworks.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- anigbrowl 10y agoEvery box of neodymium magnets I've ever bought has a big warning on it saying 'DANGER - do not swallow' with an explanation of why. It's not the manufacturer's fault if some people refuse to pay attention to clearly stated warnings. It's those parents which are putting their children at risk, not the manufacturers. Those examples are obviously dangerous while magnets are not. A parent is [not] going to leave their 2 year old playing with a loaded gun [...] I amended your quote as you seem to have omitted a word by mistake. However, I have to disagree - lots of small children die or shoot others every year because the parents do allow them to play with a loaded gun. Sure they don't hand them a gun and say 'have fun Timmy,' but it's quite common for people to leave the gun accessible to children who then play with it. I don't recall how many kids die this way each year but it's far from zero. Given the wide popularity of guns, I'd think a lot more 2 year olds get shot than die or suffer injury from eating magnets. http://www.gunviolencearchive.org/reports/child-injured-killed http://www.gunviolencearchive.org/reports/child-injured-kill... has pretty up-to-date raw data for anyone interested in analyzing this.
- DashRattlesnake 10y ago> I've ever bought has a big warning on it saying 'DANGER - do not swallow' with an explanation of why I've seen the "do not swallow warnings" but I don't recall ever getting much of an explanation. I think explanations of warnings are severely under rated. It's the difference between a warning someone might actually heed and one someone might easily dismiss as nannying.
- anigbrowl 10y agoWell I first learned about the risks from reading the warning leaflet supplied with the fancy magnets I bought which explained exactly what could go wrong.
- slg 10y agoYou are right I omitted a word there, but it is too late to edit my post. >they don't hand them a gun and say 'have fun Timmy,' That is the distinction. These things are marketed as toys. The expectation is that they will be played with and probably by kids. Regarding the warnings, almost every kids toy has these type of warnings. It is easy to get desensitized to them. A parent should still be aware of them, but it also means that in practice these type of warnings might not be enough to stop potential problems. And for the record, I'm not saying these should be outlawed or anything. Just that the comparison to guns and fireworks or using those as a justification for a lack of regulation is silly due to the marketing and perceived danger of all three products.