13 ms·
To Know If the Election Was Hacked, Look at the Ballots
- hackuser 10y agoI read and saw many assurances by IT experts that the election couldn't be hacked and wasn't hacked (said much too soon for them to know) but I never heard a convincing argument or an indication of a serious analysis. Can anyone here provide one? The only serious argument I heard was that it would be very complicated and expensive to hack so many local voting systems. However, certainly state-sponsored - and maybe other - attackers have the resources to do it, they can greatly reduce the cost by targeting only necessary systems (e.g. just a few voting systems in each swing state), they probably can find more ways to economize on a brute force attack, and most importantly: For them the massive return on investment - controlling who is the next President of the U.S., and possibly undermine confidence in U.S. political institutions - makes it worthwhile. It's arguably worth it to hack the machines, leave evidence, and not change the result I worry that in their rush to refute Trump's allegations of rigging, the experts opened the door to attackers by preemptively blocking investigations; they are now politically very difficult, they will cost the experts' reputations, and they may cause more uncertainty among the public than they resolve. The best security I can think of is deterrence: If they get caught, the attacker might be inviting a war with the U.S. But do Russia and China really feel threatened?
- umanwizard 10y agoWhat makes you think it would be Russia and China necessarily, as opposed to just internet trolls?
- hackuser 10y agoThat was a comment on the scenario the expert described, where such an operation would be "very complicated and expensive".
- dmurray 10y agoThat's one good argument against mass hacking: if it was as easy as it's being made out to be to manipulate the results, we should expect to see something obviously vandalized: a black county that voted 100% Trump, or a county where third party candidates get all the votes. > There’s no question that this is possible for technically sophisticated attackers. (If my Ph.D. students and I were criminals, I’m sure we could pull it off.) If anyone reasonably skilled is sufficiently motivated and willing to face the risk of getting caught, it’s happened already. Surely there's someone on 4chan who ticks those boxes. The motivation doesn't even have to be pure vandalism: it would be a very effective way to call attention to the vulnerabilities in the system.
- LoSboccacc 10y agowell, my to-go expert was writing about unreliability since unsuspecting times https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2004/11/the_problem_wit.html https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2004/11/the_problem_w... - don't know whom you listen to, but back in time when slashdot still had some content I recall a big fight between vendors and researches over source code auditing, which of curse after many lawsuites completed exposing many weakness in design, even before accounting for "honest" bugs, and even back then the whole business surrounding election automation was exceptionally shady.
- joshwa 10y agoFrom NYT Upshot's Nate Cohn: - "Metro Wisconsin, where Clinton did well, uses paper; rural Wisc, where she collapsed like everywhere, is electronic. https://www.verifiedvoting.org/verifier/#year/2016/state/55" https://www.verifiedvoting.org/verifier/#year/2016/state/55" https://twitter.com/Nate_Cohn/status/801217804783394816 https://twitter.com/Nate_Cohn/status/801217804783394816 - Remember it's not just Wisconsin here. 1. Michigan only uses optical scan. http://www.michigan.gov/sos/0,1607,7-127-1633_8716_45458---,00.html http://www.michigan.gov/sos/0,1607,7-127-1633_8716_45458---,... 2. The margin in PA is 65k votes. 65k. https://twitter.com/ForecasterEnten/status/801219149326385152 https://twitter.com/ForecasterEnten/status/80121914932638515... retweeted by @Nate_Cohn
- joshwa 10y agoAnd Nate Silver: - To follow: some _very_ quick analysis which suggests the claim here of rigged results in Wisconsin is probably BS: http://nym.ag/2gI6YLP http://nym.ag/2gI6YLP - Run a regression on Wisc. counties with >=50K people, and you find that Clinton improved more in counties with only paper ballots. HOWEVER: https://twitter.com/NateSilver538/status/801221546685661184/photo/1 https://twitter.com/NateSilver538/status/801221546685661184/... - ...the effect COMPLETELY DISAPPEARS once you control for race and education levels, the key factors in predicting vote shifts this year. https://twitter.com/NateSilver538/status/801221907609579520/photo/1 https://twitter.com/NateSilver538/status/801221907609579520/... https://twitter.com/NateSilver538/status/801220813890277376 https://twitter.com/NateSilver538/status/801220813890277376
- Natsu 10y agoNate has a full article here that's likely better than a few tweets for discussing something like this: http://fivethirtyeight.com/features/demographics-not-hacking-explain-the-election-results/ http://fivethirtyeight.com/features/demographics-not-hacking...
