4 ms·
This is one reason I'm not particularly fond of Mozilla. They care too much about ideology, PR and all that stuff. They have had the code but won't release it b
by zokier 17y ago
This is one reason I'm not particularly fond of Mozilla. They care too much about ideology, PR and all that stuff. They have had the code but won't release it because it could make them look bad or annoy some web devs or doesn't fit their ideology. Why can't they just release stuff and see how it fares, and improve it based on public's response.
- mbrubeck 17y agoIt's not just about ideology and PR... it's about keeping our users secure. And the "ideology" has a very pragmatic side: it's about keeping the web based on actual standards that can evolve rather than defacto standards that we will have to live with forever. We're dealing with this on the Mozilla Mobile team because of touch events. There is no standard for touch events in browsers. Mobile Safari and Android both implement touch events, and their implementations are partly compatible and partly incompatible. Mobile Firefox could choose to take one of those implementations and copy it. In the short term it would make us more compatible with some existing iPhone-optimized sites. But in the long run it would raise the barrier for getting web sites (and browser vendors) to switch to an actual standardized API. So we're going to try to get the WHATWG to agree on a standard for touch events before we implement them rather than after. The standards process is not just about ideology - it often catches significant design and security flaws, as it has with WebSockets. It's much harder to change an API once you've shipped it to a userbase like Mozilla's (hundreds of millions of people - around 30% of all internet users). Remember the story about Stuart Feldman when he was asked to make the Makefile syntax more sensible? He said he couldn't, because there were already over a dozen people using it.
- FooBarWidget 17y agoNot caring about ideology is what got us into the IE6 mess in the first place.
- Shorel 17y agoI disagree. Not caring about ideology over technology is what got us Chrome. The Embrace, Extend, Extinguish destructive MS ideology is what got us into the IE6 mess.
- FooBarWidget 17y agoYou know what got you Chrome? WebKit. WebKit started as KHTML which was developed by an ideological group named KDE.
- zokier 17y agoKDE, an ideological group? Really? I've found KDE people to be very pragmatic, not ideological. KDE's history and their choice of Qt also supports that, remember that FSF (there's an ideological group for ya) rejected KDE for some time, and creted Gnome to compete with it purely for ideological reasons. KDE in comparison was created because the founder felt the need for a good desktop environment for unixy systems.
- Shorel 17y agoWebkit was a substandard web rendering platform until Apple and Google invested a lot of man-hours in it.