4 ms·

Moving your community to another platform which has a better history of respecting their users isn't metaphorically similar to burning your house down. Its more

by 010a 10y ago

Moving your community to another platform which has a better history of respecting their users isn't metaphorically similar to burning your house down. Its more like immigrating to Canada because Trump won.

RandomInteger4 10y ago
If there are 25,000 users in a community, then it's not "your" community.
freehunter 10y ago
If he just left reddit and deleted his account, that's one thing. Shutting down the community and deleting the content is another. But going through steps to make sure that community can never rebuilt itself after it's gone is so far beyond a protest against one person that I can't even believe it's being considered. Literally, in that Google Groups conversation they said they wanted to delete everything and make it private so no one could ever use it again. That's insane.
- sqeaky 10y ago
  There has to be a less destructive way than to simply delete the subreddit, perhaps put up a date that new post will be disallowed and links to other official Forums. Then when posts are no longer allowed, leave a read only copy up for some time, then leave nothing but the links to other communities.
  - freehunter 10y ago
    Why even disallow new posts? What's the point? It's not an official support forum, he shouldn't have the right to shut down a community site and bar people from using it.
    - sqeaky 10y ago
      Many people not be aware of the issue and the network effect would have those people stay, despite the most talented leaders of the Go community leaving. It stops being a community it the non-experts are separated from the experts by inaction of the experts. If someone really likes Reddit that much, let make another go language sub.
sangnoir 10y ago
> Moving your community to another platform A) the community does not belong to the golang team, the subreddit originally existed independently of the golang team. B) The community is not a piece of furniture to be moved at will; they have to choose to move. If they do proceed with this (say they take a vote), the best they can hope for is fragmenting the community between Reddit and Voat or whatever.

by 010a 10y ago

RandomInteger4 10y ago

If there are 25,000 users in a community, then it's not "your" community.

freehunter 10y ago

If he just left reddit and deleted his account, that's one thing. Shutting down the community and deleting the content is another. But going through steps to make sure that community can never rebuilt itself after it's gone is so far beyond a protest against one person that I can't even believe it's being considered. Literally, in that Google Groups conversation they said they wanted to delete everything and make it private so no one could ever use it again. That's insane.

sqeaky 10y ago
There has to be a less destructive way than to simply delete the subreddit, perhaps put up a date that new post will be disallowed and links to other official Forums. Then when posts are no longer allowed, leave a read only copy up for some time, then leave nothing but the links to other communities.
- freehunter 10y ago
  Why even disallow new posts? What's the point? It's not an official support forum, he shouldn't have the right to shut down a community site and bar people from using it.
  - sqeaky 10y ago
    Many people not be aware of the issue and the network effect would have those people stay, despite the most talented leaders of the Go community leaving. It stops being a community it the non-experts are separated from the experts by inaction of the experts. If someone really likes Reddit that much, let make another go language sub.

sangnoir 10y ago

> Moving your community to another platform A) the community does not belong to the golang team, the subreddit originally existed independently of the golang team. B) The community is not a piece of furniture to be moved at will; they have to choose to move. If they do proceed with this (say they take a vote), the best they can hope for is fragmenting the community between Reddit and Voat or whatever.