4 ms·
The analogy to shouting "fire" isn't appropriate. There is a public interest balance when it comes to speech. The more public the interest, the more liberty y
by sandworm101 10y ago
The analogy to shouting "fire" isn't appropriate. There is a public interest balance when it comes to speech. The more public the interest, the more liberty you can take with the truth. Falsely shouting "fire" involves no public interest. All it does is harm. But saying the president is a Lizard-person from Mars ... that actually involves something of great public interest; the honesty of a politician. No court will step into that question. No court will trample on someone's right to say any manner of untruths about a politician.
The flip side to this is speech about non-public persons. You can call the president a lizard, but say the same about his kids and you expose yourself to slander liability. False news about non-public persons is already regulated.
Freedom of speech is about the government not locking you up. Private lawsuits are a totally different paradigm.
- redial 10y agoWho is to judge what is or isn't in the public interest? Is a song that shouts fire illegal? not protected? The fire argument always gets made, but is shouting fire actually illegal or even regulated?
- Analemma_ 10y ago> Who is to judge what is or isn't in the public interest? Er, judges? For all the histrionics, they've traditionally done pretty well with 1A cases.
- redial 10y agoTo my knowledge they don't judge in line with the public interest, but with the law, and shouting fire is not against the law.
- whybroke 10y agoAnnihilating a family owned pizzeria as a satanic pedophile front for Clinton is pretty close to yelling 'fire' isn't it?
- barsonme 10y agoObligatory Popehat: https://popehat.com/2012/09/19/three-generations-of-a-hackneyed-apologia-for-censorship-are-enough/ https://popehat.com/2012/09/19/three-generations-of-a-hackne...