8 ms·
> white men have been more powerful than white women or black men in the West So how do we define power in this context. If members of the group has conflictin
by belorn 10y ago
> white men have been more powerful than white women or black men in the West
So how do we define power in this context. If members of the group has conflicting goals and conflicting interests, how do the group as a whole "get their way most of the time"?
We could use a proxy like wealth and work position, but that leaves us with the problem that quite explicit in the Chinese culture. If men are culturally forced to seek wealth and profession, is that power? When there such major incentive for men to seek wealth, which I will emphasize by cite OkCupid (West data) statistics blog: "If you're 23 or older [male] and don't make much money, go die in a fire". The effect of wealth for men is as correlating and explicit as looks are for women.
Comparing white men with black men works better using that proxy, through there is additional factors. The most powerful factor for wealth is being born by wealthy parents (per any article I have read on the subject of wealth). Unless a nation has an immigration that matches the wealth of people currently living there, those people are going to be at a major statistical disadvantage in their ability to gather new wealth.
Politics is however a nice proxy for checking if a group is getting their way most of the time, since plenty of political decision intentionally impacts group of people. When balanced in respect to wealth, do schools in black areas get less funding/focus then schools in white areas? Do parks get more built/funded in white areas than black areas? If so, is it because of the political representation (ie, since black population in the US is 8%, the 92% will carry a majority in all decision and in theory dominate any decision). This is part of the problem why most nation aren't rule by popularity vote, since high population density of cities would dominate the lower population of the rural area and carry a majority in all political decisions. However, the cost to such system is that all votes don't counts as equal, and all system that I know of is based on land and not on race.
> It's unlikely that feminists would emphasize a biological cause
A common comment I see is that new feminism is extremism, and they don't represent the mass movement that view everyone as humans. While I do hope that is true, key note speakers on tech conferences is heavily weighted in the new feminism camp, and when it comes to political activism, there seem few who represent the view that cultural roles and values in gender and race is harmful.
- pron 10y ago> how do the group as a whole "get their way most of the time"? I think you're making the mistake of confusing intent with outcome. Power, like pressure, is a statistical property. Gas particles don't need intent in order to have communal properties. Also, I think you're associating judgment with power, as if someone is saying that having power is bad. I think it's important to first understand what power is as a neutral attribute, and only then understand the criticism (which, BTW, boils done to "with power comes responsibility"). > If men are culturally forced to seek wealth and profession, is that power? Yes. Again, power is not about how you feel and what you want, but what you have. I know nothing of Chinese culture, but Chinese men may suffer terribly from stress and depression, but they still have power. > since plenty of political decision intentionally impacts group of people. Right, but, again, we're talking statistics here. If some decisions affect me negatively and some affect me positively, but overall, 80% are positive for me and 80% are bad for you for, say, the past 50 years, then, obviously, there's something going on here. > the 92% will carry a majority in all decision and in theory dominate any decision Being a majority is a great source of power. If the majority doesn't treat the minority equally, that's discrimination. > and they don't represent the mass movement that view everyone as humans. You may be more sensitive to these things than me, but I don't think you're being fair. "Black lives matter" isn't about white lives. It points out that blacks are discriminated against and that should stop. Feminism, old as new, points out the discrimination and unfair distribution of power between men and women. It's not about men's problems. If I'm getting mugged and I yell, "help, someone is mugging me", I don't think it's fair to say, "why aren't you also yelling for the woman getting raped two blocks over?!" Advocacy groups are supposed to focus on one problem, or one kind of problems. Simply saying "everybody has problems" may be absolutely true, but would terrible advocacy. Also, distinction between new and old advocacy is pretty much a constant. People always say, we were fine letting you have what you asked for yesterday (even though they really weren't fine), but now you're asking for too much or stepping out of line.
- belorn 10y ago> Yes. Again, power is not about how you feel and what you want, but what you have. Knowing the source is critical to solve a problem. If cultural pressure is the source, shouldn't it be solved? Seems a bit to me like blaming black people for being in prison, demanding that they should fix the issue of being jailed more than white people. A key feature of science is to figure out and understand how a system works and what affects it. How successful has efforts in the past been in trying to get people that are forced into a situation to also fix the problem of being forced? > If some decisions affect me negatively and some affect me positively This was part of what I was wondering about. Could you define in what way 80% of decisions have been positive for say, men in general in the last 30 years? In order for things to be positive for the group as a whole, the decision can't be significant contradicting within the group. I can't think of any interest that is that exclusively an interests to men but the opposite for women, and carries a significant majority. > If the majority doesn't treat the minority equally, that's discrimination. Should 8% get equal 50% influence? With winner take all decision, majority will always dominate the minority. In an election, the winning 51% get 100% representation, while the loosing 49% get 0%. That is not equal, and many nation solve this in a imperfect way by having more than 2 party system, through practically all retain some limits. A problem with the word discrimination in this context is that intent is lost. 92% voting what they want and 8% voting for something else is generally not considered discrimination since the 92% don't intentionally try to miss treat the 8%. You need intent for discrimination, which is by its nature create before the end result. > Advocacy groups are supposed to focus on one problem, or one kind of problems. A common reply I get, but there is three major issues with it. First, feminism proclaims to be about gender equality, and over half its existence the movement stood for that. Its only in the last 30 years that the movement changed course. Second, having an alternative movement that focus on Mens Right is bad for everyone. Equality don't need to have competition between two polar movements. If your house on fire, the fix is not to use fans and try to cool it down. Having two polar movements with the same goal is only causing less understanding, more fighting, and less empathy, and shouldn't a movement about equality stand for more than that? Third, it should be said that sex segregation has only gotten worse in the last 30 years, a trend that many people are surprisingly surprised about. Difference feminism is sometimes, rather hushed, accused of this, and I don't disagree. > we were fine letting you have what you asked for yesterday Except when that what people asked yesterday, and what people are asking tomorrow, is polar opposites. One side want people to be treated equally regardless of gender and race. The other side want people to be treated different based on gender and race, but demand that the outcome to be equal. You can only fulfill the later demand by taking back the earlier and reversing progress. > "Black lives matter" I always found that adding the word "too" transforms the message. I also think it is way too early to evaluate the movement, as it could go as black panther movement and be about guns and violence, or it could be about reducing murder caused by racial tensions. The later has general support in society. As a side note: Thanks for the link to Jonathan Haidt talk. Very interesting, through I have heard some exception to the left politics being pro-science and pro-lenience with crime. In particular, feminist (assuming left) groups successfully lobbied to prevent medical research on causes for rape, with statements that such research could result in lower jail sentences and people avoiding justice with insanity pleas.