8 ms·
This Neo-Luddism feels really misplaced. Do you know why some people are getting the short end of the stick? It's because the educational system has failed them
by adamnemecek 10y ago
This Neo-Luddism feels really misplaced. Do you know why some people are getting the short end of the stick? It's because the educational system has failed them by wasting their youth and giving nothing in return. But I can't blame a guy who founded a SV-centric blog to see all problems through a SV-centric lens.
- SomeStupidPoint 10y agoIt still remains to be seen if the Luddites were wrong or merely early -- that's the very thing under discussion! Great PR to use their name as an insult before resolving whether they're right or not.
- adamnemecek 10y agoI didn't know this was still debated.
- SomeStupidPoint 10y agoThere's at least a very popular opinion that the accelerated rate of technological progress will make humans the horses of the 21st century, that is, we'll be replaced at jobs by technology faster than (most of us) can be retrained, and that most of us will be rendered useless and left in the cold. The article itself was about that debate still going on, so it seems disingenuous to say you werent aware it was still being discussed.
- rhodri 10y agoI am a software engineer, and also a luddite. technology destroys jobs. the question is whether that destruction liberates or oppresses. do we fire some workers and overwork others, or find ways to reduce and share the burden and benefits of labour?
- hash-set 10y agoTechnology also creates jobs. I think what you are missing here is that technology is neutral to human ambitions. Technology doesn't care--it could empower us, destroy us, whatever. Technology does not care about human destiny.
- rhodri 10y agoone point is that most of SV's technology is in the hands of an elite of techno-libertarians and super-rich VCs with various chips on various shoulders. they have no interest in spreading technology's monetary or possible systemic benefits to the entire population, and indeed a direct interest in accumulating and then exercising political power. it's a real problem that cannot be explained away through a lack of education, as many over-educated, under-employed and disempowered young (and old!) people directly experience day to day. open-source software and education are steamrollered by the directed power of hierarchy.
- pmoriarty 10y ago"they have no interest in spreading technology's monetary or possible systemic benefits to the entire population" But they're making world-changing phone apps!
- noir-york 10y ago> It's because the educational system has failed them by wasting their youth and giving nothing in return Ah, the deserving poor! Some never consider getting an education because it was not something to aspire to, let alone spending enough time in the system to fail them. Maybe these people are getting the short end of the stick not because they were idle, but because their family were too busy working three jobs trying to make ends meet, maybe because their mother wanted to read to her children but was working some late to pay off medical bills, etc. A strong welfare state and job security can break the cycle, but who is willing to pay - in taxes - for that?
- adamnemecek 10y ago> A strong welfare state and job security can break the cycle, but who is willing to pay - in taxes - for that? Don't get me wrong, I fully agree. But I think that if I were to pick a single element of a welfare state that can bootstrap the whole thing, I'd pick education. It seems like a lot of the largest country growths were bootstrapped by betting on the educational system (Finland, Singapore and South Korea come to mind).
- noir-york 10y agoThe process starts earlier than education. Education needs to be valued in the first place. And then, not only valued, but the parents need to have the security to afford their kids to have an education. And that means healthcare and job security. I am all for a national health service and cheap/free college; it was what enabled my parents to afford an education for us in the first place.
- internaut 10y agoI really really disagree with this. I think the evidence is against you. The economics research shows that the 'best returns' come from early education, with diminishing returns the further progress is made. It is counter intuitive I know, but mass education is similar to macro economics. Helping everybody can help nobody. South Korea and Japan put a lot of focus on education, work insane hours for comparatively low pay, pay stupid rents and are also in a wage stagnation. Put it like this: You get to a middle income economy by doing 1 thing. You get to a high income economy by doing another thing. It is unlikely getting to a very high income economy is accomplished by replicating the former process that took you up a step originally.