7 ms·
Sadly, CNN, fox, CBS, Huffington Post, et all spread sensationalized fake news for the last 8 years (while ignoring Obama's abuses with the NSA, TPP, executive
by exabrial 10y ago
Sadly, CNN, fox, CBS, Huffington Post, et all spread sensationalized fake news for the last 8 years (while ignoring Obama's abuses with the NSA, TPP, executive orders, ect) and this only has become an issue since Trump was elected. The train left the station a long time ago, but was willfully ignored. There simply is no integrity in reporting these days, though I would grateful to be proven wrong.
- tptacek 10y agoThere is a huge difference between fakenews, like the "Denver Guardian" fake newspaper site that ran stories about HRC being involved in the death of FBI agents in order to rack up tens of thousands of dollars from impressions, and sensationalized news. Every time this topic comes up, we have to tediously explain the difference, not because the difference is hard to understand, but because people seize on the name "fake news" as an excuse to attack the media. There's nothing wrong with media criticism, but you shouldn't write it in a way that obscures to readers what these stories are actually about --- webspam farms running entirely fabricated stories.
- mc32 10y agoFake news ala straight-faced version of the Onion is a problem. It delivers content to many sides and spreads fabrications. One concern is that established media will use this punching bag of sorts to delegitimize smaller news organizations and make themselves into the canonical news organizations. In other words they seem to be seeing this as an opportunity for a power play.
- tptacek 10y agoDo you have evidence for this other than the fact that major news outlets are reporting on fakenews?
- Broken_Hippo 10y agoThere is comedic fake news, fakier news, and then there is serious fake news. While occasionally people are duped by The Onion, the site itself doesn't pretend to be posting real stories. Believing this is akin to believing the fakier news, which is basically the tabloids of old. Lizard people, celebrity "news" and gossip and the like. A certain subset of folks have always gone for that stuff, but I like to think that more of them read it for the giggles. The main reason any of this gets into mainstream is lack of fact checking by the real news folks. But the other breed, the serious fake news, is the real problem. Even otherwise intelligent folks can't really sort out if they are real or not because it is just so freaking plausible. Their goal is to be believed, and reaffirm some suspicions and beliefs people have. Even worse, some of these sites will mix in factual stuff with their fakes. These are the ones that, "seem to be seeing this as an opportunity for a power play". In a sense, any news organisation that caters to any political party - fox news to an extent, and the more insidious players (occupydemocrats, for example) - are guilty of just this. Twist, lie, and misrepresent are part of the game.
- denzil_correa 10y ago> There is a huge difference between fakenews, like the "Denver Guardian" fake newspaper site that ran stories about HRC being involved in the death of FBI agents in order to rack up tens of thousands of dollars from impressions, and sensationalized news. I'm really surprised this even has to be spelled out, TBH. IT goes to a point where I feel people are intentionally obfuscating the issue.
- keymone 10y agoobfuscation and false-equivalence is the best defense against propaganda accusations. did wonders for russia these last couple years.
- cmac2992 10y agoIt becomes a finer line when you have the Washington Post reporting (more accurately reporting an "expert" claim) that hillary Clinton may have been poisoned on 9/11 by Putin.
- pas 10y agoUmm, could you link to that maybe?
- smt88 10y agohttps://www.washingtonpost.com/news/early-lead/wp/2016/09/12/the-man-who-discovered-cte-thinks-hillary-clinton-may-have-been-poisoned/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/early-lead/wp/2016/09/12... They didn't report it as fact. They reported it as, "This respected guy is saying this thing."
- cmac2992 10y agohttps://www.washingtonpost.com/news/early-lead/wp/2016/09/12/the-man-who-discovered-cte-thinks-hillary-clinton-may-have-been-poisoned/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/early-lead/wp/2016/09/12... Even though they aren't claiming these claims are true, its at the very least, incredibly misleading. They spend most of the article talking about how Putin has poisoned people in the past, and talking up the Drs credentials. There should be a disclosure that the claims are unsubstantiated. Or it should never have been posted. That said the Washington post did some of the best reporting this election season.
- smt88 10y agoThere was no "claim" to disclaim by saying it's unsubstantiated. The original tweet was just that Clinton should be tested for poisons, not that she was definitely (or even likely) poisoned. It's true that headlines like these cause people to become certain about what is an unsubstantiated idea. But it's also within the realm of possibility that Putin did try to poison Clinton. It would be far from the most egregious thing he's ever tried to do, and (as the story describes) he's done it before.
- 10y ago
- 551199 10y agoPlease MSM colluding with Clinton campaign giving fake news daily. Most shocking being 'Trump raping 13 year kid' which was fabricated as nearly all other negative Trump stories. Read the Podesta wikileaks if you haven't already.
- 3pt14159 10y agoI've come around to thinking that not only is propaganda unavoidable, it's sometimes a good thing. Sometimes it's useful to avoid war, or to avoid public backlash against something that is actually good, but misunderstood like (potentially, anyway) TPP.
- iamnothere 10y agoIf you look at history, propaganda is more often used to justify war than to prevent it.
- pas 10y agoEh. Propaganda is always sold as education. It's an explanation, to carefully frame issues, direct public discourse and so on. Rational analysis should not care of the source of information, but about its veracity. Alas people are not that great at this, hence propaganda works.
- tormeh 10y agoAnd how do you verify news? By going out and verifying everything personally? If not, you have to trust someone. I'd rather trust the NYT than Breitbart, because I care about veracity, not because of an allegiance to the NYT. And also because the NYT cares more about the things I care about, but that's an independent factor.
- pas 10y agoI just addressed this in an other comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13038215 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13038215 tl;dr - I agree with you. NYT has some street cred, Breitbart has negative of that, that's why people should require more evidence for Breitbart's claims than for NYT's, and yes, we should take bias into account, but that's different, sort of orthogonal effect.
- mcphage 10y ago> Rational analysis should not care of the source of information, but about its veracity. You can mislead without lying. Veracity is not sufficient.
- exabrial 10y agoYes, I'm well aware of the difference between web farms and news for profit. However, the former paved the way for the latter, and in my mind is guilty for the 'problem' they created.
- tzs 10y ago> Sadly, CNN, fox, CBS, Huffington Post, et all spread sensationalized fake news for the last 8 years (while ignoring Obama's abuses with the NSA, TPP, executive orders, ect) The things on your parenthetical list have all been extensively covered in mainstream media. The key is to include newspapers among your sources, instead of just mostly TV news sites which tend to be less broad and less deep.