4 ms·
There is no technical solution to such a problem. There is only a political solution. Either force government to change politics, or change government. Some ba
by ischm 10y ago
There is no technical solution to such a problem. There is only a political solution. Either force government to change politics, or change government.
Some background of why I believe this. I grew up in communist East Germany (GDR) and lived there for 27 years, until - yes - we changed the government. Trying to change politics beforehand was not so successful after all. As you may know or may not know, that state was based to a good extent on the soft terror of broad surveillance. In the 70s and 80s of the last century, to achieve this a lot of human power was needed. Nowadays, surveillance can mostly be based on technology. I'm much concerned - given my life experience - about the trend over the last years to undermine democracy in the name of saving it - all over the (yet) free world. At least I know how a society looks like, that is no longer democratic.
The technical solutions like VPN or whatever are similiar to what we called "inner emigration" back in the past. It was a widespread phenomenon in that society. But only once many people have stopped this kind of hiding, and have publicly stripped off their fear, the system began to tumble. In the end, all the surveillance could not save it. They did know what happened and they could not stop it, simply because the people did not play their game anymore.
That petition mentioned here elsewhere is the right way. Sign it if you are a UK citizen. I'm unfortunately not, but I would do it now.
- mfukar 10y agoTrue. We tend to forget the lessons of history very fast.
- dualogy 10y ago> yes - we changed the government. Trying to change politics beforehand was not so successful after all East-German too, younger though. Yeah it's funny, all the time it seems impossible for "da people" to engender substantial change in governance. Then woopdidoo, some Gorbachev comes along, holds some talks with the Reagans of this world, eastern client states slowly learn they now can and should hold off a bit from total autocracy, and "the folk" get to exercise some agency for a brief time. Beautiful. Where was this agency after Snowden, after other introductions or revelations of police/surveillance state measures? Looks like it wasn't quite as expedient to today's Reagans/Gorbachevs/etc of today. Sorry people, no illusion-of-agency for you when alignment with officious objectives is absent. Maybe it'll come around somehow..