13 ms·
The sparrow with four sexes
- brian-armstrong 10y agoThere's a diagram about halfway through that illustrates how this works. I miunderstood the article at first and was wondering why you wouldn't just say that there are two species, but the diagram sorted me out. The tan stripe birds almost always mate with the white stripes, and the offspring have a 50/50 chance of having the mutation. I wonder if the birds instinctively "know" that they have 4 sexes
- taneq 10y agoAh, thanks. This was confusing me too. Weird (and interesting)!
- throwaway4891a 10y ago"They almost always pair with the opposite color morph for breeding. The two color morphs occur in approximately equal numbers. Both male and female white-striped birds are more aggressive than tan-striped birds during the breeding season." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White-throated_sparrow https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White-throated_sparrow
- vorg 10y ago> The tan stripe birds almost always mate with the white stripes The "almost" hints at the origins of homosexuality.
- astrodust 10y agoSame sex birds adopting eggs from other breeding pairs are quite common in the avian world, especially among populations that nest in close proximity such as penguins. There's no "origin" to homosexuality. If anything having differentiated sexes is an aberration, the majority of plant species have both as well as many of the precursor species to modern mammals like snails and flatworms. In situations where the separation of the sexes provided some kind of evolutionary advantage it took hold. In others it never happened. Also our preconceptions about gender goes out the window when there's four possible expressions as in the case with these birds.
- vorg 10y ago> There's no "origin" to homosexuality Did I use the word "origin" incorrectly? Because evolution of a second sexual system in these birds results in white-striped birds and tan-striped ones mating only with the other almost all the time instead of always all the time, homosexuality is being built into the differentiation of a species into 2 sexes, I presume because DNA processing can never be error-free. I didn't imply it starts happening after the differentiation.
- astrodust 10y agoThe term doesn't even apply here since the physical expression of gender is more complicated than the typical binary variant seen in mammals. white/male + white/female is not "homosexual" by any conventional definition. If anything it's "homomorphic". Birds, like any creature, don't do anything all the time. I think you're reading way too much into these observations.
- vorg 10y ago> white/male + white/female is not "homosexual" by any conventional definition. If anything it's "homomorphic" Did I use the term "homosexual" incorrectly? Perhaps "origins of homosexuality" would be more accurate. That's what I said in the first place. The article says "the researchers had come up with the concept that the birds were evolving a second set of sex chromosomes" and "the inversion on chromosome 2 doesn't include genes that determine sexual development — but it does contain some that affect the birds' reproductive behaviour". The tan-striped "swingers" are monogamous and fiercely protect their hatchlings from predators, whereas the white-striped "singers" are aggressive, promiscuous, and more cavalier about their offspring. The tan stripe birds almost always mate with the white stripes, but there are exceptions. We're seeing here firsthand (on a genetic time scale) the origins of homosexual behavior. I appreciate your comment because when I first got the 5+ downvotes without any comments, I thought it was homophobic attitudes from HN readers. But now I know they could also be anyone with an overly pedantic reaction to the use of certain words.
- 10y ago
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- throwaway4891a 10y ago"Four sexes" sounds click-baitier than "two morphs." It's not like they have unique procreation, other than effectively two subspecies whom cannot interbreed (they both have males and females respectively). It's interesting a species can diverge with a large mutation and split the gene pool suddenly. More intriguing is how enough of a population could grow from the first individual and thrive. EDIT: gotta make you wonder if there were a large forest fire, volcano, human hunters or other event that almost wipe them out, and that the survivors went through a population bottleneck, perhaps picking up the mutation along the way.
- colanderman 10y agoNo, it's very different than two subspecies. The males of one morph almost exclusively mate with females of the other morph, and produce offspring which are one of the four sexes in roughly equal proportion.
- kseistrup 10y agoDo we know that they “almost exclusively mate with females of the other morph” or is it just because same-morph matings are infertile?
- drcross 10y agoWhat consenting morphs do in the privacy of their own nests is none of your business.
- matt_morgan 10y agoThe article isn't explicit on that, but they did observe the birds for 30 years, so maybe it's in the paper.
- qb45 10y agoThe paper says 1.5% of pairs were indeed between the same morphs. No mention of infertility, but white/white pairs produce 1/4 of chicks with both 2nd chromosomes mutated and the only male chick of this kind they found was 50% underweight runt, though two such females grew up as normal white adults.
