3 ms·
Have you looked at and 'reviewed' alternatives, such as Facebook Instant Articles or Apple News Format? Why is passing validation an important thing for AMP? T
by madeofpalk 10y ago
Have you looked at and 'reviewed' alternatives, such as Facebook Instant Articles or Apple News Format?
Why is passing validation an important thing for AMP? The main complaint I hear about it is the AMP CDN, where Google caches and hosts your page for you. If you're failing validation then they wouldn't do this, right? So you get the advantages of a fast page without the disadvantage of Google reposting your content.
- lucideer 10y agoThe main advantage of validation is prioritisation in Google's search results, the AMP logo next to your search result on Google (which for most Google users has come to mean "fast"), and the extra speed-up of Google's CDN.
- madeofpalk 10y agoHerein lies the 'confusion' with AMP - its actually two completely different things: - news distribution platform - framework and guidelines for making fast webpages If you want Google to distribute and prioritise your content, you'll have to play by their rules, just in the same way if you want Apple's help as well.
- quelltext 10y agoI have implemented both AMP and Instant Article "views" for a website and boy is the latter a bigger pain in the ass. The format is way more restrictive than AMP. Whereas the latter allows for nested lists, columns, or nested pictures Instant Articles require almost everything to be linearly placed on the top level. So unless your source format has a similarly simple structure you will have to think about ways to transform it down to that. Then, documentation is missing all the crucial details, so I ended up sifting through FB's SDK internals, which still ended up not covering all the issues reported by the web editor. Also, the only way to visually test the output is via the Page Manager app.