4 ms·
So you posit a universe of an infinite number of dimensions? That's nonsense. Just because there's nothing in dimension n+1 doesn't mean it's not part of the
by stcredzero 17y ago
So you posit a universe of an infinite number of dimensions? That's nonsense. Just because there's nothing in dimension n+1 doesn't mean it's not part of the universe. It would also allow expansion of the n-dimension brane.
Do you know of cosmological models proposing an infinite number of spatial dimensions?
EDIT: Note that the "expansion of the universe" is really only "expansion we observe through telescopes." I've never heard anything about astronomical observations concerning dimensions S, 6, or others. 3D space can easily expand without the need for anything outside the universe, in a universe of more than 3 dimensions.
- sp332 17y agoI'm saying that there are a finite number of dimensions - maybe a dozen or less. They all exist inside the universe. "Outside" the universe, there are no dimensions. There is no space or time. There is actually no "place" for you to "go" outside the universe. It only makes sense to say that the universe is expanding by measuring the space and matter in it. There is no measuring stick outside to hold the universe up to.
- stcredzero 17y agoWhat happened to empiricism? Where's your evidence that dimensions other than the 3 we can see are expanding? Waiting for the light bulb...
- sp332 17y agoBy "n" I thought you meant all the dimensions in the universe, not just 3+time. Like you were inventing new dimensions to expand into. So never mind that part. But just because the dimensions we see are expanding, doesn't mean they are expanding into other dimensions we can't see. Here I ask you for some empiricism - what's your evidence? To modify the balloon example, just imagine a flat rubber sheet that is stretched to be a little bigger. No extra dimensions necessary.
- stcredzero 17y agoTrue, that, but we do have empirical evidence that spacetime is not flat.
- sp332 17y ago"Not flat" doesn't mean wrinkled into other dimensions. Again, it's just a metaphor/visualization, not a direct representation. It's like this image: http://sparrow.stanford.edu/~chumakov/images/grids-negative-P.png http://sparrow.stanford.edu/~chumakov/images/grids-negative-... The 2D space has "negative curvature," but it doesn't bend into a third dimension. It's still flat.