10 ms·
Wells Fargo says customers gave up right to sue by having signatures forged
- thr0waway1239 10y agoOutrageous! This is like a software company which pushes unwanted OS upgrades on its customers and then hides behind customers agreeing to a nag-screen exploding "offer" when the upgrade bricks some of the previously fine computers. Thankfully we in the software business don't have to worry about such things, because we are above such tactics. All you little people, its really your fault for being such small fry...
- bjelkeman-again 10y agoI recognise that behaviour. Indeed I was exposed to it.
- slededit 10y agoDespite the histrionics of this article, its actually an interesting question from a legal perspective. In the case of an account the customer never agreed to open - are they bound by the agreement which opened their primary account, or is there no legal agreement in place? Assuming the original arbitration clause covered the entire business relationship - not just matters specific to the account opened at signing then it ultimately is a question of whether the fraudulent account is a new business "relationship".
- witty_username 10y agoTIL histrionic (it looked like a misspelling) histrionic ˌhɪstrɪˈɒnɪk noun plural noun: histrionics 1. melodramatic behaviour designed to attract attention. "by now, Anna was accustomed to her mother's histrionics" synonyms: dramatics, drama, theatrics, theatricality, tantrums archaic dramatic performances; the theatre. "he loved the theatre and everything which savoured of histrionics" 2. archaic an actor.
- pugworthy 10y agoThat's boingboing for you in a lot of ways. Interesting stuff sometimes, but also ... they get a bit excited.
- BEEdwards 10y agoHow is it "histrionics"? "are they bound by the agreement which opened their primary account, or is there no legal agreement in place?" How can you be bound by things you never agreed to? "We signed you up for more services, but because you said yes once that means you are always ours."
- Pyxl101 10y agoI think the argument (speculating - the article isn't clear on this) is that the customers were bound to that agreement when they legitimately opened their first account. I agree that the article sounds like histrionics because it doesn't explain the situation clearly. The article makes it sound like the customers are being bound somehow based on their forged signatures, which sounds like hogwash to me. My suspicion is that the customers were bound to this term by opening their original account -- or at least, that's Wells Fargo's argument. The legal debate seems to be about whether the terms of service signed by the customer at that time would prevent them from suing over the additional fraudulent accounts. Basically, whether those terms of service apply to that situation or not.
- FullMtlAlcoholc 10y agoI'm a bit of a numbskull when it comes to legal matters, but wouldn't any previous agreement between the bank and its customer become null and void when the bank willfully and egregiously commits criminal acts by forging signatures and signing them up for services they didn't agree to? For me, this is one of the scariest issues USA faces, a de facto loss to right of trial via binding arbitation
- Lazare 10y agoFirst, no, contracts do not generally become void just because one party committed a crime. Not that it really matters because, second: >when the bank willfully and egregiously commits criminal acts Wells Fargo has not been found guilty of committing criminals acts at all, much less willfully and egregiously. There are some ongoing criminal investigations, and they were hit by some civil penalties. But there have been no criminal convictions.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- techsupporter 10y agoThe Boing Boing article basically quotes this Reuters article, so I think the Reuters one should be the one linked as it is the source and is more in-depth: http://www.reuters.com/article/us-wellsfargo-accounts-lawsuit-idUSKBN13J1WX http://www.reuters.com/article/us-wellsfargo-accounts-lawsui...
- johngalt 10y agoThere is an obvious legal gap at work here and it isnt just wells fargo exploiting it. Once a business has your info on file they can effectively open additional accounts or services for you at will. It can be difficult to seek any sort of remedy because it would be hard to prove damages except in extreme cases.
- DannyBee 10y agoLet's take a gander at the federal arbitration act: "A written provision in any maritime transaction or a contract evidencing a transaction involving commerce to settle by arbitration a controversy ... shall be valid, irrevocable, and enforceable, save upon such grounds as exist at law or in equity for the revocation of any contract." Want to guess what grounds exist at law and equity for the revocation of a contract? :) Note also the now-common practice of requiring individual arbitration is not well-tested in court either. The FAA pretty clearly preempts court class actions when there are mandatory arbitration provisions. However, it is silent, and it's purpose unrelated, to whether that arbitration is individual or class arbitration. It seems likely to me that a state could reasonably say forcing individual arbitration was against their public policy, and not have that pre-empted by the FAA.
- kutkloon7 10y agoThe article is wrong. Wells fargo says customers gave up their right to sue by signing up for an account, which is far more defendable from a legal point of view. Unfortunately, this is common practice and it also shows one of the biggest problems of the western world. It is quite profitable for a company to screw over customers. Just discourage them as much as possible to go to court by letting them sign a large page of legal gibberish, and don't screw them over too much, and the company will probably be fine.
- JustSomeNobody 10y ago> It is quite profitable for a company to screw over customers. Because companies are beholden to investors and not customers.
- CWuestefeld 10y agoI think the article is opaque on the terms of that waiver. W-F seems to be taking the stance that the signature applies to the entirety of the customer's relationship with the bank - sign this once for any account, and it applies to actions across all your accounts. BoingBoing and others are taking the position that the waiver only applies to actions relating to the specific account that was signed for, each account standing separately. The latter approach seems more sensible to me, but really it all comes down to the language of the statement that they (really) signed, and how courts have chosen to interpret that.
