5 ms·
Have I missed a runaway profusion of investment scams targeting people with net worths between 1 million and 2.3 million? The perceived need for this just perp
by patio11 17y ago
Have I missed a runaway profusion of investment scams targeting people with net worths between 1 million and 2.3 million? The perceived need for this just perplexes me.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoSomething must be done. This is something. Therefore, we must do this.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoLook! I did something! It looks good on TV and 98% of the voters are not directly hurt by it. Looks good, gets votes, it is good.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- jshen 17y agoSomething must be done. This plan isn't perfect. Therefore, we must not do this.
- ajross 17y agoThe article is behind a paywall, but I'd be curious how big this population is. How much actual funding derives from investors in that range? My guess is not much, and of that I suspect a lot of it is of the "rich uncle" form, where you can just make the trusted relative or friend a "founder" and get around the rule.
- hristov 17y agoYou do not need to make the relative a founder. When it comes to relatives you probably do not need to worry about the accredited investor stuff at all, as there is an exception for purely private placements. (this is not legal advice, do consult a lawyer). Anyways, I agree that the lower end of the accredited investor range probably does not contribute much or anything to angel investing.
- prodigal_erik 17y agoI seem to recall reading some advice that friends-and-family money is limited to a couple dozen people, and their involvement can make early VC rounds more complicated therefore harder to get. Is there anything to that?
- hristov 17y agoThe exception for private placements is not limited as to people or amounts invested. But a lot of lawyers do not like using that exception because it is not entirely certain what constitutes a private placement. So if they are not very close "friends and family" you may get in trouble. Therefore, a lot of lawyers prefer to use other better defined exceptions. Regarding VCs, they dislike any earlier investors, and they probably dislike laypeople more because they prefer to deal with professionals. In any event, again please make sure you consult a securities lawyer for your particular situation. I am really an IP attorney, so while I know the securities laws I do not have much experience in that field.
- hga 17y ago"they probably dislike laypeople more because they prefer to deal with professionals" If they've got a clue they most certainly do. There's few things worse than dealing with a squirrelly non-professional investor (been there, done that, both myself and my father). Still, if you have to get money somewhere to attract bigger investments and if this bill passes without fixing these problems you may find yourself pretty much limited to "very close "friends and family"". I.e. if you live in a state where all others are forbidden to invest ... and from that TechCrunch item posted to HN the association of those state regulators may be the entity that's pushing this hard. Which means we may get much less of a fix that we desire/need.
- hristov 17y agoThere actually are such scams all over the place. Couple of years ago I was in a position where I was an accredited investor (based on income) and I had to basically reveal that information on the Internet. I was an attorney in one of the large international law firms and they required you to post a professional biography online. The biography did not mention your salary, but the top lawfirms pay lockstep and publish their salary info so anybody familiar with the legal profession could have figured out the salary from the posted information. Anyways, as soon as I fit the criteria for an accredited investor I started getting calls for what seemed to be obvious scams. There were generally of two types. One type was a call from a boiler-room type operation from some guy with a hilariously exaggerated Jersey accent asking me to buy some over the counter stock. They would suggest a stock for me and then call a couple of months later and say "see the stock we suggested before doubled in price, you should have invested with us, why not try this new stock we are suggesting now." Of course OTC stocks are so thinly traded one can easily manipulate the price. The other type of scams are calls that are made to sound like they were accidentally made by people that have their cell-phones in their pockets and accidentally press a button. It is usually conversation between two people that is supposed to be private and you are only hearing it by accident. The two people then disclose "important inside information" that is supposed to make you rush out and buy a certain stock. So yes those scams are out there. There are boiler-room operations all over the place trying to bilk people that are on the lower end of the accredited investor spectrum. Usually, they prefer accredited investors because stocks that require such investors do not require SEC filings so the scams are easier.
- snissn 17y agocall 1000 people today, tell 500 of them football team A is going to win this week. call the other 500 people, tell them that football team A is going to lose this week. Football Team A wins. Next week call 250 of the people that you told team A would win this week, tell them football team A will win again. Call the other 250 and tell them that football team A will lose. by the end of the season you'll have a dozen or so (i think?) people that will believe anything that you tell them [if anyone can tell me the source of this idea (book/movie?) let me know!]