9 ms·
I am as concerned about climate change as anyone. I think it's the most serious problem we face today. But it is very important to keep some perspective here,
by lisper 10y ago
I am as concerned about climate change as anyone. I think it's the most serious problem we face today. But it is very important to keep some perspective here, if for no other reason, so that we who believe this is a serious problem don't lose credibility in the political battles to come.
1. Earth is not going to become Venus. The surface of Venus is hot enough to melt lead, hot enough to completely sterilize the planet. That is not going to happen here even under an absolute worst-case scenario.
2. Homo sapiens is almost certainly not going to go extinct even in a worst-case scenario. We are a very robust species capable of adapting to an extraordinarily wide variety of situations. We are very, very tough to kill en masse. We ourselves have tried to wipe out segments of our own population in the past and barely made a dent. The biggest killer in our history, bubonic plague, barely killed a third of us.
3. What is at risk, and what IMHO is worrisome, is the modern technological civilization we have built for ourselves. Our infrastructure and political systems are highly dependent on a stable climate. If we lose that, would could easily go back to the middle ages. (We probably won't go back to neolithic times because knowledge is also pretty robust, and we will almost certainly be able to keep basic technologies alive. But a Mad-Max type scenario is a real possibility.)
4. Colonizing the moon or other planets won't save us. All extra-terrestrial environments accessible to use with current technology are much harsher than earth will be even in a worst-case scenario. If we and our civilization can't survive here, we can't survive anywhere.
- susan_hall 10y agoI am surprised you were downvoted. The 4 points you make seem straightforward, and are accurate. The timeline for economic damage (from global warming) is fairly long. Even in the worst-case scenario, the Earth as we know it is still recognizable for the next 50 years, and all of the seasons and climate patterns remain roughly the same. The major changes will tend to show 50 to a 100 years from now. Also, I'd like to point out that the increasing acidity of the oceans is a much worse problem, in the long-term, than the warming of the atmosphere. Carbon washes out of the atmosphere, and ends up as acid in the oceans. At current trends, in less than 100 years the oceans will be more acidic than at any point since the Cambrian Revolution. It is not clear that life in the oceans can survive with those levels of acidity (other than organisms that live in volcanic vents and love acid).
- civilian 10y agoI suspect that some of the life in the ocean _could_ adapt, if they were not also being over-fished (or having their prey over-fished). You need a large population for variations to crop up, and then some period of time for the beneficial variations to spread out. 50-100 years is _breakneck_ speed as far as evolution goes, but if you have an annual-breeding fish then they could get 50-100 generations to adapt. Whales & dolphins may have a bad time though.
- lisper 10y agoThis is exactly the kind of hyperbole I'm talking about. Whales and dolphins and fish are not the totality of life in the oceans. There's krill and algae and bacteria and a bazillion other things. Now, losing whales and dolphins and fish would be catastrophic (IMO). But that is not the same as losing all life. It is not that "some of the life in the ocean could adapt." Life in the ocean (and on land) will adapt, no question about it. It just might not be the kind of life we humans want to see. That is the problem.
- lisper 10y ago> I am surprised you were downvoted. I'm not. Many people seem to have lost sight of what downvotes are supposed to mean on HN. They are supposed to mean, "This comment is not constructive." Instead, people use it to mean, "I don't agree with this." So controversial opinions often get downvoted into oblivion rather quickly. It's damned annoying, especially when people don't follow up with any explanation of why they disagree. > It is not clear that life in the oceans can survive with those levels of acidity Actually, that's pretty clear. Some kind of life will survive, even if it's just bacteria and jellyfish. Life is incredibly robust. This is exactly the kind of hyperbole that undermines the arguments for policy changes. This is not to say that acidification is not a serious problem. It is. But not because it will sterilize the ocean. It won't.
- greglindahl 10y agoI downvoted because the comment wasn't a response to the article, nor did it really seem to be responding to other comments. I agree that many people make the same complaint you do, claiming that many downvoters are simply disagreeing with content. You might want to consider topicality, too.
- wallace_f 10y ago> a Mad-Max type scenario is a real possibility. Can you please substantiate this conclusion?
- lisper 10y agoSure. There are any number of ways that climate change could destroy civilization. It could do it directly. For example, weather could get so extreme that it could directly destroy our infrastructure faster than we can rebuild it. Weather anomalies could destroy our ability to produce enough food to feed everyone. A catastrophic melting of the Greenland ice cap could raise sea levels to the point where all of the world's coastal cities would be inundated, and it could happen much faster than we could rebuild elsewhere (to say nothing of the fact that global commerce currently depends crucially on stable coast lines so we can have ports). But much more likely is not the direct destruction of civilization, but rather increased political and economic tensions leading to nuclear war. Climate change is going to lead to a global game of musical chairs as the world's powers vie for ownership of what used to be arctic tundra but is soon to be prime farmland, or what used to be polar ice cap and is soon to be rich oil fields. People are already starting to quibble over who owns the northwest passage (is it an international waterway, or does it belong to Canada?) That didn't matter when you couldn't get through because it was filled with ice. When the ice clears and it becomes a prime shipping route, it matters a lot.