- hackuser 10y agoIf they have a serious argument backed by evidence, they should make it public. Hillary Clinton may have a personal concern about the issue but it's a very serious issue for all Americans (and the world). She shouldn't have a veto.
- whybroke 10y ago>She shouldn't have a veto. Absolutely. Regardless of how likely or unlikely manipulation is, an independent group should be able to request an audit. If for not other reason than she could be silenced by a tacitly threatening to endless prosecute and summon before congress on some unrelated matter if she makes any trouble.
- hackuser 10y ago> If for not other reason than she could be silenced by a tacitly threatening to endless prosecute and summon before congress on some unrelated matter if she makes any trouble. A very good point.
- stale2002 10y agoWould you say the same thing about the Democratic primary?
- whybroke 10y agoWhat a curious default view of humanity and reality.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- fbreduc 10y agothat was much less interesting than i thought it would be...
- waqf 10y agoThat was much more sane and reasonable than I thought it would be. Two sides of the same coin.
- fbreduc 10y agoWe've all known for quite some time that election system needs improvement, what's so different this time? Each and every election the losing side brings up the tampering bit, well yes if people cared enough, we should begin processes to make sure tampering election votes is extremely difficult to impossible. And maybe this is the beginning of real discussion, only problem is who will lead the effort, is this guy just another person with a megaphone? Also to say paper ballots cannot be tampered seems silly . Unless we know the exact procedure and check points in which they are handled, how they are stored and secured even after the win for case of recount (especially if tampering happens afterward and recount is the plan to which the coin lands on the other side). Hell maybe even down to the specific type of paper a ballot is printed with. And I like what someone else said, scan them in as well... have machine and human come to the same total. I expected the guy to have proof considering the hype around this, but I do appreciate he said it is unlikely the election was hacked...as if just to quiet those twitter echo chambers.
- HillaryBriss 10y agoI was excited to read this, thinking "Ok, finally! This is the shit -- the actual evidence that uncovers the actual conspiracy by a foreign government to elect Trump." Then I read this: > Were this year’s deviations from pre-election polls the results of a cyberattack? Probably not. I believe the most likely explanation is that the polls were systematically wrong, rather than that the election was hacked.
- rdhyee 10y agoHalderman continues though: "But I don’t believe that either one of these seemingly unlikely explanations is overwhelmingly more likely than the other."
- jfjejxjcjf 10y agoIt's amazing how people can mock the idea of subverting elections as long as it's not their candidate who lost. Many similar concerns were raised during the election by people who hold very different political views than most HN readers, and yet these concerns were written off and publicly mocked. Now the shoe is on the other foot but nobody is willing to point out the partisan hypocrisy. And yes, throwaway account because HN tends to get very uncivil about this subject.
- rdhyee 10y agoVerified Voting the non-partisan umbrella organization that connects many leading election technology experts (including Halderman the author of the piece; Ron Rivest and Philip Stark -- http://news.berkeley.edu/2016/11/22/election-hacking-audit/ http://news.berkeley.edu/2016/11/22/election-hacking-audit/) has been in the business of ensuring the integrity of the voting system since 2003. https://www.verifiedvoting.org/about-vvo/ https://www.verifiedvoting.org/about-vvo/
- tmaly 10y agoI was having a discussion about security of the voting systems with my neighbor from Germany. He was of the belief that the mechanical machines without computers were more secure. I like the type of machines we have in Connecticut. There is a paper ballot that is filled out and then scanned optically. We get a paper ballot that acts as an audit trail. There is always the possibility that the optical scanner contains a bug or something, but the 2000 election showed that even mechanical machines have flaws if not maintained. I would not prefer the touch screen voting machines as there are always reports of the machines switching the vote. It just seems like more can go wrong with those machines.
