4 ms·
I think the main argument for abolishing corporate taxes is that they're inherently regressive, if we assume that the taxes get passed on to either consumers (w
by crazygringo 10y ago
I think the main argument for abolishing corporate taxes is that they're inherently regressive, if we assume that the taxes get passed on to either consumers (who may be poor) in the form of higher prices, or investors (like grandma holding retirement shares) in the form of lower stock prices.
There's certainly an argument to made that corporate taxes should be abolished, and personal taxes increased instead (income and capital gains), where we can ensure that the equivalent amount of taxation is applied progressively, through higher tax rates on the rich.
Because the key thing to remember is, corporations don't exist on their own -- they have human owners. So if you tax the rich owners directly, instead of taxing the corporation, you can get the same money but with finer-grained control -- you can progressively tax the rich owners more, and grandma's pension less.
(Of course, if you don't believe in progressive taxation, then corporate tax, sales tax, property tax, etc. are all just fine.)
- moron4hire 10y agoAlso, most people aren't employed by the type of giganto corporations people are mentioning in this thread, like Google or Apple. Most people are employed by the very long tail of small businesses, whose owners are decidedly not ultrarich demigods. From your small consultancies to the sort of cafe I'm sitting in right now, lowering the corporate income tax will have a huge impact on how many people they can employ and what sort of prices they can charge. All of the small business owners I know don't want to make themselves absurdly rich. They just want to have a comfortable, middle-class life and help other people do the same.
- tomp 10y agoWhy would taxes be passed onto customers? The goal of the company is to optimize pre-tax profit, regardless of what kind of tax is slapped on top of it (as long as that tax isn't 100%).
- crazygringo 10y ago"The cost of corporate taxes are usually split between the companies and the customers." http://www.cs.cmu.edu/~ref/econ101e.html http://www.cs.cmu.edu/~ref/econ101e.html
- candiodari 10y agoAll taxes are regressive in that sense of the word. Taxes on income have the exact same problem. The net result is "higher prices" (in terms of % of your monthly paycheck). Every single tax. Every last one. The problem is that rich people cheat "legally". They control the companies as well. What companies did in the years of those very high company and personal taxes is to have "executive perks". Now those exist today (and to some extent are defensible, e.g. I understand why the CEO of IBM needs some security). The costs for those were then costs of the company. So companies would lure shareholders in those days by making sure a 1% stake in the company would guarantee a director-level position in the company, which came with free use of a company yacht, plane, very low rent on company-owned housing, ... E.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Club_33 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Club_33
- crazygringo 10y agoYou can't redefine words to mean what you want them to mean. Some taxes are progressive, some are regressive. A progressive tax means you pay a greater % of taxes, the more money you have -- like income tax in the US. That's just the definition. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Progressive_tax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Progressive_tax
- slv77 10y agoNot all corporations are domestically owned and the owners that you propose to tax may reside outside US tax jurisdiction. Lowering corporate tax rates and raising domestic taxes would effectively mean that foreign owners of US corporations would effectively have a profit advantage over domestic owners. Also corporations have a lot of discretion in when they distribute profits. A zero tax rate would effectively create the equivalent of an unlimited 401K/IRA. The corporate tax rates the US has today are in many ways the result of the high personal tax rates in the 70's that resulted in a lot of people creating what the IRS called "personal holding corporations" to defer taxes. Does it make sense that a guy working for a $150K wage would be limited to deferring $16K in income while a consultant working for the same amount could defer taxes on any amount over what he chose to spend?
- crazygringo 10y agoThere’s nothing to prevent taxing foreign owners of domestic corporations separately to make up for that -- taxation across borders is a separate issue. As for deferrals, it's the same as with capital gains -- if you have a $1 stock that grows to $1,000, your taxes are deferred until you sell it. A greater harmonization of tax deferral period is a good idea. Either everybody should get to do it, or nobody. But this is a separate issue, that should be totally divorced from corporate tax.
- slv77 10y agoThe ability to defer income through capital gains is an extremely limited vehicle to defer income when compared to being able to accumulate profits in a corporation tax free. Assume that you have a business that generates $500,000 dollars in profits and you'd like to defer taxes. In the US under section 179 you can defer those taxes by investing in depreciating capital equipment such as computers, trucks or medical equipment. Obviously investing in depreciating capital equipment only allows you to defer taxes if it in the future allows you to expand your business and generate at least the same amount of income. In addition to being capped, and phasing out, the rules are very specific to prevent the system from being gamed. For example, you can't use those deductions to invest in real-estate. To effectively defer taxes for 10-20 years would require that over that time you were able to find profitable ways to invest those profits to expand your business. Trust me that finding profitable investments over a 10-20 year horizon is an extremely difficult thing to do and requires significant talent that is in limited supply. Allowing those people to defer taxes and re-invest profits is a win-win-win for the owner, the government and citizens. Compare that to corporations that could accumulate profits tax free. Essentially unlimited amounts of funds could be accumulated in the corporation tax free with no personal obligation to find effective ways to deploy those funds. Those funds can be held and grow tax free until needed in retirement where they can be meted out at favorable tax rates or left for heirs. They would even more favorable than traditional IRA and 401Ks because they wouldn't have required distributions. While its true that corporate taxes in the US are out-of-line with other developed economies which has distorted the economy in some ways dramatically lowering corporate tax rates without implementing rules requiring distribution of corporate profits and implementing taxes on a foreign holders creates a tax loophole so large that you could drive a truck through it. Of course you'll hear the Wall Street Journal talk about how this is 'good' for the US economy because it will allow corporation to 'reinvest' which will lead to all sorts of good things for everybody but the corporate owners. Oddly enough there is never talk about expanding limits on 401K's and IRAs and allowing the middle class to defer taxes.
- crdoconnor 10y ago>I think the main argument for abolishing corporate taxes is that they're inherently regressive, if we assume that the taxes get passed on to either consumers (who may be poor) in the form of higher prices, or investors (like grandma holding retirement shares) in the form of lower stock prices. You can assume anything you like but in reality, grandma doesn't own the majority of US stocks, the 1% does and the tax incidence doesn't land on consumers it lands almost entirely on shareholders. Sales tax is an example of a tax incidence that lands mostly just on consumers.
- crazygringo 10y agoWhat do you think grandma's savings are tied up in? A significant share of it is in equities. And it's completely irrelevant what percentage of corporations are owned by savers in the 99% vs the 1% -- corporate taxes lower the value of those shares for all of them equally. They hit grandma just as hard.