6 ms·
I think the article makes a good point. Most comments complain about some technicalities, like using the word "open source software development" vs. "open sourc
by lucb1e 10y ago
I think the article makes a good point. Most comments complain about some technicalities, like using the word "open source software development" vs. "open source software", or mention that "no it isn't inferior!" (which is true, but not the point).
A few months after meeting me, my girlfriend wanted to try a Linux system and I was happy to help her install it. In the end she didn't see what I thought was better about it. I thought I never said it was better, but apparently I gave off that impression, leading to a false expectation.
And it's true, Linux desktops are still notorious despite being actually very stable these days. Open source programs like Firefox, Chromium and Telegram all work the same; and some others like the average file explorer is functionally equivalent too. It's just not better, at least not for most people. It might even eat more battery because of inferior drivers.
The inherent advantage of free software being free (as in freedom) is what the article is about, and that is a good point.
- g00gler 10y agoYou could sit your girlfriend down and do the "advanced configuration" on Windows 10, then she'll understand why Linux is better.
- criley2 10y agoYou could sit your girlfriend down with nothing but terminal, the man pages for a printer or video card driver, and the root user password, and she'll understand why Windows is better.
- abpavel 10y agommc, regedit, powershell, sure this could cascade much further, but I think maybe op had the default privacy options in mind, which enable windows to use the camera and microphone feeds as the os sees fit.
- g00gler 10y agoYes, this exactly. If anyone cared to check out the advanced configuration it is pretty much exclusively turning off security vulnerabilities. One of them is "Automatically trust WiFi connections my contacts trust", a bunch of others are sending data to Microsoft. It's been a few months since I turned on a new Windows 10 PC but I was completely turned off by the advanced configuration. The #3 story on HN right now is "Windows 10 in-place upgrades are a severe security risk" I thought this was a good read the other day https://www.brokenbrowser.com/abusing-of-protocols/ https://www.brokenbrowser.com/abusing-of-protocols/ It just seems terrible security wise, the OS itself is spyware. That is to say, I was excited to be trying out a sexy new Asus Ultrabook with Ubuntu mixed in but didn't care to try after setting it up.
- WayneBro 10y agoThat would be missing the point entirely due to the fact that most users care more about ease of use and apps than "advanced configuration". Not sure why we have to "sit anybody down" either...that sounds a bit forceful and unnecessary. Last time I checked, "better" is completely subjective. But for the record, most people think Windows is better since that's what they've voted for with their dollars. Windows won the desktop war. It's got more users, more apps, more consistency, more stability, more commercial support...more everything. People still fighting for desktop Linux to become popular with regular users are like Hiroo Onoda, the japanese soldier who kept fighting WW2 for 30 years. Good luck with that!
- alkonaut 10y agoThe biggest issue imho is that there just isn't a nice consistent desktop story for linux. Making an application with a nice consistent setup and UI experience across all desktop environments and all distributions without having to distribute to several different package repositories or test on these distributions or window managers? Until that works there is no one Linux desktop - only several different Linux desktops, each with too little traction.
- krylon 10y agoThe things that - to me, at least - are better about a Linux/Un*x-based desktop only became apparent after spending at lot of time using it (a year, maybe 18 months). Which makes me pretty bad at convincing people to give it a try - "Yeah, it sucks at first, but trust me, in year you will love it" is not a good pitch. (OTOH, having first installed SuSE Linux about sixteen years ago, the process of getting a Linux desktop setup is soooo much smoother these days.)
- slgeorge 10y agoThe problem with this argument is that it doesn't achieve the aim of winning more users, even if it is true. The "open source" movement recognised that users don't care about freedom, but they do care about other aspects. In a choice between 'proprietary and easy' and 'free but slightly-harder' users go with the first option: it's actually worse that this because consumer users are actually willing to go beyond 'zero cost' and actively sell their privacy in return for ease/sociability etc. I think the actual issue with the OSI's marketing is that it turns out these words work for professional users of software and not for general consumers. Professional users such as IT departments care about 'power', 'flexibility', 'maintainability' etc - general consumer users don't think that way. End users (particularly consumer users) care about achieving aims in very straightforward, simple terms! Neither, the FSF or OSI philosophy translate into perceived or real benefit for them. To a large degree I think it's something like this: Developers (care about freedom) <---> professional users (care about attributes) <---> consumers (care about ease of outcome) 'care about attributes' is the wrong word, but professional users tends to care about aspects of the software, they ascribe value to the software itself.
