3 ms·
Writing has developed independently between two and five times (Mesoamerica and Sumer for sure, maybe China, Egypt, India in decreasing order of likeliness). Al
by jcranmer 10y ago
Writing has developed independently between two and five times (Mesoamerica and Sumer for sure, maybe China, Egypt, India in decreasing order of likeliness). All of these start with a logographic script, which then gets filtered into a syllabalic component. Egypt dropped the vowels from its representation, having its characters represent only consonants--this was adapted by the Phoenicians. The Greeks took the Phoenician script, repurposed some of the characters representing consonants they didn't have into vowels, and created the first true alphabet (whence Latin, Cyrillic, Georgian, and Armenian, basically every true alphabet in the world). The Arabics and Hebrews adapted the script into their modern abjads (where vowels are marked, if ever, by diacritics), while the abugidas developed (where vowels are indicated by systematic manipulation of consonants) in India by debatable means.
Alphabets, abjads, and abugidas were effectively independently invented only once (it's debatable to what degree the creators of Hangul were aware of other alphabets). Syllabries appear to be the very natural development of writing.