2 ms·
I find the thought of replacing schools and teachers with technology and VR a scary dystopia. It seems we've gone a long way... in the wrong direction, I suppo
by the_af 10y ago
I find the thought of replacing schools and teachers with technology and VR a scary dystopia.
It seems we've gone a long way... in the wrong direction, I suppose. For example, the consensus in Sci-Fi used to be the other way: people like Bradbury and Asimov imagined nightmare scenarios were kids were taught by futuristic devices, and the implication was that human contact with actual teachers mattered; that exposure to other people with different opinions -- who might even get angry at you -- was a good thing; that education is a social thing, not a mere transference of "content".
Of course there's a lot to fix in education, but why would one root for an educational system in the hands of corporations and practiced by replacing everything with tech?
- DailyHN 10y agoI don't see why a social element couldn't be involved in a VR education. How is the current school-social-experience ideal anyway? Specifically I'm thinking about bullying and the limited time that is actually spent solving problems with peers.
- the_af 10y agoFirst of all, I do agree there's much to improve about education. I don't know if the focus of education should be on "solving problems". Part of it, yes. Parts of education aren't about solving anything. Bullying is a problem in some parts of the world, and not so much in others. I experienced some bullying at school, and it didn't traumatize me. I also made friends and interacted with people, played truant and learned some things. I talked and played with students who had a very different background from mine; I learned about parents and families who thought and acted nothing like mine. VR & tech don't preclude a social element, that's true, but how it's presented often hints at it. "Replacing teachers with VR" hints at it, for example.
- literallycancer 10y agoI'd rather learn from a 99th percentile teacher using various technology (to increase their reach) than from a top 50% teacher that is located in the same room. I didn't (and don't) get much value from my classmates anyway, so I believe I wouldn't be worse off even as some kind of remote student.