- jdright 10y agoIt is more "care about support" than attributes.
- slgeorge 10y agoYes, support is definitely an important one. There are other attributes that some professional users care about more than just a simple functional matrix. For example, I've been in situations where the ability for the professional user to fit the software to their specific requirements over time made FOSS the choice. Even though the initial solution was worse than the equivalent proprietary one. But, the idea that they could develop and improve it over time to meet their specific requirements was powerful.
- lucb1e 10y ago> it doesn't achieve the aim of winning more users Winning more users is not an aim in itself, not to me at least. It's not a cult that I want to win hearts for. But if people see how wrong it is to have a single entity control your computer (and almost everybody's computer), they are definitely welcome to ask for help installing something better (in that regard). I didn't respond to the rest of your post because it builds on that assumption.
- criley2 10y agoTo me, my linux install is my manual F-150 and my windows install is my auto/hybrid Honda Civic. They serve different purposes. They meet different goals. They have different pros and cons, but ultimately, I need both to meet my needs.
- zeveb 10y ago> To me, my linux install is my manual F-150 and my windows install is my auto/hybrid Honda Civic. To me, the Windows machine I have to use is a Trabant with a missing front passenger seat and a nasty tendency to catch fire when it's cold out. Seriously, it's horribly painful to use.
- bryanrasmussen 10y agoI have an Ubuntu desktop, Macbook Pro, and I tried a new Windows machine a couple days ago ( as well as having used one for many years) I can't say I find any deal-breaking differences between them, or even points of significant more pain on any of them. For me they each have their benefits. Are you sure it isn't painful because of being on old hardware or something? (I've used Redhat - that was sometimes painful for me)
- zeveb 10y agoThe hardware's less than a year old, but it's low-spec. Still, using it is so miserable that it makes me physically enraged. The login screen loses keystrokes; the browser constantly prompts for my smartcard; the system can't do partial OS updates; it tries to sell me things on the login screen and in the start menu. Everything is painful, and nothing is pleasant, and when I use it life is dark and miserable and existence is cursed. Seriously, that's not hyperbole: using Windows negatively impacts my life. Running Debian with stumpwm, OTOH, is so comfortable it's like slipping on a glove.
- criley2 10y ago>To me, the Windows machine I have to use is a Trabant with a missing front passenger seat and a nasty tendency to catch fire when it's cold out. >Seriously, it's horribly painful to use. Haha, I have the exact same experience with linux. Windows is a self-driving Tesla that just works while Linux is some 1960's beater limping into the modern world, requiring the 1500pg Shop Manual in the glove compartment on a daily basis because, you just know that old carbureted air/fuel gets knocked off and requires hand adjustment, and the throttle gets sticky if push the pedal too hard, and it just doesn't like keeping oil in the engine when the rubber seals are too cold. I guess it just comes down to what you expect. To me, Windows is "push install button, come back to internet connected desktop" while Linux is "put aside an afternoon for terminal usage and extensive googling and be prepared to make sacrifices/compromises-- temper your expectations"
- larrik 10y agoI would say the best benefit of using Linux over Windows for a casual user is to avoid viruses and ransomware and the like.
- cJ0th 10y agothe second best benefit would be the end to those endless update -> reboot -> update ... cycles ;)
- Aldo_MX 10y agoBelieving you're more secure simply by using Linux instead of Windows is dangerous. The Mirai botnet is the living proof of what happens when you use Linux and forget to take care about your security, not using Windows is not an excuse to lower your guard. As an example, think about all the untrusted code you run, something so simple like `curl -o angular-react-vue-example.sh | sh`. OTOH, not being familiar with troubleshooting low level issues means you'll never know whenever you get infected, remember kernel.org's hack[1]?. [1] http://pastebin.com/BKcmMd47 http://pastebin.com/BKcmMd47
- naasking 10y ago> It's just not better, at least not for most people. Certainly if you define "better" as "do everything I currently need it to do", Linux/BSD aren't any better. But with just a little effort, you can apply nearly any skills you learn in Linux in far more domains than you can for Windows skills. For instance, robotics and embedded systems. "Enabling a path to future growth" certainly qualifies as "better" in my mind.
