2 ms·
> it's not like anyone's skin is even on the line Huh? Then why spend money on it? If I told you there was voter fraud, but it was so small it didn't have a s
by paulddraper 10y ago
> it's not like anyone's skin is even on the line
Huh? Then why spend money on it?
If I told you there was voter fraud, but it was so small it didn't have a snowball's chance of changing the results even in a very close election, would you spend thousands legislating ironclad voting id laws?
I think either (1) there is a chance this changes the outcome or (2) this has a too low ROI to bother.
- paublyrne 10y agoIf it happens once then it can happen again and on a larger scale.
- paulddraper 10y agoAnd if it doesn't happen once, it can still happen on a larger scale. Either way, we'll still have to mitigate fraud/hacking in 2020.
- snowwrestler 10y agoIf we had tangible proof of manipulated votes--even at a very small scale--then: A) We would have "real-world" attack data to shape defenses against; and B) It would be a lot easier to make the case for resources to better secure the voting apparatus.
- scarmig 10y agoThere's obviously a world of difference between voter fraud--which happens some amount, but doesn't have a partisan lean--and a foreign state effectively pressing its thumbs on the scales to determine who's going to lead the USA. Even if Russia only hacked one state to give a couple thousand votes extra margin to an already winning candidate, that would be worth millions or billions of dollars to uncover. Luckily, this would only likely cost seven figures.
- anigbrowl 10y agoIf I told you there was voter fraud, but it was so small it didn't have a snowball's chance of changing the results even in a very close election, would you spend thousands legislating ironclad voting id laws? Well, the GOP has spent a great deal of political capital in several states insisting on rigorous ID requirements while claiming that voting by undocumented immigrants is a huge problem, and it's an article of faith on the right wing that vast numbers of foreigners are voting in US elections despite a dearth of evidence. Of course, these rigorous ID requirements (in combination with other policies) also have a significant tendency to disenfranchise legitimate voters, and many on the left argue that this is the real intention. Myself, I think voter ID is a good thing because it increases public confidence in elections - but that ID has to be easy for lawful voters to get and keep, and the Democratic party made a strategic mistake by opposing such laws strenuously while having no contingency plan to make sure that their supporters could maximize their chances of voting if direct opposition to voter ID laws failed. Voter ID laws are frequently unfair but you're better off having ID than getting locked out of the democratic process. If the Democratic party had invested more effort in helping people get ID than in fighting the ID requirements, they might have held the White House. The left suffers from a chronic weakness of being unable to set priorities; the obsession with fairness above all other considerations is incompatible with effective decision-making. This is why no country organizes its military forces democratically.