6 ms·
"Electron is a really good fit: for example, shipping a single-page webapp as a desktop app, a need that surfaces often in today's world, despite his de
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
"Electron is a really good fit: for example, shipping a
single-page webapp as a desktop app, a need that
surfaces often in today's world, despite his derision
of this concept."
From a systems perspective that is emminently rant worthy, it indicates the system has completely failed the developer who cannot easily express what they can in a single page web app as a real application in the system.
- nilliams 10y agoYep, all the native toolkits failed, that's worthy of ranting about, but that is not what OP was doing.
- m_fayer 10y agoThe only native toolkit I've ever tried that I thought could compete with web is wpf. It was slow and cludgy but way ahead of its time, and the web is only now starting to approach its power.
- sixbrx 10y agoI think WPF is nice but has actually fallen behind a bit on binding vs. some of the web toolkits like React/Redux, Angular 2, Ember. It's been a while since I messed with it, but MVVM didn't work so well for some kinds of things, which seemed to be why for example selected items property is often not a dependency property of MS supplied widgets (so can't be participate in binding). For example see http://stackoverflow.com/questions/22868445/wpf-binding-selecteditems-in-mvvm http://stackoverflow.com/questions/22868445/wpf-binding-sele... (from what I remember this accepted solution also has a subtle bug of double notification (or was it lack of notification on one side?)).
- mwcampbell 10y agoPerhaps WPF was the Electron of its time, in terms of being a resource hog. I remember how one particular WPF-based application hastened the obsolescence of my brother's laptop some years ago. [1] [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8444494 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8444494
- ivm 10y agoI can't see how Cocoa failed at anything.
- nilliams 10y ago> I can't see how Cocoa failed at anything. Will my Cocoa app run on Windows, Linux and the web? (A well-designed web app built with Electron will). Why should any company that wants their product to be widely available invest in Cocoa developers?
- ivm 10y agoWhy should it? It focuses on its platform and does it well. I prefer native Mac apps to cross-platform ones. Serious companies should build native apps and keep UX guidelines of each platform in mind.
- nilliams 10y agoBuilding an app once for each platform is not economically viable for a lot of teams, 'serious' or otherwise.
- jeremiep 10y agoNot at all. It simply indicates the system has a radically different interface than the web. And that web APIs have evolved incredibly more than system ones when it comes to building quality UX. Its no wonder all the best native applications ALL use proprietary toolkits. Adobe being a prime example. Such a toolkit is orders of magnitude easier to reproduce in HTML/CSS than it is in any of Qt/GTK/wx and others. Thinking a web app can easily be expressed as a systems application grossly overlooks the complexity web apps have scaled to.
- sintaxi 10y agoMake no mistake, system-platforms failed.