3 ms·
Has there been a single anti-American dictator who has actually improved the lives of their people? It seems the amount of anti-American rhetoric is directly co
by RcouF1uZ4gsC 10y ago
Has there been a single anti-American dictator who has actually improved the lives of their people? It seems the amount of anti-American rhetoric is directly correlated with how much they screw their country over.
- hawkice 10y agoSome of that is just because being an "anti-American dictator" entails not just disagreeing with America but making America-hate a topic you never shut up about. China has done pretty well and disagreed with America on lots of policy issues -- they just don't have the monomania that e.g. North Korea has.
- chillacy 10y agoInteresting question. I think that depends on how you define "their people". In some sense, all dictators improved the lives of "their people". Nelson Mandela for instance made life better for black South Africans, but he's implicated in violence against white south africans. Hitler made life better for many Germans, especially given the conditions of the Treaty of Versailles. Turning back to the US, you could argue that those descended from native americans have not had their lives improved by an ugly history of genocide. The US also enslaved people who our citizens today descended from. There was also internment of Japanese-American citizens. And to this day, high incarceration rates for the poor/minorities.
- kgwgk 10y agoMandela or Hitler are don't seem particularly anti-American. "The forms of government have always been different. But this cannot be a reason for hostility between different nations, as long as one form of government does not try to interfere with another, outside of its naturally ordained sphere." http://www.ihr.org/jhr/v08/v08p389_Hitler.html http://www.ihr.org/jhr/v08/v08p389_Hitler.html
- chillacy 10y agoI suppose I didn't pick the best examples. Though Mandela was a critic of the US in later years regarding Iraq / Israel, and Hitler's sentiment on America seems to be complex: a combination of not taking america too seriously and not desiring conflict too early. But I don't think that changes my original point, which is that all dictators can be seen as serving their people, depending on how you define "their people".
- kgwgk 10y agoI don't disagree, but the comment you replied to was about the direct correlation between "the amount of anti-American rhetoric" and "how much they screw their country over" so the fact that you choose as example dictators which were not very high in the anti-American rhetoric axis kind of supports his case.
- chillacy 10y agoTrue. I suppose better picks would have been leaders of Russia, Egypt, Pakistan, Iran, etc. going off of http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2014/07/15/which-countries-dont-like-america-and-which-do/ http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2014/07/15/which-countr... In all those cases they're helping some group in their country, even if its the political elite.
- saretired 10y agoThe obvious symmetrical question is whether there has been a pro-American dictator who actually improved the lives of the citizens. But 'improving the lives' is extremely vague. Measured by what? Literacy, GNP, health care, growth of a middle class, civil liberties, respect for contracts, life expectancy, public safety, etc.?
- int_19h 10y agoPutin did actually improve the lives of his people. Problem is, it was all largely based on exploiting oil exports during a boom - basically, pocket a hefty chunk, but spend the rest to improve the economy and quality of life. So when oil prices went down, so did the prosperity.