4 ms·
My thinking is similar. Long ago, I outlined it on a mailing list as follows: I'd like to posit a progression of animal awareness. (In the full knowledge that
by lproven 10y ago
My thinking is similar. Long ago, I outlined it on a mailing list as follows:
I'd like to posit a progression of animal awareness. (In the full
knowledge that there is no "tree" or "hierarchy" of evolution; the
progression is merely a convenient way of presenting some data.)
1. Single-celled animals, such as amoebae and /Paramecium/. Many of
these display simple taxic responses: they move towards light, away
from heat, and towards or away from certain chemicals - they pursue
concentration gradients. In other words, a single cell can display
what could be called "voluntary" movement; it does not follow
programmed paths but responds to its environment. You can watch a
Paramecium in a microscope, swimming through a world of bits of plant
and mineral matter in water. If they bumble into something, they
recoil, and set off in another direction. If they catch a scent of
something that might be food, they change direction and set off in
pursuit of it. It's much like watching a much bigger animal, like a
mouse, explore an unfamiliar environment. Surprisingly like.
Similar behaviours can be observed in all sorts of small animals, like
collembolans and nematodes.
Small animals - even single-celled ones - interact with their
environment, responding to stimuli in ways that are more than a
simple, determinate pattern. They are not like a clockwork mouse or
toy that always follows the same path.
- lproven 10y ago2. If you put a woodlouse in a T-shaped maze - one junction, choice of left or right - and teach it that food and a damp place lie in one direction and bright light and dryness lie in another, you can teach an individual woodlouse to turn left or right consistently. In other words, a woodlouse has a memory. It can learn new behaviours. Woodlice have enough "brain" to at some level form a model of their surroundings. They can learn a very simple map. 3.Many small invertebrates form social colonies. In land-living ones, like ants and termites, animals leave a chemical trail as they move around, depositing markers indicating desirable discoveries. This is how an ant colony "finds" sugar in our kitchens, say. One randomly-exploring ant finds sugar, and retraces its steps home leaving a marker indicating that it's found food. Other ants follow the trail, reinforcing it, until a path is marked for the colony to move large amounts of food back to the nest. In other words, ants make and read signals for other ants.
- lproven 10y ago4. Flying insects can't do this; there's no direct way to mark a trail in the air. So bees, as is well known, have evolved a form of symbolic communication: the "waggle dance". By dancing in a certain fashion, a worker can "tell" other workers the direction and distance to a food source. The dance indicates direction relative to the sun - bees can see the polarisation of light and thus see the sun even when it is covered by clouds - and distance, and it does so independent of the orientation of that bee while it is dancing relative to the sun. In other words, bees have symbolic communication. Their signals are not direct, one-to-one, follow this to the food; they are abstract and require interpretation. Obviously, this is innate, it is not learned behaviour, but individual insects learn the way to food and communicate this symbolically to other individuals. 5. Small mammals can be taught complex behaviours in the lab. Rats can be taught to press levers to obtain treats; mice can be taught to run mazes; "experiments" with wild squirrels have shown that the animals will perform an amazing array of actions to obtain a food reward. Many of these patterns of behaviour show that the animal is able to learn that unrelated actions can elicit a reward, showing some kind of understanding of cause and effect. 6. Non-mammalian vertebrates perform all sorts of ritualistic behaviour that is not directly related to finding food, a mate, predator avoidance and so on. Many birds have mating rituals; male bower birds construct huge and elaborate structures to tempt females into mating, which are presumably derived from nest-building behaviour, but actually the structures serve no purpose other than to be on some level "pleasing" to the females. Many migratory birds such as albatrosses and swans form long-term pairs which persist over years, sometimes lifelong. They can recognise their mate and when they rendezvous at breeding time indulge in long rituals which appear to stimulate and reinforce the pair bond. Obviously mate recognition does not involve some simple biochemical cue of kinship which might be used in a mother finding her offspring in a large, mobile breeding colony independent of environmental cues, such as penguins. Maybe penguins can "smell" or "taste" their own offspring by some form of genetic resemblance; I'm not aware of any research into this. However, even if they can, and don't somehow just learn what their offspring look or sound like, the same cannot apply to individuals recognising their mates, who are, by choice, usually not directly related. In other words, these birds "know" their non-related partners, can recognise them and distinguish them from strangers, and behave in entirely different manners around their partners to around other individuals. When encountering their partners for the first time after a protracted absence, they indulge in displays and other complex behaviours which are not directly survival-related. It is hard to watch such a pair being reunited without thinking that they "feel happy" to see one another. It is also a reasonably common experience to see one which is isolated and has lost its partner, witness its lack of animation, listless behaviour and so on, and the human reaction is to interpret this as the animal "feeling sad".