3 ms·
There's plenty of room for other Facebooks. In fact, there are major competitors to the likes of Facebook & Linkedin & Google. They just happen to be national
by user5994461 10y ago
There's plenty of room for other Facebooks. In fact, there are major competitors to the likes of Facebook & Linkedin & Google.
They just happen to be national companies (russia, china, some european).
If anything. The thought that they have no competitors/alternatives is just a display that SV totally ignore the local non-english competitors (no matter how engrained they are in their market) and generally disregards anything that is under 1 billion unique users.
- gordon_freeman 10y agoI think Facebook acknowledges that they have competitors in china such as weibo,renren and wechat. That's the reason Mark Zuckerberg visits China so frequently to persuade chinese govt in allowing facebook access there to gain that enormous market share.
- brianwawok 10y agoThis is only for ad base products. Tesla has far under a billion users and SV loves it. Many b2b startups have a few hundred to thousand users. If you want to sell Ads and be free, you need billions. If you have an actual product you charge money for, you need far less.
- lacampbell 10y agoWhat if you want to sell users data? Isn't that what most free web and mobile apps are really selling? I have a lot of great software ideas (great in that I wish they existed and want to use them), but no clue which could actually be monetized effectively. Billions of users seems like a tall order, and not a sensible thing to pursue.
- brianwawok 10y agoEasiest is b2b. Are any of your ideas something a business would pay to use? Start with a product that cost say $50-$500 per month. Much easier to sell 100 copies of something than get 100 million people to use your software.
- tsunamifury 10y agoSilicon Valley (or at least the large corps) is very aware of the regionalization of software adoption. Its simply that how success is defined for them is by, as you said, large numbers that often require something larger than small regions. One of the difficulties of SV is that several people have made the "Facebook for Brazil" or the "X for Y region" but over long term iteration, the regionalized product gets overtaken by a supra-regional product's momentum.
- madgar 10y agoGoogle had Orkut which was famously very popular in Brazil and India. Network effects couldn't sustain them when Facebook successfully went global and mobile.
- eloff 10y agoActually I think these mostly succeed against Facebook where governments create an artificial environment by blocking Facebook. Perhaps the most successful of the social networks that competed against Facebook on even terms was Orkut, and it's gone now. Markets with strong network effects, like social networks, tend to be winner takes all. You'll never upset the market leader by making a marginally better product. If it's not 10 times better AND can't be copied by the leader you've got no chance really. If Facebook is replaced it will be by people shifting to a different paradigm, not to an incrementally modified version of the same thing.