4 ms·
There's still the old issue of whether downvotes should be used for disagreement or only for mistaken or unconstructive commenting. Paul Graham said several ye
by schoen 10y ago
There's still the old issue of whether downvotes should be used for disagreement or only for mistaken or unconstructive commenting.
Paul Graham said several years ago that it made sense to him to use it for disagreement (because people might use upvotes for agreement), but I continue to feel uncomfortable with that and try never to use it that way. I try to upvote things that I disagree with that I thought were well-put or constructive.
Maybe an alternative would be to look at Paul Graham's own "hierarchy of disagreement" and try to use downvoting only for things at DH2 and below.
http://www.paulgraham.com/disagree.html http://www.paulgraham.com/disagree.html