4 ms·
The US attitude towards immigration is completely asinine and driven by ignorance. Immigrants are a huge sector in the economy. This WSJ article, like so many
by austincheney 10y ago
The US attitude towards immigration is completely asinine and driven by ignorance. Immigrants are a huge sector in the economy.
This WSJ article, like so many others, is part of that ignorance in that it isn't about low skill or low pay workers. It is about filling jobs, regardless of pay rate, that US citizens are not willing to fill. A prime example is software developers.
In the US software developers make 2x to 3x the national average pay rate for full time labor. Despite the high pay rate and comfortable work environment there is a massive demand for skills that is not being filled domestically. From 1995-2005 there was a massive off-shoring to find low cost software developers. Since 2010 the off-shoring is entirely about finding competent employees to fill labor shortages opposed to reducing expenses. Americans are not willing to step up and take these available software development jobs at a level of competence demanded by employers regardless of pay rate.
A popular bitch-fest on reddit is that software developers are paid too low and if they were paid more this problem would be magically solved. First of all there is absolutely no evidence to suggest such. Secondly, software developers are already paid well and still there are massive shortages with high attrition. These problems are not related to pay rates, but are deeper rooted issues more related to outdated skills, low confidence, missing initiative, and poor education. These deeper problems are a hard pill to swallow considering they require some amount of time and investment and still result in an substandard result.
- yardie 10y agoI've looked into some of those jobs and the guys on Reddit are right. A lot of those jobs don't pay shit. Developers will get paid 2-3x the national average in major cities and tech hubs. Outside of that expect an honest offer of 38-45k. I've been in that call with a recruiter trying to fill a job in flyover state. I felt sorry for him because he really had an impossible task. He had gone through surrounding towns and states slowly widening that circle until he was now trying to find talent on the coasts. His client needed a developer with SC clearance but was offering low pay, stale benefits, and no relocation. No wonder he was having problems filling the job. If you want skilled developers with modern skills be prepared to pay for it.
- austincheney 10y agoI work in a major metropolitan area (one of the 4 largest in the US). There is a large educated sector of the population and a huge number of software and technology companies here. Still, despite this, technology jobs cannot be filled. Half my coworkers have always been immigrants. Even when pay is high local people are not stepping up to fill the positions. If you are in technology you can only continue to ignore that you work with a large number of immigrants and offshore teams for so long. Eventually, you will have to keep up with current skills, move to a low income market, or be content with being replaced by an immigrant who has more initiative. > If you want skilled developers with modern skills be prepared to pay for it. There is no evidence that increased rates have solved this problem as demand continues to outpace availability.
- yardie 10y agoI've worked with smart domestic and immigrant workers. I've also worked with incompetent domestic and immigrant workers. There is a shortage of talent and there is abuse of immigrant worker vidas. These are both indisputable. Even I, an American expat, is an immigrant worker. I'm well compensated for my work. And that's how it should be. But there are employers m that abuse h1b, E, and L visa schemes and they prefer the system just he way it is. Abusing immigrant workers and undermining domestic wages.
- geebee 10y agoI've discussed this with a lot of people. Why do you feel the "shortage" isn't a rational response to wages and working conditions? Do you think none of the US citizens who became nurse anesthetists, physicians, or lawyers were capable of becoming programmers? I suspect many of them could have, but realized that better working conditions and wages were available in other fields. This doesn't really many much to do with immigration - the 1.2 million immigrants the US takes in every year are, like people born here, generally free to pursue their profession or trade in response to their own personal interests and market signals. Interestingly, among 300 million US citizens and 1.2 million new arrivals every year, software employers continue to experience a shortage. I'm glad you feel well compensated, but the real test is whether someone who is free to pursue other fields chooses to pursue this one. I see the restrictions of these visas as inherently anti-market. I actually see them as anti-freedom. If you can't compete for the labor of free people, people who are free to choose their field, then you don't deserve workers. Setting up a coercive visa program that allows immigrants into the country only if they agree to work as software developers seems like a magnificently bad way to solve this problem. I'm also very confident that in the absence of this crutch, employers would absolutely find a way to improve wages and working conditions, to the point where people with choice (a group that includes all immigrants who came here freely) might be more interested in it again. If you create a large scale program that staffs this field with people who have no choice in the job they work, I assure you, eventually the only people who work it will be the ones who have no other choice.
- sk5t 10y ago> Americans are not willing to step up and take these available software development jobs at a level of competence demanded by employers regardless of pay rate. Do you honestly believe this? There's an easy test against it: post a hard-to-fill job at $50K salary, increase it by $3K per day posted. Within a couple months you will start to see desirable applicants.
- austincheney 10y ago> Do you honestly believe this? Absolutely. Most of the time I have interviewed for a job in the past I am the guy picked out of 20-25 applicants. Its not because I am a rock star or something special. It is because most of these people are horribly under qualified. People want to get paid more, but are often not willing to invest the effort to make higher wages a reality. The common solution (band-aid) for this problem... frameworks.
- sk5t 10y agoPointing to your record as an interviewee is like saying "you always find your keys in the last place you look." Tech hiring is hard, and the glut of candidates pumping up their resumes with nonsense makes it harder still, but nothing about this suggests that Americans don't _want_ the jobs... the job postings just didn't attract a high proportion of very good applicants, whether due to company status, pay, location, or some other factors.