3 ms·
"In short, I think regulations will prevent more damage than post-hoc legal retribution." Time has proven that wrong so far. We got a lot of highly-secure prod
by nickpsecurity 10y ago
"In short, I think regulations will prevent more damage than post-hoc legal retribution."
Time has proven that wrong so far. We got a lot of highly-secure products after DOD's Computer Security Initiative giving clear guidance plus financial incentive. DO-178B and other safety-critical markets are cranking out lots of them on safety side. So is segment of smartcard industry focused on high-security.
Regulation works so long as it has effective standards, they're clear, evaluated against product, and must be followed to sell the product. As in TCSEC era and DO-178B, reusable components for common cases show up to reduce the evaluation cost or risk. Open-source security would likely get a boost, too, as companies sponsoring it would sponsor certifiable versions with the higher QA.
- 0xCMP 10y agoYou're mentioning an industry funded by about 1/6th[0] of the Federal Budget related to war and consequences if things go wrong (like losing/death/geo poltical problems). Just cause it worked for the DOD doesn't mean it'll work everywhere else. [0]: https://www.cbo.gov/taxonomy/term/17/featured https://www.cbo.gov/taxonomy/term/17/featured
- nickpsecurity 10y agoThe LOCK project reported high-assurance cost them 30-40% over a regular development. Altran/Praxis does it regularly for a 50% premium. You don't need the DOD's budget to get even high-assurance software. High-quality stuff usually just cost a bit more upfront followed by savings in maintenance.
- ridgeguy 10y agoI read what you wrote as affirming my thought. The constraints of DoD CSI, DO-178B, and the smart card industry focus are all embodied in regulations, which precede legal retribution. If a company busts the regs, it can be sued. But the first line of defense is that companies are required to do it right - by the regulations. I agree regulation needs clear definition and followup to be effective. I continue to regard regulation as a better mitigator of damage than post-hoc penalties. Regulation is about preventing a mess. Litigation is about cleaning it up. I'd rather not have the mess to begin with.
- nickpsecurity 10y ago"Regulation is about preventing a mess. Litigation is about cleaning it up. I'd rather not have the mess to begin with." That's exactly it. Although, I did propose possibility in this thread of defining regulations that aren't immediately applied but apply in court after harm is alleged. The reason being evaluation costs and time can be a big problem, esp for startups. This lets them simply follow guidelines with evidence produced during development & they only pay the cost if they screw up. The cost goes up with level of deviation and harm it caused.