4 ms·
The result of the popular vote reflected the media's interpretation of pre-election polls: she won by a strong margin, millions of votes. Trump still won the pr
by pavlov 10y ago
The result of the popular vote reflected the media's interpretation of pre-election polls: she won by a strong margin, millions of votes. Trump still won the presidency thanks to the peculiar American system that emphasizes the mostly arbitrary state lines over popular representation.
Because the results of a single state can swing the total so wildly out of proportion with the state's population, doing recounts against the paper trail (which otherwise would never get looked at) seems like a reasonable thing to do.
- akvadrako 10y agoThe electoral college is not some new information the media wasn't aware of, so it doesn't make sense to say it explains their story about how she couldn't lose.
- davrosthedalek 10y agoThe popular vote is meaningless. Everybody knew the system. There is no incentive to vote in states-not-perceived-as-swing-states. It's not clear from this election who would have one a straight up popular vote. Also: The voting system America has is an important step to protect minority groups, that is, small population states. Maybe the winner-takes-all in the states has to be modified.
- SomeStupidPoint 10y agoThe president is meant to represent the populace more closely than it does, as should the House. The Senate is meant to protect less populace states. Really, the problem is capping the number of representatives at around 450. We should have something like 1000-3000 members of the house, which if distributed by population would fix most people's problems with the electoral college. Basically, Congress got selfish and broke the balance of power for the country to entrench their own, and now the states that don't do much have too much say, and basically slow the country down.
- JadeNB 10y ago> minority groups, that is, small population states. I'm not sure that this synonymy is justified.
- briandear 10y agoHow do the results of a single state swing the total "so wildly out of proportion with the state's population"? The Electoral College is exactly based on a state's congressional representation. California has more people, thus more electoral votes. Each electoral vote represents roughly 700,000 people within a state. While state lines are arbitrary, states are not: they represent a sovereign entity within the United States much like Belgium is a sovereign state within the EU despite Belgium having arbitrary borders. To think otherwise is to fail to understand what the United States is: a federal system with divisions of power allocated by the Constitution. The interests of the people of Louisiana are vastly different than those of New York -- the system represents that reality. The more interesting question is if we would have this discussion if Hillary had won? Popular vote does not determine the presidency -- that has been true since the beginning; it isn't like anyone was robbed. If Trump had lost and Breitbart had conducted some statistical analysis to prove that the vote was rigged, it wouldn't even make it on Hacker News. Every election one side or another tries to justify their losses but rarely does such a justification ascend to high art as it is apparently doing here. Ultimately the bottom line is that the media state-by-state predictions were wrong and now there is hand-wringing to rationalize it. National polls are meaningless yet we continue to subscribe to their irrelevance.
- redler 10y agoIn a state like Wyoming there are about 190,000 people per elector. In California or Texas it's more like 700,000. The fundamental unit of a democracy should be the citizen, not the square mile. (Cue responses that it's not at all a democracy)
- akvadrako 10y agoWhy do you make that statement without any argument to back it up? It's clear that equal representation per person is not universally agreed to be ideal. That's not how any federal system works. They are more like unions of states than one big government and in a union the less powerful partners deserve some protections.
- 10y ago
- billsmithaustin 10y agoIt is nonsensical to credit Trump's win to the Electoral College. How a candidate runs a campaign is dependent on the rules that govern the election. If you were to change the rules, the campaign would be run differently. None of us know what would have happened if the candidates had run their campaigns without the constraints imposed by the Electoral College.