10 ms·
This is asinine and it going through would seriously harm how mature I assumed the community around Golang was (actually reading through those posts already did
by BoorishBears 10y ago
This is asinine and it going through would seriously harm how mature I assumed the community around Golang was (actually reading through those posts already did, but either way I guess I'm just one person right?).
The CEO edited a comment and admitted he edited it, and it was stupid, and he shouldn't have done it.
I'm 100% sure there is a way for someone at any given platform they'd choose to replace it with to access a DB of posts and edit it without triggering any sort of edit marker.
I'm also sure if that process exists a CEO is someone who could probably make it happen, and in fact in some (most?) places someone lower in the chain of command can probably make it happen.
Spez's actions harm himself more than users of the site. By confirming what any technically minded person probably already knew (you can edit raw data backing something like a post), he gave the masses a new source of drama any time something they don't like appears on the site.
The sensible amongst us should be above childish drama like this.
What is there on /r/Golang that they expect to see edited?
If their qualm is political instead of practical then the users themselves should leave Reddit, and not burn down the entire village on their way out.
- problems 10y agoI'm not so sure dismissing this as "childish drama" is smart. Sure, it's technically possible, but technical possibility does not mean it should be used, especially in this sort of way. I don't think it's a bad idea to disassociate yourself from a company who's behaving in a way you don't want to condone.
- nurettin 10y agoIt may not be smart, but it definitely is not stupid as you might have insinuated. Individuals deciding to exit because they disagree with company policy (editing content and apologizing) is one thing, forcing others, who don't care about stupid internet drama and conspiracy theories, to do the same is entirely something else. (that something else is borderline despotic)
- problems 10y agoAgain "stupid internet drama and conspiracy theories" this is not. An admin abused their power. It's ripe for abuse and they've proven they're willing to abuse it and not mature enough to treat that power respectfully. I have a hard time respecting a company with someone like that as CEO. No conspiracy, no politics, just what happened.
- nurettin 10y agoWilling to abuse it - that is conspiracy -. How do you know that something done once will repeat? Will google restart google buzz because they did it once? Will everyone jump ship to RoR because they did it before? I am doing everything I can not to create strawmen believe me, but your explanation simply does not cut it.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoBecause the power is there and it's tempting to use. Restarting Buzz may not have economic sense for Google, but abusing admin-edit powers has obvious value for the abusers and may be hard to catch if the abuser is not an idiot. "Opportunity makes a thief", and all.
- oneeyedpigeon 10y agoBut, realistically, the power is there on any site featuring user contributions - Hacker News, Twitter, Slashdot, etc. etc. Humans are fallible; given infinite time, the same thing will happen on those sites too, and probably worse. If you push someone hard enough (I don't know the full story, but I believe the CEO was provoked) they will lash out and do something stupid unless they are incredibly serene or lack any emotion. If that possibility is too much of a concern, maybe we need to come up with an alternative - like some kind of decentralised, mass-distributed reddit-like. Actually, wasn't that usenet? Is it too late to get that back?
- Buge 10y ago
- TheGrumpyBrit 10y agoIt shouldn't be possible. There is certainly a reason for the ability to edit user posts to exist, but in an age where governments can and do demand details of a users activity, such a permission needs to be tightly controlled and properly audited. He's the CEO. He has absolutely no need for that level of access to end user accounts, any more than the CEO of a bank needs permission to silently skim money out of customers accounts.
- meowface 10y ago>The CEO edited a comment and admitted he edited it, and it was stupid, and he shouldn't have done it. Many comments.
- 0xmohit 10y agoAnd what were the changes like? Curious.
- jandrese 10y agoFrom what I understand people on The_Donald subreddit were accusing him of being a shill, so he edited his name in those posts to be The_Donald's moderators instead. If you had guessed stupid political garbage mixed with internet trolling, congratulations you get a cookie.