- wallace_f 10y ago>But much more likely is not the direct destruction of civilization, but rather increased political and economic tensions leading to nuclear war. Ah, I see that you and I actually do agree that the much more likely case is not a Mad Max scenario, and I agree political tension is the greatest danger. The worst case scenario is we see innocent people needlessly die due to the actions of other people--whether it be squabbling over who caused climate change, or over newly found resources it created, or migrations of peoples whose homelands have been destroyed. I really don't want that to happen. >Weather anomalies could destroy our ability to produce enough food to feed everyone. That is a good point, and a great reason why we should stop altering the global environment. It may not be that the ability to produce food is destroyed in the long run, but in the short run we struggle to adapt quickly enough to a changing environment--a topic for debate but certainly one for worry. While I concede there's no evidence this will necessarily happen, the fact is we simply don't know what we're doing when it comes to global climate science, and we're historically great at screwing up the planet with unintended consequences. So we should stop. >weather could get so extreme that it could directly destroy our infrastructure faster than we can rebuild it. While of course anything is possible, can you link me to scientific evidence that this will happen. Of course, there is in fact evidence that weather extremes will increase, the likelihood of this scenario where we literally cannot sustain infrastructure on the planet anymore, that would require very extreme weather and a loss of current technology (there already exists technology to build infrastructure which can withstand harsh weather and earthquakes). I don't have a problem with the science, but the doomsday or "Mad Max" alarmist scenarios are not based in science, and that kind of irrational thinking may do more harm than good--leading to even more irrational thinking.
- riffic 10y ago>Homo sapiens is almost certainly not going to go extinct even in a worst-case scenario. This is an incredibly arrogant assumption.
- burke 10y agoI don't think this is true. Even with an unbreathable atmosphere, some tiny fraction of humans would survive with recycled air, solar power, and greenhouse vegetables. It's conceivable that climate change could kill 99%+. I would be very surprised if it exterminated us completely.
- anon1253 10y agoNot long ago I thought the same thing. We can live on the ISS, so even if there's no oxygen and temperatures will be perpetually 200ºC above current, I'm sure we can construct habitats (even small cities) that could be self-sustaining and live. But here's the catch: these things don't happen instantly. It's not a turn-based RPG where somebody decides one turn to "build self-sustaining, hermetically sealed arks", before these things become an absolute necessity we may have already lost the infrastructural or technological abilities to do so (even the raw materials come from /everywhere/ on Earth these days). Worse yet, when the social-economic inequality is the difference between life and death, I'm sure a lot of people will be very angry. And very angry people do stupid things. So you build an ark to live, but not everyone outside is truly dead yet, I'm very sure these people would like to get in. Destructively.
- cel1ne 10y ago> 1. Earth is not going to become Venus Not sure about that on a couple-of-hundred-years-from-now time-scale. > 2. Homo sapiens is almost certainly not going to go extinct. I agree. But it's possible that 90% of humanity dies, mainly because of starvation after the oceans become lifeless. I also think there are going to be massive refugee streams in the order of more than 100 million people.
- lisper 10y ago> Not sure about that on a couple-of-hundred-years-from-now time-scale. It's really not possible. Even if you took all of the oxygen and carbon on earth and converted it to CO2 (which is not even remotely possible) you still wouldn't get Venus. Venus's atmosphere is almost 100 times denser than earth, and it's nearly 100% CO2. Venus is also closer to the sun, which isn't the deciding factor, but it certainly helps keep Venus nice and toasty warm. Look, earth is 4 billion years old, and life has existed for about 3.9 billion of those, give or take a few hundred million years. Environmental catastrophes have come and gone and life has persisted through all of them. But civilization has only existed for 10,000 years or so, and those 10,000 years have been climactically stable. Unusually stable. It is far from clear that civilization can survive climate change. That experiment has never been done. > it's possible that 90% of humanity dies Yes, that is definitely possible. Maybe even likely if we stay on the current trajectory.
- wcoenen 10y ago> you still wouldn't get Venus. Venus's atmosphere is almost 100 times denser than earth, and it's nearly 100% CO2 That extremely high amount of CO2 in the atmosphere of Venus is not the original cause but a consequence of runaway warming. At a few hundred degrees C, the carbon dioxide bound in rocks starts to sublimate into the atmosphere. For example, limestone would go CaCO3 -> CaO + CO2. 10% of all sedimentary rock is limestone so one can see how that leads to a Venus-like atmosphere. That said, I agree that a Venus scenario doesn't seem to be possible for Earth right now. In this paper published in Nature, even 3000 ppm of CO2 (i.e. all fossil fuels burned) was calculated not to trigger such a thing. It would require more like 30,000 ppm, which is not really breathable atmosphere anymore: http://www.nature.com/ngeo/journal/v6/n8/full/ngeo1892.html http://www.nature.com/ngeo/journal/v6/n8/full/ngeo1892.html Coverage in scientific american: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/fact-or-fiction-runaway-greenhouse/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/fact-or-fiction-r...
- _ph_ 10y agoPoint 3 is the one that matters. We still have the ability to keep our current civilization alive. We don't even have to change our life style at a large scale. Switching from coal and oil to solar and wind should be a no brainer. It is even widely cost-efficient. People, who think that a few windmills are an offensive sight, are not considering how different life for all of us would be, if we do not act in time.