- nickbauman 10y agoThe voting machine's viability is all about how easily a layman can verify its correctness. This is why any mechanical voting machines are theoretically "better" because the layman can actually SEE it working correctly or not.
- akytt 10y agoHave you ever tried to inpelement a modified d'hont method manually? There are always computers involved. Counting hundreds thousands of votes manually will always yield an error that can be exploited. Voting as a concept has changed beyond what mr. Halderman is willing to admit. Let's say you have widespread electronic id and electronic voting. In isolation, this sounds mad. In conjunction with physical voting and common use of eid, not so much.
- oh_sigh 10y agoHow would one exploit a seemingly random error to favor a specific candidate over the other?
- admax88q 10y agoSeems harder to exploit manual counting of paper ballots than the firmware of some closed source system that's poorly understood by those deploying it. The larger the election, the more manual counters you will have. Which means the more people you would have to influence in order to rig an election.
- akeck 10y agoA (dystopian?) future? One's birth certificate includes a cryptographic certificate used to sign and validate everything related to one's interaction with the government (replaceable by some protocol as cryto tech changes over time). One's vote is signed. However, subway cards and automatic highway tolls are signed as well.
- kej 10y agoThis would enable both vote selling and tracking down the people who voted against you.
- waqf 10y agoNot if properly combined with other technologies. Cryptographically signed voting enables vote selling only in the same sense that requiring voters to present ID at the polling place already enables it.
- kej 10y agoDepends if you're signing the actual vote (Alice voted for Bob) or just their presence (Alice voted). I thought akeck was talking about the first one but you're right that the second one would not present the threats I mentioned.
- savanaly 10y ago>tracking down the people who voted against you. Tracking down every single vote against you, or just a large batch of them for retaliation? If it's the former, I can't really see the purpose. If it's the latter, you can do that today, people don't usually make a secret about who they vehemently hate in the presidential elections on facebook.
- sooheon 10y agoThe third option is tracking down a specific person who voted against you (and was paid to / promised to do otherwise).
- yosito 10y agoIt's mind boggling to me that we don't automatically check the paper trails of an election and do several counts to verify the results. How will democracy survive if our mechanisms for implementing it are so far behind the changing world?
- r00fus 10y agoWould you be more boggled to know that there are a few large voting machine companies, one of which (Diebold) has the CEO on record as handing the election to a specific candidate (which candidate? exercise left for reader).
- r_smart 10y agoI hadn't heard about this. Can you point me to a source? Are you talking about this year's election?
- mikestew 10y agoDon't bother, what parent most likely would link to is so taken out of context as to not be worth your time. Why do you think parent didn't post a link, and instead just made some vague statement? But if you insist: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Premier_Election_Solutions#O.27Dell.27s_fundraising https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Premier_Election_Solutions#O...
- r_smart 10y agoThanks for the link. I figure you're probably right, but you never know when someone is going to surprise you with something interesting. I try to give everyone a fair hearing if they care to put a decent argument together :)
- tptacek 10y agoIt's not OK for Trump supporters to take threads off on bogus ideological tangents about "questioning the election", and it's no better for people who don't approve of Republicans doing the same thing over the Diebold story. Please don't set fire to threads on HN with stuff like this?
- altendo 10y agoMy tongue-in-cheek solution: put the sysadmins in charge of voting machines. They'll make sure there are several backups, automate testing of all the machines, and an unwavering ambition to prevent data corruption and hacker intrusion. The heroes we need. Full disclaimer, I am a systems engineer :p
- waqf 10y agoHow is it tongue-in-cheek to suggest putting a professional with relevant experience in charge of critical national infrastructure? One of us has a misaligned Overton window.
- altendo 10y agoI didn't mean to say that we shouldn't have knowledgeable people handling our voting machines (as pretty much any election shows, we certainly do). I just imagined sysadmins across the country saying "screw it, I'm taking care of this" and abandoning their normal jobs to take care of it.