- st3v3r 10y agoOnly if they actually have an interest in that, or development in general.
- rglullis 10y agoNot at all. The main point of the article and you seem to be missing: freedom has intrinsic value. Personally I don't care if you voted in the last election, or if you ever traveled abroad. But I do care very much about the rights that I have and allow me to vote or exercise free movement. I also don't care if you are interested in modifying the source code of your operating system or the driver of your printer, but I do care very much about having a world where these things are possible. The article is trying to exactly show that "Free Software" is like this, focusing on keeping the intrinsic value of having software that can be freely read, distributed and modified - even when it does not translate in more utility value, a.k.a better software.
- st3v3r 10y ago>Not at all. Yeah, it is. >The main point of the article and you seem to be missing: freedom has intrinsic value. And not everyone agrees with that, or that the value is enough to forgo the other things. >I also don't care if you are interested in modifying the source code of your operating system or the driver of your printer, but I do care very much about having a world where these things are possible. YOU do. Someone who just wants their printer to work would probably place much more value on that, than if the driver were open. Remember, one of the main themes of the article is whether software with "freedom" is worth more than software with usability or features. >The article is trying to exactly show that "Free Software" is like this, focusing on keeping the intrinsic value of having software that can be freely read, distributed and modified - even when it does not translate in more utility value, a.k.a better software. And many people disagree. If it doesn't do what it needs to do, then the software isn't of much value, even if it's libre.
- Grishnakh 10y agoWhen I get into a conversation about Free software being better than proprietary software, I focus on real problems with modern proprietary software that average users have these days, mainly with operating systems. For instance, lots of people don't like Windows 10's interface, but there's also the spyware and advertising issues, and various other annoyances with it, plus the forced-update problem and the fact that you have to separately purchase so much software for it to make it useful. With desktop Linux, you don't have these problems: lots of software is easily installed from the repos and you wind up with a fully-functional system very easily, updates are ridiculously simple and fast and don't prevent you from using your computer, updates aren't forced on you breaking your software, your OS won't be forcibly "upgraded" to a new version you don't want, performance-crippling anti-virus software isn't needed, etc. On the Apple side, the OS is tied to very expensive and now-crippled hardware (see the new MBP which lacks ports, requiring you to carry around a whole bunch of dongles) and still has the problem of not having useful software by default. For people who insist on using some kind of proprietary software like Photoshop, I just don't bother, but for people who just want something to surf the web, write simple documents, watch videos, etc., desktop Linux works great so this is how I pitch it.
- st3v3r 10y ago"and the fact that you have to separately purchase so much software for it to make it useful." That's not a negative, especially for anyone who makes their living selling software. And there's nothing special about Linux that saves it from that; if it became popular, commercial software would be written for it as well, and you'd have the same problem.
- Grishnakh 10y ago>That's not a negative, especially for anyone who makes their living selling software. So you think free things should be banned so that leaches who want to make money selling things can do so? How idiotic. If I'd like to make a living selling air for breathing, is it wrong for people to breathe the air that's freely available? I guess so, in your world. >And there's nothing special about Linux that saves it from that; if it became popular, commercial software would be written for it as well, and you'd have the same problem. Here you completely miss the point. I'm not talking about special niche software, just basic stuff. I can't even edit a fucking text file in Windows without installing some special third-party software, because Windows doesn't come with a usable text editor. Luckily there's free stuff available on the web for some things like that, but it's a big PITA to go find some website, find a download link, and install the program. On Linux, this kind of basic software is part of a standard install, and at the very worst, all I have to do is something like "sudo apt-get install vim".