- yareally 10y agoQuite a few bird species and some other animals[2] can have chromosomes of both sexes[1]. When it happens to northern cardinals, they end up split down the middle in color--one half gray like a female and one half red like a male[3]. [1] http://www.bbc.com/earth/story/20150916-these-animals-are-male-on-one-side-and-female-on-the-other http://www.bbc.com/earth/story/20150916-these-animals-are-ma... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gynandromorphism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gynandromorphism [3] http://www.remotesensingart.com/CardinalMF/index.html http://www.remotesensingart.com/CardinalMF/index.html
- countryqt30 10y agoMaybe this is just a "correlation vs. causation" error? Think about humans. For Chinese males, it is very likely to mate up with Chinese girls. That's not just a matter of availability (in China, there live mostly Chinese-looking people o_o), but also a phenomenon overseas, I believe. You have a lot more in common, similar values and similar cultural perceptions. PS: This case shall not be construed to address Chinese especially, I'm convinced it works the same with all the similar ethnic groups and even subgroups.
- nv-vn 10y agoInterestingly, you could conclude the opposite for certain groups: http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2015/06/12/interracial-marriage-who-is-marrying-out/; http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2015/06/12/interracial-... American Indians are more likely to marry another race.
- runarb 10y agoLooks like you have an extra ";" in your url. Correct is http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2015/06/12/interracial-marriage-who-is-marrying-out/ http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2015/06/12/interracial-...
- patall 10y agoWhat shall be the "correlation vs. causation" error here? I mean, if you draw an analog here, it would mean that Chinese people could get children of any race but those would still pair up. The birds do not know which type they are but still pair up with the different morph, so its something intrinsic inherited from the genotype that influences the sexual phenotype.
- probablybroken 10y agoOr possibly that birds value reproductive success, and learn to mate with partners who can produce eggs from experience.
- Pitarou 10y ago
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- zoner 10y agoHi LGBT, this is how you get more than two sexes. Report back if one of you have it.
- sctb 10y agoThis kind of flamewar-style comment is not OK here. Please comment civilly and substantively or not at all. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- woliveirajr 10y ago> “This bird acts like it has four sexes," (...) Interesting to see that one phrase was changed to make the title more interesting, by nature.com.
- unclenoriega 10y agoSadly, that's the nature of journalism.
- erroneousfunk 10y agoWere you just saying that for the pun? Regardless, I wanted to point out that the title, while interesting, is hardly "click bait and switch." These birds DO have four sexes, from the point of view of their chromosomes, which results in behavioral differences between the four sexes, and produces birds that can only mate with a quarter of the entire population. The biologist that said the "these birds act like..." quote was not the author of the paper being discussed. Also, later on he says "...in a four-sex system, each bird must work that much harder to find a mate — a white female is not just looking for a male, she needs a tan one — so selection will favour a more advantageous two-sex system instead." So which is it? "A four-sex system" or something that "looks like a four sex system"? I think the article makes it pretty clear that it's the former. Also, from the article: "Some animals, such as reptiles, have two sexes and no sex chromosomes, whereas the freshwater protozoan Tetrahymena thermophila has seven sexes, each of which can mate with any type except its own. Two sexes with one set of sex chromosomes is the most common arrangement, and has evolved independently many times. But there's no reason a species can't have more sex chromosomes, Wilson Sayres says. “If you've got two genes linked together that can't cross over during meiosis, and one of them plays a role in sex determination, suddenly you can have a new sex chromosome.”" How is the title incorrect?
- unclenoriega 10y agoYes, I was. Sorry. Still, I do think there's an unfortunate amount of truth in my comment, even in the likely case that the parent is incorrect that it applies to this article.
- AWildDHHAppears 10y agoWell, according to Facebook, Humans have about 17 sexes.
- swsieber 10y agoThe tl;dr: The species has two chromosomes that act like sex chromosomes. That is to say, our Y chromosome never get's to mingle with other Y chromosomes, and so it accumulates mutations fairly quick, and thus a sex chromosome. In the bird species, there are 2 such chromosomes, and thus 4 unique states with regards to those unique chromosomes, as opposed to our 2 states. They are defining sex not through sexual organs, but through the chromosomal state.
- astrodust 10y agoIt's a very interesting combination of factors here, and they're also making the observation that this could be how the original XX/XY split occurred. Sexual genetics are actually a lot more complicated than people think. There are YY "supermale" people, though it's more common in fish which gender-flip depending on population balance leading to XY males breeding with XY females. A YY male will always produce male children. There's also XXY, XXXY and so on which is where things get even more complicated.
- Ericson2314 10y agoI wonder if they could recreate the original single inversion, and check the fertility of those.
- Pitarou 10y agoThere's something I don't get. Can someone explain to me what prevents a tan-striped male mating with a tan-striped female?