- rubyfan 10y agoTLDR: Were this year’s deviations from pre-election polls the results of a cyberattack? Probably not. I believe the most likely explanation is that the polls were systematically wrong, rather than that the election was hacked.
- rdhyee 10y agoFollowed immediately by "But I don’t believe that either one of these seemingly unlikely explanations is overwhelmingly more likely than the other."
- dang 10y agoThere have been several posts about this (e.g. [1] and [2]), downweighted by user flags and by standard penalties (e.g. for politics stories). But some thoughtful users have argued that it's more on-topic for HN than most politics, so we'll make an exception, even though HN probably ought to be in detox right now. Edit: actually there was already at least one major discussion about this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13019333 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13019333, so technically we ought to be marking all these as dupes. But we'll leave this one open for now. The moderation test in cases where there's an ongoing story and many follow-up posts is: have one major thread and bury the rest as dupes unless there's significant new information. 1. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13018675 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13018675 2. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13023998 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13023998
- cmdrfred 10y agoI don't know if Donald Trump is a tactical genius or surrounded in a cloud of luck. Remember when he said he wouldn't accept the election results if he lost and the outcry at his comments? Now all the pundits who question these results have tweets from a couple of weeks ago saying things like "You have to accept the result, that's how democracy works!" effectively invalidating their arguments today. If on purpose that is some Lannister level statecraft. You can down vote all you want. Game recognises game. You don't have to support someone for that.
- shortstuffsushi 10y agoTo be fair, (many of) those on the right thought Donald Trump was an idiot for saying he wouldn't accept the results, so it doesn't seem unfair for them to continue they're claiming "we won, leave it be" now. They would (likely) have asked Trump to do the same in the "we lost, leave it be" situation.
- cmdrfred 10y agoAgreed, but you also look rather hypocritical saying "The results are perfect don't question them!" and then a week later "I question the results." This reveals partisan hacks on both sides of the aisle.
- shortstuffsushi 10y agoThis reveals human nature on both sides ;) When you lose, it sucks, and you want to find a way to alter the results. When you win, it's great, and you don't want it taken away. I don't think this behavior is limited to politics.
- jstalin 10y agoHe didn't say he wouldn't accept the results. He said he would wait and see, you know, kinda like Bush v. Gore.
- cmdrfred 10y ago
- misterbowfinger 10y agoI kind of don't understand why we can't vote through a web app. You can deposit checks and buy stocks through your phone. Why can't you vote?
- Scea91 10y agoHow would you ensure that someone can't vote for another person? How would you ensure that the person is alone when she votes?
- jhatax 10y agoYour argument stands on tenuous ground because you just pointed out all the flaws that exist with "mail in" ballots. Did you know that states like Oregon only have mail in ballots? So, despite all the flaws that you point out, why are these legal but a mobile app is not?
- Scea91 10y agoI am actually from Europe so I don't know the specific details of your voting system. Mail-in ballots are of course a weakness, but it doesn't mean that we should further weaken the current system. Here in Czech Republic we receive voting tickets by mail about a week before election and have to physically put them into a box behing a curtain in a voting room. I also see weakness here, and don't understand why we receive voting tickets by mail, because it allows you family relatives filter your tickets. Better system would be if the voting tickets were available only in the voting room. Still it is better than web app. There are more security concerns with online voting, you can read more about it here: https://security.stackexchange.com/questions/15417/online-government-elections-system-is-it-possible https://security.stackexchange.com/questions/15417/online-go...
- anigbrowl 10y agoIt's worth remembering (for non-US residents) that US voters don't just vote on a few legislative and executive candidates, but on a very large number of them. The California voter information booklet about who is running and what issues the voters can express a preference on regularly runs to over 100 pages. A completed ballot can easily involve >50 different decisions - hence the ubiquity of machine counting in the USA.