- hashhar 10y agoActually the people on /r/The_Donald branched off and opened another discussion that led to the Pizzagate (accusing a restraunt owner, Hillary Clinton and others of being pedophiles). And when /u/spez deleted the Pizzagate stuff (people were actually harassing the restruant owner), the mods started abusing and accusing /u/spez of being a pedophile. And also take note that witch-hunting is prohibited on reddit and can warrant legal action.
- hartator 10y agoHe replaced "fuck /u/his user ame/" by "fuck /u/the_donald mod/" in several comments in other poeple comments.
- siidooloo 10y agoPeople were accusing him of being a pedophile because redit removed a subreddit that was involved in a conspiracy falsley accusing other people of being pedophiles. He changed the attribution of the accusation to be against the people doing the brigading.
- 10y ago
- marcoperaza 10y agoI have no opinion whatsoever in this controversy about the golang sub. But I'd like to call out something in particular about the point you're making: I see this kind of reductionism to what's "technically possible" a lot around here in regards to security and user trust. Let's go back to meatspace to get a more balanced perspective perhaps. Your mailman can read your mail and steal your packages. Your bank can steal your money. Your waiter can poison you. Your car mechanic can overcharge you. It's not about what's "technically possible" (though a solution to make it technically impossible would be useful). It's about TRUST in another human being who is in a position of power. Trust is built by having a long record of good behavior and can be destroyed by a single bad action.
- berkeleynerd 10y agoWhy in the world would this incredibly insightful comment be downvoted? It sums up the argument perfectly.
- type0 10y ago> Your mailman can read your mail and steal your packages. Your bank can steal your money. Your waiter can poison you. Your car mechanic can overcharge you. And then they could end up prosecuted and/or loose their jobs, will any of it happen to Reddits CEO?
- sheepmullet 10y ago> Your mailman can read your mail and steal your packages Exactly. If my mailman edited one of my letters he would be instantly fired and hopefully prosecuted.
- ikeboy 10y agoI bet that the CEO of Google would have a very difficult time, if even possible, editing individual emails sent or received with gmail, editing YouTube comments, etc.
- Springtime 10y ago> The CEO edited a comment and admitted he edited it Well, it was an entire page of them, but an interesting thing I found while following a bit of this as it blew up was coming across a user that mentioned a comment that was seemingly also deleted by the admin [1]. It seems the CEO may have been doing more than just editing comments. Not that it changes the view of your post though. [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/The_Donald/comments/5ekdy9/the_admins_are_suffering_from_low_energy_have/dadlfxc/ https://www.reddit.com/r/The_Donald/comments/5ekdy9/the_admi...
- freehunter 10y agoI would think that deleting a comment would be less controversial than editing a comment. Deleting a comment without needing the moderators involved is a power I would entirely expect an admin to wield.
- mtgx 10y agoIf Larry Page or Sundar Pichai edited some of your emails, would you still want to use Gmail? And before you say that it's "different" because emails are private, let's remember this: http://www.bbc.com/news/business-26677607 http://www.bbc.com/news/business-26677607 Emails are not private. At least not Gmail/Outlook emails. ProtonMail or PGP email should be safer.
- Zren 10y agoIt's not really comparable. He wasn't editing Private Messages between two people, but public discussion (which was calling him a pedophile supporter). The reddit admins aren't known for making the greatest judgement calls, but that just makes them more human. The fallout of this will probably be a bunch of nothing. It doesn't affect the 90% of lurkers, nor the rest of the site which doesn't give a shit about US politics. The people who it does affect (/r/The_Donald) will find that they need reddit to attract new users. It's doubtful their community could stand own their own or it would have done so already. It's no secret that they didn't trust the admins before the election.
