6 ms·
Smart criminals will use strong encryption anyway and won't give the passwords to law enforcement both for data at rest and sent over the Internet. I'm encrypt
by pmontra 10y ago
Smart criminals will use strong encryption anyway and won't give the passwords to law enforcement both for data at rest and sent over the Internet.
I'm encrypting my disk now, but I'll give the password to police if they have a search warrant. I'm encrypting so if somebody steals my computer they won't read my data. I think that almost everybody is like me.
Weakening that encryption doesn't help me and doesn't help investigators. Sure, seeing strong encryption over the wire will ring alarms and identify sender and recipient. That works if they actually decrypt all the data sent over the Internet. The workaround for the tenaciuos criminals will be steganography. Narrower band but good enough in most cases. All that effort and damage to honest citizens for nothing.
- trendia 10y agoThe problem is: How do you handle cases where data appears to be encrypted but it isn't? Or, the data is encrypted but the suspect has forgotten the password?
- Gracana 10y agoThe state has little incentive to care about such issues. Look at the success and continued use of BS forensic science... False positives aren't a problem.
- paulddraper 10y agoHow do you handle cases where someone lies about a crime they've committed? Solving offenses without 100% certain evidence is by no means a new problem.
- vuanotinv 10y agoDumb people believe this is about whether encrypted data from criminals can be decrypted or not. It's not about that. It's about being able of charging a criminal with something just for using encryption. That way it won't matter if he refuses to give up the key.
- roblabla 10y agoExcept you can already use key disclosure laws[0] against those people. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Key_disclosure_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Key_disclosure_law
- stale2002 10y agoThats why you use something like TrueCrypt to provide plausible deniability. You have 1 partition/password with the stuff you actually want to hide, and you have a second password/partition that just contains your porn collection. "Yes officer, I just use encryption to hide this stuff. Nothing illegal here. It is just embarrassing. Thats why I hide it." Thats really good plausible deniability.
- alkonaut 10y agoOr "This 500gb file is just a garbage file of random numbers I keep because I heard harddrives last longer if they aren't empty". In any reasonable legislation there shouldn't be a difference between not providing a password and not admitting you have anything encrypted at all (because no one can prove the difference anyway). An important thing that is often forgotten is that most many aren't challenged for encrypted contents in criminal cases but civil lawsuits where the burden of proof is (also) on the defendant because there is no "beyond reasonable doubt" . In that situation, the mere existence of e.g. a file transfer log with the movie file name + an encrypted disk is enough to end up with massive damages. In that situation you would be very interested to show your unencrypted data if you don't have the file in question.
- jdavis703 10y agoIf the only thing sitting between you and life in prison is murder evidence on your drive, vs. a few years for obstruction of justice for not handing over a password, you'd take the "life in prison" door? I don't think most defendants or lawyers behave as nobly as that.
- Legogris 10y agoI assume OP and most other people don't actually have incriminating evidence of things like murder on their hard-drives.
- fuzzy2 10y ago> but I'll give the password to police if they have a search warrant. That’s not right. In most countries, you don’t need to incriminate yourself. Before making wrongheaded decisions, contact a lawyer.
- sbuttgereit 10y agoThis. In the U.S. at least, the 5th amendment gives you the right not to incriminate yourself. A search warrant doesn't change that. Not all authentication methods are equal it appears. Fingerprint, facial recognition, other bio-metrics aren't considered the same as if you need to "speak" your password to someone. In other words, they can make you scan your finger or look into a camera, but they can't force you to tell them your password.
- loup-vaillant 10y agoHow about forcing you to type the password, behind a Mantle of Power if need be, such that they can decrypt the disk, without ever knowing the password?
- dTal 10y agoAs I understand it, in the US at least this is indeed the line. Same goes for combination vs keyed locks: you can't be forced to self-incriminate by sharing information, but you can be held in contempt for withholding evidence. I imagine it gets murky around things like SSH keys, which are technically a kind of password, but too big for a human to remember - and therefore must be "instantiated" in a physical device somewhere.
- semi-extrinsic 10y ago> I imagine it gets murky around things like SSH keys, which are technically a kind of password, but too big for a human to remember - and therefore must be "instantiated" in a physical device somewhere. A likely interpretation might be: an SSH key without a keyphrase is like a physical key, and you must hand it over, while a key with a keyphrase is like a combination lock, where you must hand it over but you are not required to state the keyphrase.
- dghughes 10y ago>but I'll give the password to police if they have a search warrant What if the police are wrong? Or like in Canada the police were trying to find the sources of journalists who wrote about corrupt police. And maybe in the US Trump's hate of journalists could mean something similar. My desire for personal privacy doesn't mean I am hiding anything. Maybe I don't want anyone to read my poetry or see family pictures nothing illegal but certainly private.
- nixgeek 10y agoAlmost nobody is entirely innocent under the law when sufficient scrutiny is applied, so giving LEO access to your computer invites a fishing expedition. IMO.
- mdpopescu 10y agoYep. I had that happen. Someone tipped the police that me and some friends were hacking computers and stealing credit cards. We were raided, gave access to the police to our computers, they found nothing related to cc fraud (of course) but then prosecuted us for some pirated games they found.
- CamperBob2 10y agoNo almost about it. "Give me six terabytes of data from the most honest of men and I will find something in them which will hang him. Probably before I make it past the boot sector." - Cardinal Richelieu
- devoply 10y agoBackdoors and weakened encryption means that there is no encryption going on at all. If any government official can get any information that means anyone can get that information as many of the people who break this stuff don't work for governments and governments are least technically capable actors. So it means there is effectively no encryption all if encryption is weakened or backdoored.
- jb613 10y agoThere is a difference between weakened and backdoored. Weakened is along the lines what you're saying - that likely others than just the governments can easily access, whereas backdoored (if done properly) means only the govt. Of course, this assumes a perfect world and that there is a proper way to backdoor - in the real world, adversaries simply attack the governments backdoors/keys. Nonetheless, given your context of "there is no encryption going on at all" I argue does not necessarily hold for a backdoor - or at least not at the outset and if done properly. If the govt backdoor is a key for which huge amount of care is taken to protect and take the extreme example of the govt encrypting the only copy of the key and firing it off in one direction into space - there is a backdoor but this is not necessarily equivalent to "no encryption at all".
- csydas 10y ago> I'm encrypting my disk now, but I'll give the password to police if they have a search warrant. I'm encrypting so if somebody steals my computer they won't read my data. I think that almost everybody is like me. I may be taking the word "everyone" too literally, but I think that part of the problem is that most people don't think like you and don't really understand the benefits of encryption and why it's a practical tool for absolutely everyone, not just terrorists, pedophiles, and drug dealers. There's a very big educational gap when it comes to encryption, and I don't think that most people can even cover the basics of it very well, which makes it extremely difficult at times to tell if law enforcement and politicians even understand the implications of what they propose beyond the immediate benefit to their operations. However, I do think that your position is probably the best that can help people to begin to understand why encryption is important; there still is a disconnect where most people don't understand that encryption is an all or nothing ordeal, or if they do, they accept the rationalization that the weakening of encryption is important for the security of the nation, whichever nation that may be. But in general, encryption is a problem because it operates in a blackbox for the majority of people, and it's incredibly easy for talking heads to say just about whatever they want on it without being challenged. It feels to me like strong encryption is one of those lessons that people are going to have to learn the hard way, much like how a lot of people learn about backing up data only after having a hard-drive go with important data on it. Though it would likely be difficult to prove, I think it's going to require that a government exploit or something intentionally weakened by a governmental actor be utilized by criminals to harm the public at large before people really get the idea on what government-approved encryption really means.