- scarmig 10y agoElection results must be beyond doubt. Clinton, Trump, and all Americans have a shared interest in this. It seems unlikely for the result of the election to change even if one state was hacked, so it's not like anyone's skin is even on the line. Absolutely no one should doubt that Russia, and many other nations, have the capability to do what people are suggesting might have happened. The only question is whether they did, which would be almost unprecedented: the undermining of a mature democracy's electoral process by a foreign power would be a singular event. (Though, both the USA and Russia have done similar-ish things in the past, but often against immature democracies.) Russia has shown interest in destabilizing the USA's electoral system throughout the year. The only question is just how far they are willing to go. We have the capability to determine whether they did this time. We should exercise that capability: if we don't, it will encourage our enemies (and our friends!) to do so in the future, regardless of what happened in 2016.
- paulddraper 10y ago> it's not like anyone's skin is even on the line Huh? Then why spend money on it? If I told you there was voter fraud, but it was so small it didn't have a snowball's chance of changing the results even in a very close election, would you spend thousands legislating ironclad voting id laws? I think either (1) there is a chance this changes the outcome or (2) this has a too low ROI to bother.
- paublyrne 10y agoIf it happens once then it can happen again and on a larger scale.
- paulddraper 10y agoAnd if it doesn't happen once, it can still happen on a larger scale. Either way, we'll still have to mitigate fraud/hacking in 2020.
- snowwrestler 10y ago
- redthrowaway 10y agoI see we've moved from "Comey did it" to "fake news did it" to "the Russians did it". Eventually, I'm sure, we'll get to "we lost". Protip: the entire US intelligence community was on the lookout for Russian interference in the election. If they messed with enough voting machines to make a difference, NSA etc would know about it. Which means Obama and Congress would know about it. So either they're all conspiring to keep it secret from the American people, or it didn't happen.
- makomk 10y agoVia "voter ID laws did it", "Crosscheck did it", and a few other equally dubious theories, yes. See my comment in the other thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13021602 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13021602
- encoderer 10y agoSure, no way our intelligence community could ever mess something up as big as this... Remember 9/11? Iraq WMD?
- paganel 10y ago> Iraq WMD? I'm not an American, but I remember reading that there were (competent) people in the US intelligence services who had warned the powers-that-were that there were no conclusive proofs of WMD in Iraq. The issue was that the people in power didn't want to hear that from the intelligence services, so some other guys (they're mostly guys) from the intelligence services caught that hint and provided the desired "intelligence". Here's an article about it, concerning the CIA: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/06/24/AR2006062401081.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/06.... Here's another article about it, this time concerning MI6, https://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/mar/18/panorama-iraq-fresh-wmd-claims https://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/mar/18/panorama-iraq-... , where is mentioned that the French secret services had told the British that the WMD claim was bogus. I'm pretty sure that there were people inside the MI6 who also believed what the French were saying, but the higher-ups of course took the political decision of telling Blair what he wanted to hear.
- paulddraper 10y agoPollsters predicted reality incorrectly => Reality was hacked Man, those guys know how to spin the outcome.
- TheGirondin 10y agoDemocrats were right when they said the losers of this election would refuse to accept the results.
- forgetsusername 10y agoI also find this interesting: in the week leading up to the election, Trump was asked repeatedly, "If you lose, will you accept the results?", to which he said he'd have to assess the results at the time. He was roundly criticized for this.
- TheGirondin 10y agoDemocrats were right when they said the losers of this election would refuse to accept the results.
- TheGirondin 10y ago>Election results must be beyond doubt. It's been so interesting to see this turn of narrative after months "questioning the outcome of an election is undermining democracy." I wonder what happened between Sept-Oct and now that changed all that?
- scarmig 10y agoSo, your point of view is that concern about Russian hacking of the US electoral process is stupid, because people were also upset Trump suggested he might reject the outcome of a legitimate democratic processes?
- sakopov 10y agoI think the OP was just commenting about the irony of the situation and that at the end of the day everyone doubts the democratic election process.
- zo1 10y agoI think he's trying to point out the hypocrisy of the overall media-opinion on the matter before the results, vs now. I'd argue that people are a whole lot more "interested" or "curious" in the possibility of vote-manipulation or hacking now that the really unexpected candidate won. Hillary was a sort of "okay" result, yet Trump is, well I'm sure you've been reading HN and the rest of the internet.
