4 ms·
TL;DR: The Internet allows people to self-publish ideas, uncontrolled by universities which [according to the article, really!] were the main gatekeepers of spe
by rwmj 10y ago
TL;DR: The Internet allows people to self-publish ideas, uncontrolled by universities which [according to the article, really!] were the main gatekeepers of speech before.
- yummyfajitas 10y agoThis is not a complete summary of the article. The article also postulates that due to the threat caused by people outside the academy/media/"cathedral", the overton window has shifted sharply in a radical direction in order to flush out those who are insufficiently loyal.
- hga 10y agoThe article also postulates that due to the threat caused by people outside the academy/media/"cathedral", the overton window has shifted sharply in a radical direction in order to flush out those who are insufficiently loyal. And if I recall correctly, that this is a regular process. Which has led us to this rather extreme point, historically near the extreme for the US.
- danarmak 10y agoIt is a regular process, but when it works normally, it is self-limiting. The idea is that recently it hasn't been successful, the political opposition hasn't been silenced (it merely moved outside the Overton window), and so as the danger signals grow, the radicalizing response grows, to a point where it is perhaps counterproductive.
- hga 10y agoWhat makes it self-limiting? There's always an opponent, someone completing for resources or whatever, that you can use this method to outgroup and purge. That's just one of many mechanisms driving it. What are the specific counter-reactions you see that limit this as an ongoing/regularly exercised pattern?
- danarmak 10y agoOnce the enemy is weak enough, the reaction dies down. What indicates a strong enemy? According to the article, among other things, its media presence. In the past, if academia and mainstream media didn't give a platform to a view, it was effectively silenced. Today, such views can reach the wider public via the Internet. (This isn't really my opinion, I don't have good enough evidence for or against; it's just my understanding of the claims of the article.)
- cronjobber 10y ago> universities which [according to the article, really!] were the main gatekeepers of speech This erroneous concept seems to have spread to this writer via Curtis Yarvin (of Urbit/Strange Loop fame/infamy.) It seems superficially valid because the media loves to use witnesses of academic prestige that back its own agenda. However, it should be clear that the ultimate gatekeeper has always been the media, not any media-selected credentialed proponents of whatever position the media wants to be seen as the most prestigious and scientifically valid.
- Moshe_Silnorin 10y agoI don't know much about Yarvin but I imagine his point is the universities indoctrinate the teachers and the journalists who in turn indoctrinate the public.
- badsock 10y agoIt baffles me that university professors, who are in front of a minority of the population for typically only 4 years, are viewed as having all this control, whereas the people who literally own the media, who can arbitrarily hire and fire any voice they please, are viewed as somehow having less sway over their own company's output.
- hga 10y agoYou're ignoring the power they have to shape minds during that 4 year period, which is particularly powerful for residential students who are out of the nest for the first time, how they can keep doubleplusungood people out of a lot of professions by not letting them graduate (it's now getting explicitly official in some, and personally sobering for me, the moderate conservative-libertarian I was in 1979? No way today I could become a scientist in the US today), and apropos of that, they control who gets to teach K-12 students, the Overton Window in K-12 curricula (which has had a serious allergy to effective teaching of reading for close to a century now, and much later math), etc.
- 10y ago