3 ms·
You've heard of Neilson ratings... How about a Trust Rating? How about a third party that certifies the facts and guarantees that the opinion in which they are
by FakeNewsBot 10y ago
You've heard of Neilson ratings... How about a Trust Rating?
How about a third party that certifies the facts and guarantees that the opinion in which they are expressed by is not slanted past a certain degree. Perhaps give a slant rating. Also, These third party could give a balance rating to a company on a certain issue or candidate. Out of X number of news stories, how many (positive and negative stories) did a given outlet run on each side? The third party could have internal peer reviews and other checks and balances (who watches the watchers?)
Can you imagine what these numbers would look like this election season? One last thing. How about each story has the author name at the bottom, but the link to their profile includes their voting record and party affiliation.
Now that would be transparency.
How about a startup for a news aggregation that somehow did this in an open and transparent way. They would disclose the reasons for all their decisions to keep things honest. Finally a one stop shop to get a balance of stories and opinions, both sides of the story, the actual truth about what is going on. There are so many misinformed people today.
- fao_ 10y agoVoting record? Nope (At least not in the UK. I've heard it's the same for the US, too). You can only get who they say they voted for. Anything else is a gross breach of several data protection laws. Party affiliation could be faked in some way, but isn't an absolute thing any way. I could easily see ~alt-right~ fascist journalists donating $1 to many different left-wing parties to get a record of affiliation, and then undoing those donations by writing opinionated articles against those parties.
- throwanem 10y agoParty affiliation is a matter of public record in the US, as are the dates and amounts of donations to political campaigns and action committees. I haven't heard of any case in which anyone claiming affiliation with the "alt-right" has used any of this information in order to attack anyone. Unfortunately, the same cannot be said on all sides; Brendan Eich's politically motivated ouster from Mozilla, for example, tends to crop up fairly regularly in discussions of such matters, as a good example of the sort of behavior considered entirely apropos and indeed quite virtuous among progressive biens-pensants.
- fao_ 10y agoI didn't say that party affiliation isn't a matter of public record, I said that voting record isn't =/ I wouldn't label them as right wing ('biens-pensants'), but as post-left[0] [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Post-left_anarchy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Post-left_anarchy
- throwanem 10y agoYou talked about faking party affiliation, though, so the point seemed relevant. If I read you correctly, you're describing the alt-right as post-left anarchists. I think many who favor the label might quibble somewhat with that analysis. At the very least, I'd be interested to see some elaboration on it.
- fao_ 10y agoThe a̶l̶t̶-̶r̶i̶g̶h̶t̶ fascist-right (This conversion is well supported by comparing the two ideologies) generally support figures like Brendan Eich, because he shares their viewpoints. He has a history of financing right-wing parties. After some more research, I was incorrect with the label 'post-left', however you were extremely incorrect about the label 'a̶l̶t̶-̶r̶i̶g̶h̶t̶ fascist-right'. The push to get Brendan Eich out of Mozilla was not done by people who use the a̶l̶t̶-̶r̶i̶g̶h̶t̶ fascist-right label, but rather by people in the LGBT sub-community of left-wing (At least, as I understand it that was their overlap). i.e. people who think that it was inappropriate for him to fund anti-progressive legislation with money acquired from the open source movement.
- throwanem 10y agoI can see that you feel strongly about the equation of "alt-right" with "fascist", but beyond that I'm having some trouble grasping the point you're trying to make. Are you taking me to mean "right-wing" by bien-pensant? The term refers to orthodoxy of thought, not to any specific political tendency.
- 10y ago
- Spooky23 10y ago> I could easily see ~alt-right~ fascist journalists donating $1 to many different left-wing parties to get a record of affiliation Why? Anyone who cares enough to verify that will quickly see through it.
- pjc50 10y ago"Balance" in the partisan sense just gives you "Views On Shape Of Earth Differ" articles. Or, from CNN's ticker the other day, "Are Jews People?". It also provides a big incentive to go as partisan as possible in order to drag the Overton window about.
- Spooky23 10y agoIts pretty easy to identify politically motivated people who are affiliated with politicians. For one, it's pretty obvious for a moderately discerning reader to identify talking points that come from a party and campaign. Second, most political activity is public record and you can get registration and contribution records for anyone. Dig a little deeper and you can figure out who the persons family does and where they work. The fake news phenomena has nothing to do with all of that -- it's just pure propaganda. It's easy to identify, but 80% of the population isn't highly engaged (many people don't realize that clearly identified "sponsored posts" are paid content!) and has no idea... they are looking for infotainment.