- serf 10y ago> It's not really comparable. He wasn't editing Private Messages between two people, but public discussion (which was calling him a pedophile supporter). Why does it matter what the discussion was about? >The reddit admins aren't known for making the greatest judgement calls, but that just makes them more human. I don't get it. Is being 'more human' good or bad? Is 'humanity' somehow a property that emerges from deceit and hypocrisy, or does it emerge from some other portion of this scandal? >The fallout of this will probably be a bunch of nothing. It doesn't affect the 90% of lurkers, nor the rest of the site which doesn't give a shit about US politics. agreed that the fallout will be minimal, but I disagree that it only affects US political boards. The reality is that we don't really know the scope of the problem; we have to take the word of parties, that have already been proven dishonest, regarding the depth and scope of their own wrong-doings. >It's doubtful their community could stand own their own or it would have done so already. I'm sure reddit was an awesome vehicle for their messages, but the internet is a big place, and there were people/places/forums/groups/zines like this before reddit was around. > It's no secret that they didn't trust the admins before the election. and now it's no secret that they were right.
- ryanlol 10y ago>The CEO edited a comment and admitted he edited it, and it was stupid, and he shouldn't have done it. Only incident we know of. It's overwhelmingly likely that they both had tools built for this and had used them before. And admitted he edited them? Yeah, after he was called out in front of the entire world. >The sensible amongst us should be above childish drama like this. Not sure if trying to rationalise massive fuckups by C-level execs like this is "sensible", nor is ignoring the fact that reddit in all likelihood has ready tools (unless you're saying that it's more likely he had direct access to prod db) for stealthily editing user comments.
- philovivero 10y agoWho's down-voting this comment? What's controversial in here? If anything, this comment seems way more even-handed than it should be. Are we down-voting for showing self-restraint now?
- SomeStupidPoint 10y agoI try not to worry about HN downvotes on comments less than 12 hours old. (Or really downvotes in general.) Lots of my comments go several points negative only to be dug back out hours later as the more sporadic, calmer crowd filters through and quietly votes.
- rublev 10y agoSomeone has to make a stand. People moving their communities off of reddit is a great thing. That place is a disorganized, broken, low quality cess pool. Let's skip the "B-B-But you have to find the good small subreddits!". Even those are mostly shit and in-jokes. Reddit is a former shell of its past. >Spez's actions harm himself more than users of the site. If people like you keep defending him for really no reason. People lose jobs over much less. I think he has got to go.
- kaishiro 10y agoAs an active member of a half dozen "good, small subreddits", there actually are some really great communities on Reddit if you can find them. I don't disagree that much of Reddit is a goddam mess, but there absolutely are some redeeming subs.
- patrickk 10y agoHis offhand remark about knowing people's interests showed a real lack of judgement as well (even if he was 100% not serious the reaction from the interviewer is telling): https://www.reddit.com/r/videos/comments/4lmfmj/ceo_of_reddit_steve_huffman_about_advertising_on/ https://www.reddit.com/r/videos/comments/4lmfmj/ceo_of_reddi... Link to relevant video section: https://youtu.be/uSVqoW1rz6w?t=13m55s https://youtu.be/uSVqoW1rz6w?t=13m55s
- yarou 10y ago> Spez's actions harm himself more than users of the site. By confirming what any technically minded person probably already knew (you can edit raw data backing something like a post), he gave the masses a new source of drama any time something they don't like appears on the site. Vehemently disagree. You can extend the same argument to the NSA conducting effectively unrestricted surveillance on citizens. Those of us who are technically minded knew it was going on years before Snowden showed up. That still doesn't make the action morally correct, nor justifiable in any way.
- imron 10y ago> Those of us who are technically minded knew it was going on years before Snowden showed up I seem to recall it being dismissed by the technically minded as possible but largely tinfoil hat conspiracy before Snowden showed up.
- xg15 10y ago> Spez's actions harm himself more than users of the site. I'm not sure. If everyone would say "alright, it was incorrect but we don't want any internet drama", then how exactly would it hurt him? Closing a subreddit seems to me like exactly the kind of thing that could communicate a "not OK". I think it's especially necessary as the edits had been done in a trump support group subreddit. Even though I don't agree with them at all, I think setting a precident that manipulating discussions are ok if I don't like the political content would be even worse.
