6 ms·
There are so many things wrong with Jobs explanation I don't know where to begin. But two claims really pisses me off. Battery Life If I activate push notifi
by ThomPete 17y ago
There are so many things wrong with Jobs explanation I don't know where to begin.
But two claims really pisses me off.
Battery Life
If I activate push notification it sure isn't nice to my battery. So I switch it off.
The same thing could be done with flash. Or even better, make flash an opt in. What's the problem.
Yes I know apple can claim that it will affect peoples impression of their products, but so do not having flash.
Touch
This really is a strawman of enormous proportions.
First. There are plenty of html pages out there that have roll-over. Plenty of menus that expand as you roll over them.
Second. Rollover states is not a problem for most flash websites that users use. In fact Apple could simply allow for rollovers to be activated on push down and click on release.
I love apples products, but they are simply in the wrong here. I love my iPad but not being able to see flash sites is really getting quite annoying.
- yan 17y agoI don't understand why you reacted so strongly to the roll over argument. Jobs didn't state roll overs as the raison d'etre for not including Flash, he simply used it as yet another example why the tools and, more importantly, thinking of the previous generation of web developers will not advance the platform forward. (As an example, I have been frustrated at some sites reliance of roll overs when using my iPhone). The battery life argument is also stronger than you make it seem. When users turn on push notifications, the phone warns you of a reduced battery life (also, when enabling 3G) and is usually not toggled by the majority of the population. Flash is much more insidious; it will live in the browser and to the average user, will just be a part of normal browsing. Ditto for watching movies over flash.
- ThomPete 17y agoThe touch argument just isn't valid. What exactly is it that can't be done with flash just because it's a touch environment. Flash don't care about what the input is. It will listen for what you ask it to listen to. Regarding battery life And why couldn't the phone warn you off reduced battery life if you turn on flash? You simply make it an opt in, the first time someone is running flash you overlay a warning saying that flash reduces battery life and you can turn that warning off. Its simple interaction design, apple are masters at that. None of the problems stated can't be solved or are not already there with regular html (rollovers on plenty of normal html sites)
- yan 17y agoThese are all problems that could be solved, this isn't the argument. The argument here is solving them is not in everyone's best interest and is artificially keeping the platform in the past. edit: why are you so angry? Apple are providing a beautiful product at a great price to the public. If it doesn't have a feature you want, buy another product that supports it. I never understood being angry at a company because of not putting effort into what you think they should be putting effort into.
- ThomPete 17y agoWhat do you mean with in everyone's best interest? Everyone includes the millions of flash sites and flash developers out there that do fantastic work. Flash isn't a feature it's as ingrained a part of the web as HTML is and surely much more than HTML5. I like apples products I fully accept that they don't want to put flash on there even though I disagree. But his answer isn't an answer, it's not a counter argument as many of those problems he states aren't really problems that are flash related.
- wfarr 17y ago"I don't understand why you reacted so strongly to the roll over argument. Jobs didn't state roll overs as the raison d'etre for not including Flash." This is why: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Straw_man http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Straw_man
- ThomPete 17y ago"Flash was designed for PCs using mice, not for touch screens using fingers. For example, many Flash websites rely on “rollovers”, which pop up menus or other elements when the mouse arrow hovers over a specific spot. Apple’s revolutionary multi-touch interface doesn’t use a mouse, and there is no concept of a rollover." Flash don't care. You are not forced to use rollovers in flash you can but you are not forced to do it. Drag and drop is a historical mouse feature. You have that on the iPad too. So apples touch is not more revolutionary than it still uses these. Every other mouse metaphor is in use besides rollover.
- wfarr 17y agoNo — they don't have to use rollover. But the fact of the matter is, particularly with games but also to some extent websites (navigation), that many (perhaps the majority) do. Apple is speaking about the state of things as they are, not how they could possibly be if people so chose for them to be that way.
- ThomPete 17y agoBut that is true for so many HTML/js sites too and nothing absolutely nothing prohibits people from playing flash games with a touch interface. Most flash games are point and click
- marknutter 17y agoMaking flash opt-in wouldn't solve the problem. The VAST majority of non-technical users will not know about or use that setting and will blame Apple for the poor battery life, not Adobe. It's a lot about saving face here. Apple wants to be in control of their own success, which becomes hard to do when you're allowing proprietary technologies to run on their hardware. Jobs points out his frustration with Adobe taking so long to adopt Cocoa - this is just him trying to avoid a similar situation on the iPhone. Speak for yourself about the lack of flash on the iPad, I consider it a feature on mine. 90% of the videos I run across on the web on my iPad are youtube or vimeo videos and work perfectly.
- ThomPete 17y agoI am speaking for myself, who else do you think I am speaking for? Regarding making flash an opt in being a problem. It's a pure interaction problem. By no metrics is it harder than to turn push notification on and off or setting your time.
- ThomPete 17y agoBy all means who ever voted me down. Prove me wrong.
- vetinari 17y agoYou know, what draws most of the juice from the battery? 1) Radio, 2) Display. These two facts made VAST majority of non-technical users aware, that the more they use their gadget, the shorter the battery life is. Fortunately for them, Flash is pretty much interactive, it does not run in background and does not draw energy when the users thinks it is off. It is pretty easy for the users to comprehend that they were using flash and that's why the battery is empty.
- eli 17y agore: battery life, if you want a phone that is infinitely tweakable get a Nexus One. Apple devices are unapologetic about restricting you in ways that Apple thinks provide for a better user experience.
- nitrogen 17y agoSimple solution: use the accelerometer to aim a mouse cursor for sites with rollovers. I don't suggest Apple implement that, but some app developer could, or maybe Adobe.