- TheGirondin 10y agoNo, my point is that people should think their partisan rhetoric through, unless they want to put themselves into a position of being a complete hypocrite. But since you asked, yes, I do think these "concerns" about Russian hacking of the US electoral process are stupid and a thinly veiled attempt to undermine the legitimacy of the next President (which according to the rhetoric of many on left over the fall, is undermining to democracy itself).
- gdulli 10y agoTrump complained the system was rigged out of transparent demagoguery. He had no real facts, he had vague "dead people on the voter rolls" type claims because they sounded good. (People don't magically fade from the rolls when they die, there's a process and at any time it's normal and unavoidable for dead people to be on the rolls.) If (and only if) one party has actual evidence or data of rigging, it wouldn't be hypocritical for them to challenge the results after not taking Donald's whining during the campaign seriously. But it's academic, the results shouldn't be overturned. Even if it was found legitimate to give Hillary the win, it would make a martyr out of Donald and his movement would gain traction for 4 more years. The next 4 years are going to be ugly either because Donald is president or because half the country believes a conspiracy gave it to Hillary. One party or the other is going to be punished in 4 years. Better it should be Donald, let him fail and have his movement get put behind us for good.
- sakopov 10y agoHas everyone forgot about Wikileaks and its treasure trove of information about Clinton conspiring with DNC to drop Bernie Sanders out of the race? And that was just one of many things that were leaked. Why bother with malware when you can just dig up dirt on a candidate and release it to public? Don't get me wrong. I know Russia could do the hack but why would you bother with something so high-risk?
- godelski 10y agoWhy? To ensure your work pays off. Dirt will get you most of the way but hacking will be a safety net. Really you wouldn't have to infect many machines. The states that were listed (and a few more) you wouldn't need to change much to sway the vote. And if you were only attacking a few dozen machines in each state the risk wouldn't be too high. You do have privacy in the polling booth and from what I've seen most hacks would only really take like a minute. Not saying they did (I don't even think they did), but giving a reason why they might want to do that. Though I would like to hear the opinion of one of our HN security experts.
- ryuker16 10y agoTrump was estimated to lose big. If Latinos actually showed up like expected in Florida and Texas that election would be Clinton easily. It still blows my mind 95% of Latinos didn't vote against Trump. Russian hacking the ballot makes sense when your candidate is the dark horse
- jstalin 10y agoPerhaps the error is expecting all Latinos to act like a hive mind.
- tptacek 10y agoThis is a purely political argument that is entirely unrelated to the story, which is about the role computer science plays in the integrity of the ballot and is written by an authority on the topic. Injecting unrelated political drama into threads cruds them up with political arguments, and is a form of trolling. Please resist the urge next time?
- Kinnard 10y agoHalderman is a computer security professor at UofM: https://jhalderm.com/ https://jhalderm.com/
- agumonkey 10y agoMany people on twitter linked him to Watergate's Halderman.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dang 10y agoYes, that's mentioned at the top of the article. We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13024781 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13024781 and marked it off-topic.
- Kinnard 10y agoDoes the HN team have any plans to increase transparency on flagging. Maybe a way to view flagged stories and how many users are flagging them?
- yareally 10y agoI'm sure it's not your intention, but I read that question as "How can we make it easier for someone to game the system on hacker news?" Making it more transparent would probably not be a good thing.
- Kinnard 10y agoI'm surprised the value in transparency isn't obvious. I'll think more about how to convey my thoughts on it.
- dang 10y agoI doubt it. Anything that would lead to more meta litigation would be a disaster, and it's not clear what the gain would be. We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13024781 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13024781 and marked it off-topic.
- SixSigma 10y agoHere's Hillary Clinton's opinion of elections: “I do not think we should have pushed for an election in the Palestinian territories. I think that was a big mistake,” said Sen. Clinton. “And if we were going to push for an election, then we should have made sure that we did something to determine who was going to win.” http://observer.com/2016/10/2006-audio-emerges-of-hillary-clinton-proposing-rigging-palestine-election/ http://observer.com/2016/10/2006-audio-emerges-of-hillary-cl...
