5 ms·
I don't much care whether it's aloe. The real question, I think, is whether the substitute product (maltodextrin) works the way aloe works, to solve the same pr
by derefr 10y ago
I don't much care whether it's aloe. The real question, I think, is whether the substitute product (maltodextrin) works the way aloe works, to solve the same problem aloe solves. If it does, and it's cheaper to stick in a bottle, then I'm all for it. If it doesn't, then it's a problem.
When you buy "aloe extract" in the cosmetics aisle, you're not buying it for its particular organochemical structure (unless you're planning to spread it on toast); you're buying it for the effect it has. You're looking for a chemical that supports aloe's API contract for its interaction with your own biophysiology. You're looking for, essentially, an "IAloe".
This is the problem with a lot of organic->synthetic transitions: people know the effect by the name of the organic substance that produces it, and thus, to get any mind-share, you have to market the synthetic by making it appear similar to the organic. Pure synthetic capsaicin is still marketed as "Ghost Chili oil" or similar, because people don't know or expect "capsaicin" to be spicy, but they do expect chili peppers to be.
Really, it's a miracle (of a mega-conglomerate marketing machine) that aspirin isn't just called "willow bark extract."
---
ETA: okay, apparently people are really very upset by the idea that a company "lying" about a product could be okay.
Every company that produces a product that isn't under government mandate to be a certain way, lies about everything they can get away with! That is the world we live in. 90% of products on the market are this way. You should not believe a single ingredients list if a product isn't in the FDA-regulated classes of "food" or "drugs." Most products outside of these categories don't even bother to have ingredients lists; this should tell you everything you need to know about the incentives that caused the products that do to put one on there anyway.
When I say "I'm okay with this", I mean that "I can deal with this, because I was already dealing with this in every purchasing decision I make, and this doesn't change anything." Everything on a drug-store shelf other than the actual FDA-regulated "drugs" are unadulterated bullshit that you have to comb through yourself to verify claims.
Guess what? That's the optimum! Empowering the FDA to fact-check the labelling claims of every single product would cost insane amounts of money, slow the whole economy down to the glacial FDA-approval pace of the pharmaceutical industry.
I'm okay with the world being this way, because all alternative worlds (reachable via anything less than a complete restructuring of government and maybe the human psyche) are worse.
- lutorm 10y agoSo you're all for falsely stating that something is in the product if it's not, as long as the company thinks it's sorta the same thing? Or do you mean like generic drugs say "compare to the active ingredient in Tylenol(tm)"? I'm all for the latter, the former is just fraudulent.
- derefr 10y agoSee my sibling comment. Lying is a problem with drugs—that we solved by creating the FDA—because drugs contain things that can hurt people when people take them who shouldn't be taking them. We classify everything with such ingredients—"active" ingredients—as a drug. Nothing that's not a drug is allowed to have any "active" ingredients; only "generally recognized as safe" ingredients. It would be a public health problem to lie and say that something is acetaminophen when it isn't, and would also be a problem to lie and say that something isn't acetaminophen when it really is. Both would hurt people. Lying about whether something contains the chemical compound "aloe vera" hurts (in the literal health sense of "hurts") no single human being. Therefore, it's not illegal. It might be bad behaviour, but so is 90% of advertising. It's not particularly worse than e.g. orange juice that says it's "made from real oranges" when it's really made from a mixture of extracts distilled from oranges. Again, as I said in my sibling comment: the only real "simple" thing that would make this better is to disallow the non-FDA-regulated product classes (things other than "food" and "drugs") from making ingredients claims at all, since nobody's checking them anyway. That'd interact in really strange ways with product names that are simply ingredient descriptions—as in this case—but using phrasing as in your example would probably give them an out.
- ebbv 10y agoThe issue is false advertising. It doesn't matter if it works the same (according to whatever tests that are testing for whatever criteria that I might not share) if it's not what you were advertising and what I bought. Allowing companies to advertise X but really sell Y because "testing says they work the same" is not a good idea. Very quickly artificial tests can be created that prove anything you want. Pyrite works the same as gold for being shiny and yellow according to my tests!