3 ms·
It seems Chomsky has had to back down on quite a bit of what UG should mean, for example suggesting that individual pieces can go unused in particular languages
by schoen 10y ago
It seems Chomsky has had to back down on quite a bit of what UG should mean, for example suggesting that individual pieces can go unused in particular languages and language learners.
One interesting thing that might still be left is criteria about what languages would be learnable or unlearnable. For example, perhaps there are reasons that it's impossible for human beings to become fluent in a conlang like Ithkuil (or Lojban), even if they were exposed as children to interactions with (hypothetical) fluent speakers. Yet this isn't true of Esperanto (or at least very slightly creolized versions of it), which does have native speakers for whom the language didn't seem to present any challenge. There could be criteria about what makes a language too weird or too hard to learn and speak with the facility with which all existing natural languages can be learned and spoken by almost all children; maybe some of those criteria are fuzzy but others are firm. I think this is related to UG, but clearly a weaker concept.