- t0mas88 10y agoIn the Netherlands a bank got destroyed a few years ago by a single person starting a media campaign for a bank-run. This was done in response to "shady practices" on the mortgage side of the bank. He got people to withdraw over 600 million from DSB Bank in a few days, which caused the bank to run out of liquidity and forced them to freeze accounts. This meant they lost all trust in the market and needed to ask other banks for emergency financing. All other banks declined (with good reasons, a bank falling apart combined with pending legal action on the mortgage side is a very high risk for them to take). So within three weeks DSB was bankrupt. More here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DSB_Bank https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DSB_Bank I can imaging some disgruntled customers going after Wells Fargo in the same way. They have severe legal action pending (which makes them risky for others to save) and have destroyed their image by their reactions to this (which makes it easier to motivate customers to take action). All ingredients that killed DSB are there... The only difference is that DSB was one of the smaller banks and Wells Fargo is huge.
- gaius 10y agoIn the Netherlands a bank got destroyed a few years ago by a single person starting a media campaign for a bank-run. This was done in response to "shady practices" on the mortgage side of the bank Happened here in the UK too. Northern Rock was in trouble but companies get in trouble all the time; what killed it and precipitated a full-blown financial crisis here was certain journalists revelling in the downfall of capitalism from the safety of their state-broadcaster sinecures...
- _ak 10y agoThem going bust is actually a pillar of capitalism. This whole "too big to fail" bullshit coming from business-friendly politicians was just skewing the free market.
- tdb7893 10y agoWeren't they actually too big to fail, though? I thought that multiple huge American banks failing would've made the recession a ton worse because banks would've failed and some large companies wouldn't have been able to make payroll and it all could've snowballed
- logicallee 10y agoperhaps due to the clickbaity title, it seems people are reading "agree to arbitration" as "agree that Well Fargo's internal decisions are final and waive their right to legal remedy." let's firstly identify that yes, this is how people in the thread take "agree to arbitration." Next let me ask: I did a quick Google search, https://www.google.com/search?q=does+arbitration+always+favor+the+corporate+side https://www.google.com/search?q=does+arbitration+always+favo... expecting to see that, for example, perhaps arbitration always results in the larger player being awarded whatever they say. (Meaning that it is equal to saying "agree that its decisions are final and customers waive all recourse.") But it seems the link isn't quite conclusive - it seems the results just show that the "Forced arbitration clauses almost always favor the company over the individual" - which is very strong language, but is about "favor" and not outright as categorical. So I'm curious if people have experience with arbitration -- is it fair to read the arbitration clause as being de facto tantamount to Wells Fargo's decisions being final? (With the arbitration itself being an afterthought, a mere formality.) Or is it just a bit lopsided, but still not quite as final and definitive as that? I ask because in theory, in an environment of frivolous lawsuits that can cost companies literally hundreds of thousands or millions of legal fees, it might certainly make sense for arbitration clauses to limit the extent to which they are embroiled in huge lawsuits. This reason for arbitration would be a bit different from the reason that "it's really just an excuse to say whatever we say is final." If I were a corporation, I wouldn't think that an arbitration clause is the same as saying "our company's policies are final and we decide what they mean: you waive all right to any recourse". Is that what other people here think it means? (Genuine, open question - as you can see I did a Google search more or less with this phrasing.) Curious what you think, or your experiences. Or whether you've used arbitration clauses in the past, either on the corporate side against a frivolous lawsuit, or as a consumer against a large corporation. (I don't expect corporate lawyers from large corporations to read this comment and respond honestly - but small startup CEO's and individuals, sure. Of course, if you're doing evil work for a large corporation as a corporate lawyer enforcing lopsided contracts, I guess you're welcome to come clean under a throwaway...)
- brainfire 10y agoIf we take as true that our legal system doesn't work and is host to numerous "frivolous lawsuits that can cost companies literally hundreds of thousands or millions of legal fees" then I can understand favoring arbitration as a way to protect companies. However, I don't think that premise is true. I trust the open, standardized, and (mostly) consistent courts to fairly apply the law. While some lawsuits seem frivolous on the surface, I've consistently found that when I learn the details there is a good reason they proceeded.
- Programmatic 10y agoIt is despicable to me that citizens can be denied their right to access legal remedy by companies that won't deliver services to individuals without them agreeing to binding arbitration. Access to courts seems like it should be the cornerstone of society and should not be allowed to be removed so easily. The appeal of arbitration for a pair of similarly sophisticated entities that have the ability to vet the clauses of the contract is obvious. But the potential for abuse with one large organization picking the arbiter and a lot of unsophisticated individuals trying their luck against them is pretty obvious too.
- coldcode 10y agoIt would seem to me that since WD offers free arbitration the prudent thing in this case would be for every single person affected to file for it on the same day and simultaneously withdraw their money leaving only $1 in the account. A bank run and 100,000 filed cases would make for a fine mess.
- mannykannot 10y agoAbuse of arbitration is one of the several things that the Democrats (with one or two exceptions) have not made much of an issue over, and they wonder why they lose.