- ajross 10y agoThat's not "elections", it's specifically about one election, for an occupied territory without the capacity to self-govern. You can be a huge democracy zealot and still agree that the Hamas victory was a setback for Palestinian independence. I am, and do. Come on.
- tptacek 10y agoNone of this has anything to do with the article we're commenting on. Injecting volatile political arguments into unrelated threads is a form of trolling.
- ddingus 10y agoBy the way, can we now discuss South Carolina? Paperless touch screen voting there me and we have no idea who won any election. Completely unacceptable.
- shortstuffsushi 10y agoWhat does this comment mean? Are you saying that the results of the election are unclear in the state?
- ddingus 10y agoCompletely. There is absolutely no way to understand how the election result compares to voter intent. The record of that intent consists of smudges on dirty touch screens. We could come close to at least questioning with aggressive exit polling, but the real problem is no voter using those devices can ever understand their vote cast. They walked in and did something. That's all they really know.
- shortstuffsushi 10y agoThat really seems like a tin foil hat perspective. Sure, in the literal sense, there is no way for them to prove which way their vote was cast because it's managed by an opaque (for them) computer system, but the same is true if it were paper ballets that are handed over to a processing clerk. Once youve cast your vote, the collector "owns" the results, and their counting process is opaque in either case. And with that said, I don't think it's fair to ,
- shortstuffsushi 10y agoMy phone isn't working for some reason, second paragraph: I don't think it's fair to say that the intent of the voters is unclear unless you're wanting to entirely throw out the results of the electronically collected and processed votes as completely invalid. That seems extreme to me.
- helpfulanon 10y agoWhy does it have to be a foreign government hacking? An election tech worker or contractor with an agenda, could easily achieve the same results without having to go to the great lengths of breaking into the network using malware etc.
- dotnetisnotdead 10y agoI'm surprised to a see a professor of CS be so ruled by emotion. The Clinton team is likely to ignore this type of advice until actual evidence is shown. "I think she should have won" or "the polls all said.." is simply not good enough to overturn the entire process at this point.
- hackuser 10y agoWhat makes you say he is "ruled by emotion"? The article was nuanced, balanced, carefully reasoned and used unemotional language. > "I think she should have won" or "the polls all said.." Those aren't his arguments.
- novaleaf 10y agoIf you want a candidate to win, use the most effective hacking tool available: social engineering. As a bonus, it's legal! It might sound flippant, but I wouldn't be too surprised if the masterful politicians (in the USA or abroad) wouldn't consider illegal hacking just because it's too risky. Better to use shady-yet-legal tactics to shift opinions. The whole "fake news" issue seems like it could be a very smart campaign in this regard.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoI've wondered why the fake memes don't result in fines - they didn't identify who was responsible as all other political ads must do.
- matt_wulfeck 10y agoThat and freedom of speech is a protected and valued right in our democracy. If fake memes are wrecking your country maybe it's not the memes that are the problem?
- vehementi 10y agoAll citizens of high quality countries naturally just grew protection from propaganda, PR and psychological tricks, which evolved effortlessly for mass media/communication that reaches 100M people instantly. If that shit works on your "country", you probably need to see what's wrong with you people.
- kazga 10y ago> high quality countries Please define > protection from propaganda, PR and psychological tricks Yes, we here in Europe are blessed to represent the epitome of rational thought immune to all kinds of manipulation and fear-mongering. Alt-Right populism like the Front National, the Alternative für Deutschland and the UK Independence Party has no success here at all!
- hackuser 10y agoTL;DR Were this year’s deviations from pre-election polls the results of a cyberattack? Probably not. I believe the most likely explanation is that the polls were systematically wrong, rather than that the election was hacked. But I don’t believe that either one of these seemingly unlikely explanations is overwhelmingly more likely than the other. The only way to know whether a cyberattack changed the result is to closely examine the available physical evidence — paper ballots and voting equipment in critical states like Wisconsin, Michigan, and Pennsylvania. He goes on to give an overview of voting machines' vulnerability and methods for resolving the problem.