3 ms·
I think Shadowban has an important role in spammers and (heavy) trolls. It should not be discarded Free speech has a limit, unfortunately, because large groups
by raverbashing 10y ago
I think Shadowban has an important role in spammers and (heavy) trolls. It should not be discarded
Free speech has a limit, unfortunately, because large groups can't police themselves. And then the trolls take over (either on the internet or outside, see Antifa)
> Do you want to visit an ecochamber of heavily censored topics and discussion?
No, but if you go to the_donald that's what you get. Or do you really think they don't censor certain discussions?
> Some how I have a feeling you would not hold the same opinion spez did this to a community you approve of, or on topic you approve of
The topic or community is irrelevant, because it was directed to a troll. A message like "F U $ADM" has no place in any subreddit
- syshum 10y ago>>Free speech has a limit, unfortunately, Sorry no. The second you limit speech it is no longer free speech. This is a concept people have a hard time grasping. People that say reddit is not free expression are correct. It is limited expression. There used to be fewer limits, than today, and reddit seems to want to massively increase those limits even more. >because large groups can't police themselves Based on your subjective view on what they should and should not say they cant. >No, but if you go to the_donald that's what you get. Or do you really think they don't censor certain discussions? Dont know, never once visited, dont care what they do We are not talking about the Policies of a indivual subreddit. Most subreddits are not for Free Expression, most are topic based and heavily censoured to ensure the topic of discussion stays on topic. For example posting political threads on /r/sysadmin is not allowed, I have no problem with this as the rules are fully disclosed, open, and I know what I am getting into when I subscribed You see I have no problem with Moderation. I have extreme problems with SECRET moderation. >A message like "F U $ADM" has no place in any subreddit I would tend to agree, and would have no problem the SPEZ removing the posts. But redirecting F U $ADM to F U $MOD secretly is not the solution, it is childish and should not be viewed as acceptable.
- ManlyBread 10y ago>I think Shadowban has an important role in spammers and (heavy) trolls. Shadowban is a common knowledge at this point, writing a script that checks if the account is shadowbanned is trivial. At this point it only hurts actual users.
- pavel_lishin 10y ago> I think Shadowban has an important role in spammers and (heavy) trolls. It should not be discarded I agree; anyone who disagrees has never moderated anything. It's asymmetric warfare; moderating a single troll costs about ten times the effort that troll puts in, and it scales geometrically from there.
- ryanlol 10y agoYou're not very good at moderating things if you need shadowbans. >It's asymmetric warfare; moderating a single troll costs about ten times the effort that troll puts in, and it scales geometrically from there. This really makes no sense. Moderators are always in the advantageous position.
- tripzilch 10y agoAs someone who used to admin/moderate a medium-large forum for over five years, let me voice my strong disagreement. It's taking the easy route. You're really only punishing those who aren't clever enough to (trivially) detect or circumvent a shadow-ban. And those are actually exactly the people that you didn't need to resort to shadow-banning for in the first place. And there's no excuse for that (I'd like to hear, why would stupid people be more deserving of punishment?). Another important task was keeping ourselves, the mod-team in check, keeping tabs on each other (because emotions), to not abuse their powers like this, taking the easy way. Part of that was setting stone-hard rules that were never, ever, to be broken. Obviously, one of those rules was "don't ever edit someone else's post without attribution". We were sure to drill in that rule, calling it out even if it was a "friendly" or helpful edit--partially for the principle of it, but also because not attributing friendly edits still erodes trust. Oh and if moderating a single troll costs ten times the effort they put in, you probably need to upgrade your mod tools.
- pavel_lishin 10y agoHow did you deal with trolls when you were a moderator? Any troll who can get around a shadowban can get around a regular ban as well by registering new accounts. If shadowbans defeated 50% of trolls and made the forum 50% better, I'd consider that progress.