- eterm 10y agoI agree, and also yes he admitted it, but isn't that worse? There weren't any safeguards or anything to catch it on the reddit organisation side. It was only users noticing forcing an admission that means it's even a matter of record.
- freehunter 10y agoWhat kind of safeguards could be put in place that couldn't be disabled or overridden by the admins?
- logmeout 10y agoUse a bot to monitor comments and an SCM like git to detect potentially suspicious differences. Like a comment change that is not marked as user edited. Or a comment change that seems to shift the original meaning significantly.
- freehunter 10y agoWould those be managed by the community, or by the admins? If it was official, it seems like the admins could still shut it down, or edit that database to ignore their changes.
- qb45 10y agoNo UI for traceless edits and DB password split in three parts like nuclear launch codes. Then the CEO couldn't do it alone and he would have some time to think things through before others agree to participate in such fishy business, if they do at all.
- Buge 10y agoHe edited comments invisibly (not showing the usual edit mark), replacing the content with content against the rules of the subreddit. Thus when subreddit mods saw content that was against the rules, they banned the victims' accounts.
- personofpelican 10y ago> replacing the content with content against the rules of the subreddit. Thus when subreddit mods saw content that was against the rules, they banned the victims' accounts Got a source for this? From what I've read about what happened (not a whole lot), this seems like it's been passed through multiple rounds of the telephone game. All solid information I've heard, and seen directly admitted, is that he edited mentions of /u/spez to mentions of /u/<random-moderator-of-the-subreddit> in a single thread in a single subreddit.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Buge 10y agoYes, it's against the /r/the_donald rules to insult the /r/the_donald mods. Here's an /r/the_donald mod saying they banned some of the users by mistake after /u/spez edited their comment. https://np.reddit.com/r/The_Donald/comments/5ekdy9/the_admins_are_suffering_from_low_energy_have/dad3dv1/ https://np.reddit.com/r/The_Donald/comments/5ekdy9/the_admin...
- _RPM 10y agoI read your post, but still have no idea what you said. It reminds of Eric B at TechCrunch Disrupt interrupting Gavin Belson's interview with the press.
- wdr1 10y ago> The CEO edited a comment and admitted he edited it, and it was stupid, and he shouldn't have done it. The only reason I've heard that this even remotely defensible is because it was against Trump supporters. I'm sorry, but that doesn't cut it with many of us.[1] I don't care about political beliefs. He abused his power in such an obvious & egregious way that he should be terminated. [1] And not that it should matter, I hate Trump as much as the vast majority of Reddit & Hacker News.
- euyyn 10y agoI guess it wasn't really against Trump supporters, but against people causing a restaurant owner to be harassed in real life. Happened to be Trump supporters, but to be honest it could have been any other subreddit; wouldn't have been the first time.
- sqeaky 10y ago> What is there on /r/Golang that they expect to see edited? This is an insane question to ask. This is as flawed as arguing for mass surveillance because you have nothing to hide now. The questions should instead be "can we trust our comments to not be edited when management disagrees?". What if future management starts loving python so much they decide to do something malicious to other programming languages? It wouldn't be hard to really hurt Go with the eyes of 25,000 Gophers subscribed. All sites have this ability but few successful ones have demonstrated a willingness to use it. I fully expect that if Twitter or Facebook were caught doing this we would see an enormous backlash and huge drop in stock price. Then shortly after stockholders would demand the CEO leave. EDIT - If you must downvote, please comment so we can discuss.
- mcphage 10y ago> What if future management starts loving python so much they decide to do something malicious to other programming languages? Well, why not figure it out then? Why solve a problem you haven't had yet? That seems to fall squarely under YAGNI.
- hokkos 10y agoThis is some ridiculous assumptions, spez was clearly distressed with being harassed by trumpets, he did an April fool style edit and smart trolling, he did not made subtle edit to change the hive mind.Reddit lives on drama, everybody should calm down.