3 ms·

Freaking out about disclosed anonymized analytics about package usage in an OSS project is paranoia in my book

AsyncAwait 10y ago
> disclosed Yeah, carrier contracts also "disclose" everything, there's a reason why it's called "small print". It would only take to make it opt-in, instead of opt-out to rectify this.
TeMPOraL 10y ago
May be, but you didn't use the word "paranoia" to describe just this in your previous comment; you described also things like medical information.
- rubber_duck 10y ago
  I mean the general sentiment. I'm not saying people should have access to your full medical history, personal info, etc. on demand. I am saying is that these benign things are opt-out not because most people wouldn't want to do them if they weigh the prons and cons but because they don't want to put in the effort of doing so and will just be conservative - which is logical from an individual perspective - but will cause us to lose out on opportunities as a whole. Also this data is getting collected weather you want it or not, even intelligence people are just taping over their webcams as a security measure - the attitude that we must protect every bit of privacy by default will lead to the future where hidden data collection is the only way to access data - people will be making money off it, it won't be available to general public (for eg. public research) and there will be no transparency about it. And if you think the government will protect you - well they are the biggest transgressor here. So instead of fighting a lost battle with trying to keep absolute privacy why not just make most of that data public and available and focus on protecting the really sensitive stuff.
  - zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 10y ago
    > So instead of fighting a lost battle with trying to keep absolute privacy why not just make most of that data public and available and focus on protecting the really sensitive stuff. Because you can't. You cannot build something that protects the really sensitive stuff out of stuff that's leaking data left and right, making it harder and harder to protect the really sensitive stuff.

> disclosed Yeah, carrier contracts also "disclose" everything, there's a reason why it's called "small print". It would only take to make it opt-in, instead of opt-out to rectify this.

TeMPOraL 10y ago

May be, but you didn't use the word "paranoia" to describe just this in your previous comment; you described also things like medical information.

rubber_duck 10y ago
I mean the general sentiment. I'm not saying people should have access to your full medical history, personal info, etc. on demand. I am saying is that these benign things are opt-out not because most people wouldn't want to do them if they weigh the prons and cons but because they don't want to put in the effort of doing so and will just be conservative - which is logical from an individual perspective - but will cause us to lose out on opportunities as a whole. Also this data is getting collected weather you want it or not, even intelligence people are just taping over their webcams as a security measure - the attitude that we must protect every bit of privacy by default will lead to the future where hidden data collection is the only way to access data - people will be making money off it, it won't be available to general public (for eg. public research) and there will be no transparency about it. And if you think the government will protect you - well they are the biggest transgressor here. So instead of fighting a lost battle with trying to keep absolute privacy why not just make most of that data public and available and focus on protecting the really sensitive stuff.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 10y ago
  > So instead of fighting a lost battle with trying to keep absolute privacy why not just make most of that data public and available and focus on protecting the really sensitive stuff. Because you can't. You cannot build something that protects the really sensitive stuff out of stuff that's leaking data left and right, making it harder and harder to protect the really sensitive stuff.